Welcome to AfterEllen.com!

Enter your AfterEllen.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Lesbian and Bisexual women in Entertainment and the Media

Your Top 5 crushes on women in entertainment

I am interested to know and plus its fun, who are everyone's top 5 crushes from women in entertainment and they have to have some kind of gay/bi/queer connection. I'll list my own to start (keep in mind it's current, it changes from time to time):

1. Bridget McManus (lesbo)

2. Jill Bennet (lesbo)

3. Carly Pope (from Itty Bitty Titty and from Dirt)

4. Sarah Michelle Gellar (girl on girl kiss in Cruel Intentions)

5. Laura Sanchez (plays a lesbian on Los Hombres de Paco)

(lol, can u tell I like femmes?)


blooddrivendream's picture

mine

1. Shirley Manson (lead singer of Garbage. She says she has a lot of female groupies but that is about it for queer connection)

2. Rosario Dawson (she is in RENT- she plays the straight girl but looks far too good in fish-nets not to mention)

3. Kate Moennig (the L word)

4. Amanda Palmer (bi front-women of the Dresden Dolls, who played on the True Colours Tour)

5. Jessika (lead singer of Jack off Jill and Sarling, I am not possitive but I think she is bi) 

honourable mentions: Kiyomi McCloskey (of Hunter Valentine), Ellen Page, etc.

The only pattern I see is a fondness for lead singers of rock groups and the red head brunette alternating pattern.

 

Wil_08's picture

my faves

1. Gabrielle Christian (South of Nowhere)

2. Piper Perabo (Imagine Me & You, Lost & Delirious)

3. Sheetal Sheth ( The World Unseen, I Can't Think Straight)

4. Mandy Musgrave ( Southof Nowhere)

5. Angelina Jolie (GIA)

 

 

Rachel452's picture

1. Liz Vassey (Nikki &

1. Liz Vassey (Nikki & Nora, 3Way)

2.Christina Cox (Better Than Chocolate, Nikki & Nora, 3Way)

3. Jill Bennett (duh)

4. Kate Walsh (hmm...loved by the ladies...)

5. hmmm as for the last one I'll say Portia De Rossi today, just because she is so talented and beautiful and getting married to my favorite funny lady very soon!

Sthrnmiss's picture

1.  Portia De Rossi - I

1.  Portia De Rossi - I don't think she needs any explanation

2.  Brandi Carlile - someone told me she was a lesbian...if not, she's still hot!

3.  Katy Perry - She does sing that song.

4.  Erin Daniels - From The L Word...gay or not!

5.  Ellen Degeneres - Just because she is so funny.

madmaxip's picture

1. Kristin Chenoweth

 

1. Kristin Chenoweth ( Annette Bening's Lesbian Lover in Running with Scissors. Also on Sept.13, she'll receive a Point Foundation's Point of Courage Award for her advocacy for Gay Rights.)

2. Lucy Lawless ( does Xena Count)

3. Renee O'Connor ( Xena's Girlfriend)

4. Evan Rachel Wood ( Once and Again - kissing Mischa Barton , and Pretty Persuasion - Going down on Jane Krakowski )

5. Naomi Watts ( Mulholland Dr. and Ellie Parker)

Viva's picture

Lena Headey Jennifer

Lena Headey

Jennifer Beals

Gloria Bigelow

Elizabeth Berkley

DJ Kathy Valenti

Dolores Hot Tamales's picture

let's see

Lisa Ray in I can't think straight

Mia Kirschner in all of her bisexual roles

Ashley Judd as Tina Modotti in Frida

Ana de la Reguera

Kim Stolz

_____________________________________________

I'll google your yahoo if youtube myspace

chicky's picture

this is easy

Lena Headey - Imagine me & you:)

Missy Higgins - singer/songwriter

Amanda Moore - the model

Sarah Shahi - need I say more?

Nicole Scherzinger - the pussycat dolls

Candice's picture

Britney Spears... is said

Britney Spears... is said to have slept with girls.

Rosario Dawson... she's in RENT, a gay/lesbian movie.

Keira Knightley... was rumored to be a lesbian for a minute, and Domino is a little gay.

Penelope Cruz... has kissed a couple girls in movies.

Mia Kirshner.

LT's picture

lena headey  jennifer

lena headey 

jennifer beals 

karina lombard

alex hedison

kate walsh 

LT's picture

lena headey  jennifer

lena headey 

jennifer beals 

karina lombard

alex hedison

kate walsh 

melissa's picture

amy lee

 amy lee          she can sing to me anyday

 angelina jolie          i liked her since i seen her in foxfire

 lindsey lohan       im not really into red heads but ill make an exception for her

 its a tie between lena and yulia       t.A.T.u.

 jill bennett        i love love love her ears and her eyes

 holly marie combs        piper thats all i have to say

  

 

Im not crazy, my reality is just different then yours.

Jade's picture

My List:

  1. Olivia Wilde
  2. Yvonne Strahovski
  3. Ali Larter
  4. Tina Fey
  5. Sara Ramirez
frosch411's picture

5 Celebrity crushes ...well here you go!

In no particular order...

 

Laurel Holloman

 

Rachel Shelley

 

Romy Schneider

 

Jodhi May

 

Ludivine Sagnier wasn't really a crush but she's nice eyecandy ;D

 

--------------------------------------------------------------------

frosch411 online   Voogles

ForTheLoveOfFire's picture

in no particular order 

in no particular order 

Ellen Page

Keira Knightly 

Kate Moennig 

Tegan Quin 

Lisa Marx
strict machine's picture

hmm

liz feldman - where are you liz?
laurel hollowman
jennifer beals
sarah shahi
rhadha mitchett from high art
god that was hard to limit it to 5 
 
 
 
 
 
i bet that you look good on the dancefloor 
maclay's picture

Easy!

1. Lucy Lawless (Xena - So gay!)

2. Renee O'Connor (Gabrielle - also considerably gay)

3. Jemima Rooper (Thelma in Hex - Gay AND a ghost)

4. Bridget McManus ('nuff said)

5. Jill Bennett (I just watched Dante's Cove Season 3 ;P)

Wait, am I only allowed five...?

Anonymous's picture

no particular order

my top 5 always changing everyday, but so far its

Leighton Meester

Gabrielle Christian

Portia de Rossi

Blake Lively

Delta Goodrem

 

Nat2008's picture

5 Celebrity Crushes

1) Sara Ramirez

2)Kate Walsh

3)Kate Beckinsale

4) Angelina Jolie

5)Mary-Louise Parker (loved her since Fried Green Tomatoes)

Here it is for now... 

 

riotgrrrljaz's picture

5 only?! thats hard but it'll be...

1) Bridget McManus (professional lesbo) =)

2) Erin Daniels (duh! big ol' lesbo in the L word, love her smile!)

3) Jordana Brewster (fell for her in DEBS)

4) Angelina Jolie (i know it's so cliche, but i don't care cuz she is hot!)

5) tie between:  Jill Bennet (big ol' lesbo), Lena Headey (Imagine Me & You), Kate Beckinsale (so hot in the Underworld!), Rachel Shelley (always hot!!)

 That was hard!! and that's because i cheated and had 8! haha, and also i think the list proves that i'm into dark hair/ brunette chicks.  ;)

Bridget McManus kicks ass!!!

myspace.com/nerdygirl_who_luvs_metal

robbie's picture

Hmm..

uhh...probably 

1) Olivia Wilde

2) Mia Krishner

3) Katy Perry

4) Carly Pope

5) Leighton Meester

 

only five? that's hard man!

polkadotwings's picture

hmmmm

1. Tracie Thoms (played a lesbian in RENT)

2. Olivia Wilde (plays a bisexual in House)

3. Elizabeth Mitchell (played a lesbian on ER)

4. Idina Menzel (played a lesbian in RENT)

5. Portia de Rossi

Anonymous's picture

1. Lena Headey  (imagine

1. Lena Headey  (imagine me and you )

2.  Lauren German (standing still  

3. Mila Jovovich (not a very good one in .45

4.Hudson Leick/ Callisto (she was totally in love with Xena :) )

5. Keira Knightley (the dutchess. the only movie where you dont have to look for subtext in her character)

l@ur@ d.d.'s picture

LINDSAY LOHAN

i would go bisexual just 4 her..

1.lindsay lohan

2.3.4.5.......still lindsay lohan

Leibug's picture

Top 5

Missy Higgins

Michelle Wolff {speaking of Dante's Peak see pic below}

Jodie Foster

Marnie Alton

Patricia Cornwell

vansgirl's picture

my 5

Lauren London

Jordana Brewster

Rosario Dawson

Keira Knightly

Kristen Stewart

 

Pyewacket's picture

My Top 5!

 

 

1 - Padma Lakshmi

2 - Mary-Louise Parker

3 - Lisa Bonet

4 - Jennifer Beals

5 - Jordana Brewster

Angie 's picture

top 5

  1. Idina Menzel
  2. Jill Bennett
  3. Jordana Brewster
  4. Zooey Deschanel
  5. Bridget McManus

 

 

 

slamfirst's picture

1.  Tamara Braun (Reese on

1.  Tamara Braun (Reese on All My Children) - OMG she is so gorgeous with those chocolate eyes.  I could look at her all day long and still find something new.

2.  Rose Rollins - the voice, the eyes, the lips, the laugh, the sexy

3.  Crystal Chappell (Olivia on Guiding Light) - Always loved her...simply beautiful.

4.  Gabrielle Union - smokin hot

5.  Charlize Theron - classic

 

Anonymous's picture

an odd but Hott list of ladies.


#5.  Jennifer Beals - Love her style.

#4.  Taraji Henson - incredibly talented.  Loved her since "Baby Boy"

#3.  Meg Ryan - Not the latest Meg though.  I mean the "You've Got Mail" kinda gay lookin" Meg Ryan.

#2.  Alek Wek - The HoTTEST model out there in my humble opinion.  Stunning. 

#1.  Kerry Washington -  just look at her ...

"Be who you are and say what you feel,
because those who mind don't matter
and those who matter don't mind.
" ~Dr. Seuss

Meke's picture

I love me some Taraji!

I love me some Taraji!
sarcasticallyawesome's picture

Top 5

#1- Olivia Wilde (Duh, Thirteen and all that bisexual hotness in the OC xD)

#2- Ellen Page (Hello, lesbian skit! And she does give that at-least-bisexual-if-not-totally-gay vibe)

#3- Gabrielle Christian (South of Nowhere)

#4- Jill Bennett (She is SO awesome in 3Way)

#5- Uh... I don't know it's a tie between Jordana Brewster (omg D.E.B.S.) Katy Perry (she kissed a girl and she liked it xD) and Sara Ramirez (bisexual Callie in Grey's Anatomy)

Mags's picture

Go with...

Go with Jordana for your #5. Lucy Diamond all the way, man.
Ashlee Leilani's picture

yup

I totally agree. Jordana is best!!
flashdancer's picture

top 5

olivia wilde (house, the oc) because she's "so sexy she makes me want to strangle a mountain ox with my bare hands" 

lisa ray (the world unseen, i cant think straight) because "The issue of the stories being between two women never even crossed their minds, it never even came up in conversation"

laura sanchez (los hombres de paco) because "And one day I got to know this girl, and I kissed that girl, and I loved it"

ellen page because "Why does everything have to have a frickin' label? Why can't I just hug a woman with my legs in friendship?"

jordana brewster (debs) because "Well, their poster child doesn't know it yet, but she's into me"

Mags's picture

Top cinq

No particular order...

Christina Cox-Better Than Chocolate, Nikki & Nora,

Sarah Shahi-Do I even need to explain why? *swoons*

Kate McKinnon-Because she makes me laugh uncontrollably when she plays Fitzwilliam

Lena Headey-Imagine Me and You, *swoons again*

Karina Lombard-The L Word, and she has the most amazing accent. Hot!

And many others that people have already listed.

Thu Queer's picture

Tina Fey (God her humor is

Tina Fey (God her humor is so sexy. But its weird cause she really does look like Sarah Palin! Ahhh its okay Tina is so hot.)

Jordana Brewster (She could kidnap me anytime. Loved her in D.E.B.S)

Mandy Musgrave (She just so cute)

Olivia wilde VS Gabrielle Christian

and Sirbrina from Shot of Love 2 xD lol I watched the show just for her then she got kicked off just because tila was trying to make a point that she didn't just go for cuteness... what a retard -.-

Lindsay 's picture

five.

 In this order:

 1) Keira Knightly- Domino was a lesbian in real life, and she looks so gay and so hot in that movie :]

2) Katherine Moennig (duh)

3) Kat Dennings (In Nick & Norah she says she kissed a girl at summer camp) I can't believe no one else on this site is talking about how hot she is!

4) Kim Stolz (ANTM!) I love her no matter what her style is!

5) Ellen Page. Because otherwise all of them would have started with K, and that's just weird. But really, because I wouldn't mind letting her hug me with her legs in friendship :]

SWIRL xD's picture

oh

Hmm it's hard only to pick 5 :b

in no particular order.

1)Laura Sanchez

2)Oliva Wilde

3)Ellen Page

4)Keira Knightley

5)Carly Pope

6)Piper Perabo

7)Eliza Dushku

8)Clea DuVall

9)Kathlen Rondot

10)Michelle Rodriguez

11)Freja Beha (a really hot dane :b)

12)Ashley Massaro

13)Pink

ups- I think that was more than five :s :b

 

LarterWilde76's picture

1 OLIVIA WILDE ( She is so

1 OLIVIA WILDE ( She is so freaking sexy

2. Michelle Rodriguez( Love her to death)

 

3. Hayden Panettiere

 

4.Kristen Bell

 

tie between Emma Stone and Kat Dennings

 

 

LarterWilde76's picture

1 OLIVIA WILDE ( She is so

1 OLIVIA WILDE ( She is so freaking sexy

2. Michelle Rodriguez( Love her to death)

 

3. Hayden Panettiere

 

4.Kristen Bell

 

tie between Emma Stone and Kat Dennings

 

 

Ashley's picture

in no particular order..

- Kerry Washington -Beyoncé -Keri Hilson -Gabrielle Union -Sharon Leal (omg) -Dania Ramirez
Celeste's picture

And the top 5 contestants are...

(from first to last place) 

Gabrielle Union  -Dorothy in Running With Scissors

Sara Shahi  -Carmen in The L Word

Jordana Brewster  -Lucy Diamond in D.E.B.S.

Leisha Hailey  -Alice in The L Word

Jess  -from The Beaver Bunch on Youtube (she's not on TV or anything, but she's gorgeous)

 

 

 

"Your silence will not protect you." -Audre Lorde

 

Low-Ren-Zo.'s picture

my hot five.

5. persia white.

4. pink. i've had a thing for her since MizzUnderstood.

3. sara ramirez. why the HELL else would i still be putting up with grey's anatomy?

2. janelle monae. she has a pompadour, therefore she should join me in holy matrimony.

 

1. rosario dawson. of course. that doesn't even bear mentioning anymore.

YES PLEASE!

 

I got a dick like a mule...with a big dick.

TheBeeCharmer's picture

Top five

1. Alyson Hannigan (Buffy the Vampire Slayer)

2. Jordana Brewster (D.E.B.S.)

3. Sarah Shahi (The L Word)

4. Elizabeth Mitchell (Gia)

5. Jessica Stroup (Broken)

DaniRae(:'s picture

My top 5 (:

1. Katy Perry

2. Cassadee Pope

3. Hayley Williams

4. Kate Hudson

5. Sirbrina Guerrero


Their gay/bi connections are that a bi girl is crushing on them. xD
ChocolateSprinkles's picture

1. Lucy Lawless (Because

1. Lucy Lawless (Because Xena SO counts! :) )

 

 

 

2. Rachel Shelley (L-Word)

3. Simone Lahbib (Bad Girls)

4. Jodie Foster (Duh)

5. Erin Daniels ( L-Word )

Vixter2131's picture

1. p!nk (bisexual) 2.

1. p!nk (bisexual)

2. Jillian Michaels (not out but COME ON)

3. Leisha Hailey (lez)

4. Jennifer Beals (straight ally)

5. Laurel Holloman (bisexual)

:D

xxtaoxx's picture

Top.....

Sheetal Sheth: Perfect!      Sheetal Sheth: Perfect! Sheetal Sheth (The World Unseen movie, simply beautiful in every way)

On the flipside, Radeo Suicide Radeo: Beauty redefined.        Radeo: Beauty redefined

I know I don't have 5 to share, oh well. 

Lesley Bean's picture

(:

Jill Bennett,
Lena Headey,
Sophia Bush,
Olivia Wilde,
Sarah Shahi,
Lauren Graham,
Ellen Page,
Tegan Quin.

Why choose 5 when there are millions of beautiful ladies out there :)

 

"How happy is the blameless vestal's lot!
The world forgetting, by the world forgot.
Eternal sunshine of the spotless mind!
Each pray'r accepted, and each wish resign'd" Alexander Pope