Welcome to AfterEllen.com!

Enter your AfterEllen.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Lesbian and Bisexual women in Entertainment and the Media

Ellen Page or Kristen Stewart?

Hi, i heard that there are rumors about they being gay, also, occasionally many people have compared both of them to Jodie Foster. All these make me fantasising about what would happen if they were in our team. I'm curious to know that who would you pick to be your girlfriend, ellen or kristen? and the reasons behind.

I personally will go for kristen, firstly, she is my type lol, secondly, ellen is abit too tomboylish to me, she wears men clothes (really men men clothes!) too often. Yet, she is still very charming to me and i like her alot, just not in the girlfriend aspect.

p.s  i have a strong feeling that ellen is very very very likely to be gay, its like 80-90% when kristen is 50/50


brightClik5's picture

Hard Choice

It's a hard choice, but i think i'd go with Ellen Page.  I like her style.  I think she's adorable, and from DVD commentaries and stuff that i've listened to...she seems smart and she's pretty funny.  plus, i've always enjoyed the movies that she's chosen to do. 

ash's picture

Kristen Stewart

It is difficult because they are both very beautiful in thier own ways.

But deffinetly Kristen because I just honestly think she is basically the hottest woman walking the planet.....

taking nothing away from Ellen though she is pretty darn cute

Angie 's picture

Ellen Page

She seems like a lot of fun, and also smart. She has good taste in the rolls she chooses. I really like the way she dresses too.

tracey's picture

Ellen Page

my girlfriend is totally in love with her.  watches all her movies...
Paperback-Writer's picture

I think dating Ellen Page

I think dating Ellen Page would be a little too weird. It would be like dating myself (from what friends have said).

Plus, Kristen is taller (i like tallness), and she is still pretty androgynous (when they aren't dressing her up), and her voice is waaaaay sexier =)

I'd have to go with Kristen. If I was able to sit through In The Land Of Women and The Messengers to watch her, that says something.

Imo's picture

Ellen all the way. She's

Ellen all the way.

She's gorgeous. And likes The Moldy Peaches. End of :D

sarcasticallyawesome's picture

Ellen Page

She is seriously cute and she seems pretty smart, funny and sweet. And she's Canadian, which makes her even more awesome... xD
a_l_y_s_s_a's picture

wow

tough one right there. I'd go for Ellen BUT she has such a childish face that i wonder if that face will remain like that when she's older lol Kristen is much more attractive in the sexual way (my way of saying sexy) while Ellen is cute. Usually i do go for the cute ones but Ellen doesn't quite cut it. I'd most likely have a crush on her if we were to ever be friends but that's about it lol.
i want an athlete!'s picture

Kristen Stewart

I mean, I love Ellen Page to death, I have so much respect for her still being herself no matter all the fuss, dressing the way she wants to and taking interesting rather than well-paying roles. 

But Kristen Stewart is just hot... and sexiness beats all :)

Paperback-Writer's picture

Yeah, but that's the appeal

Yeah, but that's the appeal of Kristen. She's the mysterious silent type =D

I babble enough as it is. I usually like being just friends with other fellow babblers.

loving-the-pink's picture

Kristen Stewart

Its definantly 100% Kristen 'lick me' Stewart.

Unbelieveably hot! I even went to see a film about bloody vampires cos of her!

bubble_perfect's picture

Wow that's a hard choice...

I like them both lol.

Kristen's got that voice... I know most of my friends accuse her of being monotoned but like paperback said, I find it kind of sexy lol. Although I think she'd intimidate me a bit. Dunno why.

I think Ellen seems more likeable. And she is very gorgeous. Yeh I'll stick with her lol.

Carone's picture

I like ellen page but

I like ellen page but Kristen is hotter.
Joan's picture

Now this is probably the hardest question i had to answer Lol

i love them both so much and they are pretty much different from each other! and because of that if ever i had a chance i'll make them both my girlfriends lol!

this is just too hard for me to answer i mean Ellen is so darn cute and smart, then there's Kristen who makes me drool everytime i see her! heck i can make time for both of them haha

Hey_Lloyd's picture

Kristen Stewart

I love love love both Ellen and Kristen.

BUT, I'm currently crazy about Kristen and she's damn fine.

Melissa Hsu's picture

KS or EP

Yeah so I'm editing my comment bc I watched Juno again last night and so I don't know which one I'd like more. They both are beautiful and seem pretty cool to me.

Jen's picture

KRISTEN

I would definately go for Kristen. She is totally my celebrity crush. Not only is she gorgeous in a unique way (I'm so over what is thought of as "traditional" beauty), she isn't afraid to go against the grain and be who she is, regardless of what people say about her. I love her style and her choice in roles, and though I sincerely doubt she is bi or lesbian *sigh*, I would still ask her out. I'll bet there's an amazing person beneath all that loveliness.

 

MisDeeds's picture

ellen page just cause she

ellen page just cause she won't shoot daggers out of her eyes and stare me to death.
Jen's picture

Hahaha true, true

Hahaha true, true
Lindsay (Scout)'s picture

Ellen. I decided not to

Ellen. I decided not to give reasons why because...I'd babble.

Kristen is most def a hot, amazing girl as well though. She just can't compare to Ellen.

lwrdTalice's picture

Hell yeah!

I agree 100% with that! Kristen Stewart is hot, but I would SO go for Ellen she's hot, funny, smart and cute plus I love androgynous girls!
Zee's picture

ELLEN PAGEE

I love her tomboy-ness, it's so adorable!! And she can DEF. pull off the guy clothes. hot. AND her acting's quite good!! And she just seem awesomee. Yeah, so ellen page hands down. I don't know anything about Kristen Stewart. 
Kelster's picture

ellen page

mhhhhmm ellen is just so yummy

i mean kristen is cute, but ellen has that mhhm factor to her.

 

elladee's picture

in your pic you like a

in your pic

you like a lil like ellen there   =D

------------------
Don't lose your grip on the dreams of the past.
You must fight just to keep them alive.

IT'S THE EYE OF THE TIGER; IT'S THE CREAM OF THE FIGHT !!

... lol

ScottishLassie's picture

Tough choice

I would have to go for Kristen Stewart, because she is hot.  I love Ellen as well but theres just something so damn sexy about Kristen.
Baby_Bridgets_Bitch's picture

I'd go at them both...at

I'd go at them both...at the same time...with some sort of condiment present. 

"Honey, have you been eating meat?"
"What!? No! Ofcorse not. Why do you ask?"
"Because your...burger doesn't taste very...vaggie veggie"

Lex's picture

Ellen ellen ellen ellennnnn!

Ellen ellen ellen ellennnnn! I'm so obsessed. Shes cute, and you can tell she's funny from her interviews and things... mhmm
remolive's picture

omg kristen no contest

kristen...nuff said
Morfina's picture

¡Elena Página!

Ellen is just my crush since (i hate to say it) Juno, she would be my perfect girlfriend: Canadian, incredibly cute, smart with a great sense of humour and a bit of ambiguous sensuality.

 That pretty much describes it all i think of her.

Mz. Understood's picture

Kristen Stewart

shes the only reason i watched Twilight, lol. 

 

_____________________ 

"No matter what a woman looks like, if she's confident, she's sexy" - ParisHilton♥

Pokerface's picture

Haha

Seriously, when I watched the movie all of the girls were "omg edward he's so hot. " all I could respond was "Edward who?" Nuff said"B* I don't know your life!"
Sky31's picture

Ahahaha.. me too! While all

Ahahaha.. me too! While all my friends were drooling over Ed, I sat there in silence concentrating on watching her and her beauty! XDD
Pokerface's picture

EP

Ellen page anytime , any day. She looks really laid back and just all around awesome. Sure kristen is hot, but i'll take ellen's cuteness over anything. Btw, where are the rumours that kristen may be gay coming from? This is the first time I've heard them and from I know, she has a boyfriend. "B* I don't know your life!"
Morfina's picture

Yeah, she has a boyfriend...

 

And he is the guy who was Jacks son on Will & Grace, he looks very different now. But yeah! i heard those rumors too, i don´t know remember where or when but definitively i can feel a little Gay vibe from Kristen. 

Ashie's picture

3 some

Is that too much to ask?

lol

I am way to much like Ellen it would be like having sex with my self. But Kristen Bada Bing Bada Boom get in my room. lol

 

Love And Let Love.

Ashie's picture

3 some

Is that too much to ask?

lol

I am way to much like Ellen it would be like having sex with my self. But Kristen Bada Bing Bada Boom get in my room. lol

 

Love And Let Love.

Ashie's picture

3 some

Is that too much to ask?

lol

I am way to much like Ellen it would be like having sex with my self. But Kristen Bada Bing Bada Boom get in my room. lol

 

Love And Let Love.

kimi's picture

ellen page

even if shes tomboyish, shes soooooooooo my pick!

 

btw she looks good in tuxedos!

Wandering_Heart's picture

IDK they are Both SUPER

IDK they are Both SUPER HOTT!!! I think Kristen is really sexy, but I wasn't too crazy about her acting in Twilight... that might just be because i was so in love with the book though lol and no movie is even close to as good as the books =P

Ellen Page is really amazing to but over all I am going to choose Kristen, SHE MAKES ME WEAK AT THE KNEES!!! =D (thank god im sitting down!!!) =P

AClosetCase:x's picture

ELLEN PAGE! <3

FER SUREZ. haha. i wouldn't say i have a type, but i just really like ellen, A LOT. like her whole personality, looks and everything. :D

am i the only one who thinks ellen page is (not just cute) but HOT?

BerryHead's picture

ME ME

ME ME ME!

Ellen Page is a GIANT hottie!
she's awesome in every way possible ><
Angie 's picture

Ellen Page

She is definitely hot.

"Life... is like a grapefruit. It's orange and squishy, and has a few pips in it, and some folks have half a one for breakfast." Douglas Adams

psyco's picture

Ellen Page with no doubt!!!

She is sooo beautyful, smart, sexy, bad ass actress, smart, tomboish (I love that in her) I can keep going and going. She looks so hot in her cloths... damn now I need a cold shower hehe.

Melissa Hsu's picture

Kristennnnn

Kristen freaking Stewart!

how she constantly runs her hands through her hair.. god damn

 

But I have to admit listening to her is painful

but when she's high its fine lol

eki's picture

Kristen Stewart. Totally.

Kristen Stewart. Totally. She's hot, and... she's hot... umm... :)
BreLark's picture

What a question

This had actually occurred to me and I decided to write a blog about it at http://krikki-watch.blogspot.com It isn't up quite yet but soon!
Erika's picture

Ellen Page

She's really cute and talented.  Kristen is cute (not as much as Ellen) and talented too but she scares me a little.

--------

"Great.  Not only do I feel creepy but now I look like I'm 1,000 and that I've been smoking meth all my life." -Sara Quin

Devin's picture

my head jus exploded

both... impossible decision.
andy andrea's picture

yah ellen

i alsohave a feeling that ellen page is gay.... like i can feel FEEL it.. hehehe

 

xoxo,

andy

Erin's picture

ms. stewart

hmm... kristen id have to say hands down. but that picture that someone posted of ellen just made me rethink my decision.. beautiful picture of her. but im going to stick with my initial choice of kristen.