Archive

Review of “Drifting Flowers”

Drifting Flowers is out Taiwanese director Zero Chou’s latest effort. Far different from the sexy, tantalizing Spider Lilies, Drifting Flowers is a mood piece and a simple take on the (ever-so-fashionable) multiple-thread storyline. The film follows three branching storylines about lesbian characters, each examining a different kind of love.

In the first segment, we follow young Meigo (Pai Chih-ying) and her 20-something sister, Ging (Serena Fang). Ging is blind and earns a living as a lounge singer; Meigo follows her around to shows and falls asleep doing homework every night. Everything is shaken up – albeit rather gently – when the handsome, androgynous accordionist Diego (though everyone calls her Chalkie, played by Chao Yi-lan) comes along and accompanies Ging at her shows.

Meigo develops a massive crush on Chalkie, and Meigo becomes incredible jealous when she realizes that Ging and Chalkie are more than friends.

Serena Fang (left) with Chao Yi-lan

It’s interesting and important to note Ging’s role as her sister’s guardian – and the pressure she faces from others in the community to let Meigo live with a foster family. Meigo spends a great deal of time with a local family, who would rather see the child grow up with them than Ging (and the influence of her “lifestyle”).

The theme of familial/societal pressure rings throughout the film and informs most of the characters’ motivations.

The middle storyline is the most melancholy, depicting Lily, an aging Alzheimer’s patient (Lu Yi-ching) and her “beard” husband Yen (Sam Wang), himself a gay man, who has returned after years of neglect from his own cheating boyfriend. Lily regards Yen as “Ocean,” her long-lost love – and often relapses into memories of their time together.

Emotionally broken and HIV positive, Yen has no desire to stay with this old woman – or go on with life – but the pair eventually stumble onto a way to take care of each other, and form a sort of friendship and love that is rarely explored in film.

Lu Yi-ching

Finally, the third segment takes us into Chalkie’s past, depicting a young woman who is uncomfortable with her body and her feelings toward girls. She works at the family’s troupe (sort of like a mobile performance group, with puppet shows, singing, etc.), and she bounces around with a vibrant, adolescent energy, despite her gender-expression issues.

She eventually falls for the sexy singer at a rival troupe, and begins to contemplate life on her own.

The film moves through these storylines with a very gentle, moody rhythm, not unlike the “drifting flowers” of the title. Since its core theme is the many permutations of love, and the film plays out with a dreamy, languid pace, the entire affair feels a bit hazy and imprecise.

This is actually one of the movie’s greatest strengths, as each scene hits the emotional high notes and captures quiet moments with equal aplomb.

There are no real moments of “connection” among the threads, aside from a few arty sequences depicting the various characters riding the same train. The film begins and ends with these shots, and intermixed throughout are scenes of the main characters rubbing elbows and staring off into space within the car.

One wonders if this is a deeper metaphor, or simply a visual transition from one tale to another.

Truly the most original and interesting sequence is the middle, which first shows us the sham wedding between Lily and Yen in their younger, happier days, when each has a gay lover and a mutual understanding of their relationship; and later in life, when they come together again, broken, sick and alone.

The ways in which they compromise for one another is truly touching – it’s as if they’ve found solace in each other, long after the initial promise of “have your cake and eat it too” has faded away. Yen cross-dresses for Lily, making it more believable that he is Ocean. Lily cares for Yen and his disease, offering support and solace.

The first segment is nearly as good, offering a family melodrama framed through the eyes of a child, and it truly nails the cauldron of emotions associated with a first crush. Meigo is an adorable, precocious kid, and Ging is clearly doing her best to support them, but the pressure from others and guilt about her “lifestyle” are crippling.

Serena Fang (left) with Pai Chih-ying

Ging is a very sympathetic character, and Fang plays her with absolute honesty and fragility in what is one of the film’s best performances.

Yi-lan is also excellent in her two sequences, portraying adolescent angst and an assured, if unconventional, musician/lover later on.

Ironically, the sequence about the most interesting character is the least dramatically balanced and original. While Chalkie herself is a very likeable person – and generally fun to watch – her storyline is so clichéd and overdone that it takes away a bit of the film’s magic. It’s essentially a coming-out story, and while the tones of family responsibility and expectation ring just as loud as they do in the other sequences, it’s still a tired plotline.

Chao Yi-lan

This occasional tendency to dip into cliché is Drifting Flowers’ greatest shortcoming.

The characters are two-dimensional, and more than a few stereotypes are visited before the credits roll. This is unfortunate, as the script really calls for a character-driven piece – viewers will find themselves wanting much more in terms of character detail, and many will be frustrated by the broad strokes of the storytelling. Similarly, the acting is very hit-or-miss, with some actors giving nuanced performances (the aforementioned Fang and Yi-lan are excellent), and others over-acting to the point of melodrama.

It’s not the most polished affair in the world, but Drifting Flowers has an undeniable, dreamlike charm. Director Zero Chou is still refining her voice and her vision, though the film is certainly evidence that she’s on the right track.

The film is worth watching for it’s portrayal of still-forbidden love and the compromises that surround it in a culture that is decidedly underrepresented in the lesbian oeuvre (modern China), and for its well-paced storytelling.

Watch the trailer for Drifting Flowers:

Lesbian Apparel and Accessories Gay All Day sweatshirt -- AE exclusive

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Back to top button