Never mind the culture stuff; what about the sex?


Mira NairAt the Indo-American Arts Council Film Festival last week, Mira Nair discussed her new film The Namesake. Peter Herbst, Editor-in-Chief of Premiere, wondered whether the nude scene is “chaste” enough for Indian censors.

She wasn’t very amused by the question; more importantly, she’s not amused that Bollywood films are allowed to be so racy, while non-Bollywood films are not. But I think that’s sort of like comparing Desperate Housewives to… oh, anything else.

I read The Namesake recently, and it’s a beautiful book. And although it’s about all kinds of awakening, sexual and otherwise, I can’t imagine there’d be anything racy or provocative in it, unless the movie takes great poetic license.

But I guess you can’t really blame Herbst for asking: After all, Indian censors — not to mention Indian audiences — are rather vocal sometimes. Remember the violent responses to Deepa Mehta’s films Fire and Water?

On the other hand, maybe you can blame Herbst for asking. I mean, take a sweeping story that travels between New York and Calcutta and among several generations, and ask about the sex scene. Whatever.

For more, check out the BBC article on Mira Nair.

More you may like