Welcome to AfterEllen.com!

Enter your AfterEllen.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Lesbian and Bisexual women in Entertainment and the Media

If you were trapped on a desert island...


And you had 5 CDs with you, what CDs would those be?

Here's mine:

Andrew Lloyd Webber - Phantom of the Opera soundtrack

Milla Jovovich - The Divine Comedy

Sting - Mercury Falling

Melissa Etheridge - Brave and Crazy

Led Zeppelin - How the West Was Won

 


Ed Would's picture

I hate these questions, but

I hate these questions, but I'll try.

 

1. 13 Blues for Thirteen Moons, by A Silver Mt. Zion

2. In Rainbows, by Radiohead

3. To Bring You My Love, by PJ Harvey

4. Homogenic, by Bjork

5. Blackout, by Britney Spears

 

And before anyone says anything... that last choice is posted in absolute sincerity!

Anonymous's picture

If there was a CD player around...

I would only need to take one CD:

Dixie Chicks/Top of the World Tour(live).

I could survive on that.

Britney Spear's Blackout CD is great though so I can understand why you would add it. Being stranded on a desert island could use Britney's upbeat album, aha.

Ed Would's picture

Definitely. If I get so

Definitely. If I get so hungry that I decide I have to eat my own leg, I want to do it to that CD and that CD alone. :P
dontkillcate's picture

Jeff Buckley - Grace Tom

Jeff Buckley - Grace

Tom Waits - Rain Dogs

Arcade Fire - Funeral

David Bowie - Hunky Dory

Joy Division - Closer

K's picture

Desert Island

 

Nirvana - MTV Unplugged

Morningwood - Morningwood

any B-52s album to keep the spirits up

The Go! Team - Grip like a vice

Luscious Jackson - Electric Honey

Anonymous's picture

If I had sand in my bits...

I would hope to have with me:

Heaven or Las Vegas--Cocteau Twins

Diva--Annie Lennox

Soul Mining--The The

Mr. Heartbreak--Laurie Anderson

Trinity Sessions--Cowboy Junkies 

Zirpister's picture

Sleater-Kinney - The Hot

Sleater-Kinney - The Hot Rock

Stephen Marley - Mind Control

Rilo Kiley - The Execution of All Things

Modest Mouse - The Moon & Antarctica

Echo Is Your Love - Paper Cut Eye

Jessy's picture

Here are my picks!

OK here goes:

Annie Lennox - Diva

Eurythmics - Savage

PJ Harvey - Stories from the city..

Tori Amos - From the Choir Girl Hotel

Feist -The Reminder

And I'd hide Joni Mitchell's Blue in my bag because I need one more cd!

Granger's picture

I'd cheat..

I'd end up cheating and making 5 mix cd's.. Because there's no way I could narrow down to 5!
Low-Ren-Zo.'s picture

5 CDs to rule them all.

.................anyway.

 

Isaac Green and the Skalars - Skoolin' with the Skalars

Outkast - Big Boi and Andre Present: Outkast

Kenna - New Sacred Cow

Alanis Morrissette - Jagged Little Pill

Meshell - Confort Woman

But i'd sneak and have like, 3 CDs in each case. Oh music.

 

I got a dick like a mule...with a big dick.

evenmore's picture

The answers for these Q's change everyday...

Umm...in no order of preference

P!nk - Try This

Greatest Hits of Heart

The Best of David Bowie 1969/1974

Horrorpops - Hell Yeah

The Bloodhound Gang - Hooray For Boobies

 

The greatest thing you'll ever learn, is just to love and be loved in return.

Anonymous's picture

Hmm..

Smashing Pumpkins- Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness

Smashing Pumpkins- Siamese Dream

Bob Marley and the Wailers- Souls Rebels

Marvin Gaye- What's Going On?

The Flaming Lips- Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots

GoldringI's picture

Ooo...

1. The Corrs - Dreams (Ultimate Colection)

2. Katie Melua - Piece by Piece

3. Aaron Copland - Appalachian Spring

4. Missy Higgins - The Sound of White

4 1/2. Tegan and Sara - This Business of Art (if we're not allowed mix CDs, that is - it just has to have My Number on it)

4 3/4. Anything with Leila Josefowicz playing - maybe her Shostakovich CD

5. Lacuna Coil - Comalies

Morgan's picture

In no particular order..

1. The Milk-Eyed Mender - Joanna Newsom
2. Kid A - Radiohead
3. Turn On The Bright Lights - Interpol
4. Natural Born Killers Soundtrack
5. Laundry Service - Shakira

nimbo's picture

1. Evanescence - Fallen

1. Evanescence - Fallen

2. Tatu - 200km/h in the wrong lane

3. Frou frou

4. Jedi mind tricks - Violent by design

5. How to get of a deserted island - The selfhelp cd

What? i'm totally sure that number 5 exist =p

 

If i was the grim reaper everyone would die in freak accidents.

i love marmite's picture

tricky indeed

Complete RENT soundtrack - Movie Cast

Queen Greatest hits - Queen

Rage against the machine - Rage against the machine

Black holes and revelations - Muse

Accoustic extravagansa - KT Tunstall

fee's picture

I'd take...

For now, I'd take...

Canon - Ani DiFranco
Yes, Virginia - The Dresden Dolls
Opheliac - Emilie Autumn
Bleed like me - Garbage
Overdrive - Katy Rose

"Bad juju? Is that a voodoo-thing?"
"Close...but with a 'j'." 
- Malinda Lo & Sarah Pecora, 'the Lo-down'
Meke's picture

How can one choose?

Kate Bush - Never For Ever

PJ Harvey - Is This Desire

PJ Harvey - Stories Form the City, Stories From the Sea

Tori Amos - Under The Pink

No Doubt - Tragc Kingdom

 

This was the hardest decision of my life!

Pirategrrrl's picture

Funny ...

 

I JUST asked a someone this same question last night ... except with books. It was a painful hour spent.

But ... here's mine:

1. The Essential Bruce Springsteen

2. The Essential Mary Chapin Carpenter

3. Tori Amos - Tales of the Librarian

4. The Weakerthans - Reconstruction Site

5. Aimee Mann - Lost in Space

Speak what we feel not what we ought to say...

hmmm's picture

Ugh ...

This is a tough question that I'm going to attempt to answer.  I must say that I'm a huge fan of mix CDs and shuffle on my iPod, so this is tough!  In no particular order:

1) Michael Buble - It's Time

2) Dixie Chicks - Home  (difficult to choose just one)

3) Missy Elliott - Miss E So Addictive

4) Missy Higgins - The Sound of White

5) Tower of Power - Monster on a Leash 

rokstar's picture

my 5 would be...

the 5 cds i would bring...

10– k's choice

MTV unplugged – Nirvana

So Jealous – Tegan and Sara

Three Days Grace – Three Days Grace

Life in Cartoon Motion – Mika

god that was difficult i hate choosing my favorite bands/cds

what made me choose these cds was b/c i like every song on all of the cds not just a few

 

Mara's picture

My 5 CDs would (hopefully) be

"Magic" by Bruce Springsteen

"Home is where my feet are" by Holly McNarland

"Mirrorball (live)" by Sarah McLachlan

"Hybrid theory" by Linkin Park

"Paradise in me" by K's Choice 

_ _ _ _ _

"Be who you are and say what you feel, because those who mind don't matter, and those who matter don't mind." (Dr. Seuss)

zero's picture

My 5

The Essentials-Janis Joplin

Fever to Tell- Yeah Yeah Yeahs

Robbers and Cowards-Cold War Kids

The Con- Tegan and Sara

The Beatles 1-The Beatles

Nobody Girl's picture

Good question

1) Polly Paulusma - Scissors In My Pocket

 

2) Sleater-Kinney - The Woods

 

3) Martha Wainwright - Martha Wainwright

 

4) Dixie Chicks - Taking the Long Way

 

5) Johnny Cash greatest hits

 

but, if I am stranded on a desert island and have the means to listen to my 5 cds then surely I would have the means to charge my 40gb ipod? Then I can have all my lovely music :-)

 

psyco's picture

1- Aerosmith - Big Ones

1- Aerosmith - Big Ones

2- Garbage - Version 2.0

3- Bright Eyes

4- Green Day - Bullet in a Bible

5- Stolen Bebies

With That music I can survive until the bateries dies ;-P 

"Duda que sean fuego las estrellas, duda que el sol se mueva, duda que la verdad sea mentira, pero no dudes jamás que te amo"

shimmy85's picture

after much deliberation...

haha not really...

Coldplay - X&Y

The "Wicked" Soundtrack

Queen - Greatest Hits

Sara Bareilles - Little Voice

Feist - The Reminder

 

erica's picture

if i could choose...

...but knowing my luck I'd end up with The Wiggles or something equally bothersome. 

#1 - Shortbus Soundtrack

#2 - Bob Marley and The Wailers - Legend

#3 - Juno Soundtrack

#4 - Peaches - Impeach My Bush

#5 - Kimya Dawson - I'm Sorry That Sometimes I'm Mean

Anonymous's picture

My five cds..

1. Lizz Wright- Salt

2. Aaliyah- Aaliyah

3. Jill Scott- Beautifully Human: Words and Sounds Vol. 2

4. The Clash- Essential Clash (now this cd contains two disks)

5. H-Town- Ladies Edition

heartless romantic's picture

1. Neko Case -

1. Neko Case - Blacklisted.
2. Elliott Smith - Figure 8.
3. The Spinanes - Strand.
4. Sleater-Kinney - Call the Doctor.
5. Joy Division - Closer.

edie's picture

1. Lou Reed - Coney Island


1. Lou Reed - Coney Island Baby
2. The Smiths - The Queen Is Dead
3. Bob Dylan - Desire
4. Neutral Milk Hotel - In The Aeroplane Over The Sea
5. Patti Smith - Horses

 

SmilinHobbes's picture

My picks

In the time of itunes and the single song download, these are the full CDs I listen to on a regular basis and would need to take along to my island paradise...

1. Sleater-Kinney "The Woods"

2. Dave Matthews & Tim Reynolds "Live at Luther College"

3. Sigur Ros "med sud i eyrum vid spilum endalaust"

4. Various Artists "Dark Was the Night"

5. Tool "10,000 Days"

Honorable Mentions: T&S "The Con", Gossip "Music for Men", and Ra Ra Riot "The Rhumb Line"

Ginney 's picture

Heres mine

This was a real good question. Plus real hard for me because I love so much music lol

1.Alanis Morissette-Jagged little pill

2.Grease-Soundtrack( sorry have too lol)

3.The Judds -Reunion Dec 31,1999

4.Whitesnake-Serpens

5.Eminem-The Eminem Show

 

Jenna's picture

Tough Choice

1. Saves The Day - Through Being Cool

2. Polar Bear Club - Sometimes Things Just Disappear

3. The Swellers - Ups and Downsizing

4. NOFX - Punk In Drublic

5. Dillinger Four - Civil War

Ana's picture

Five...

Mike Oldfield - Tubular Bells 2

- The Song From Distant Earth

Madredeus - Antologia

George Michael - Twenty Five

Deepest Blue - Late September

 

Tamsin  's picture

my five...

She and Him-Volume one

Jacks Mannequin-The glass Passenger

The Juno soundtrack

Teddy Geiger-Underage thinking

Taylor Swift-Fearless 

Hoops's picture

Desert Island

Tegan and Sara - The Con

P!nk - Missundaztood

Cher - Best of

Eminem - The Eminem Show

Various Artists - Motown / anniversary 

 

There's always another way.

fakeplastictree's picture

Desert Island Top 5...

The Velvet Underground & Nico - The Velvet Underground & Nico.

Simon & Garfunkel - Bookends.

Bob Dylan - Bringing It All Back Home.

Patti Smith - Horses.

Nick Drake - Pink Moon.

- this is based on me being stranded on a desert island today...if it happened tomorrow the list would most likely vary.

"Choose rotting away at the end of it all, pishing your last in a miserable home, nothing more than an embarrassment to the selfish, f*cked up brats you spawned to replace yourself"

Chocolate.Chips's picture

Easy!

1. Wallis Bird - New Boots

2. Bon Iver - For Emma, Forever Ago

3. The soundtrack to O Brother, Where Art Thou?

4. Playlist: The Very Best Of Dolly Parton

5. Lady Gaga - The Fame

 

aprilrocks's picture

in no particular order

Brandi Carlile - give up the ghost 

Bob Dylan - blood on the tracks

Bon Iver - for emma, forever ago 

Patti Smith - horses

PJ Harvey - Stories form the city, stories from the sea

 

Lee's picture

Oh, that's a tough one...

Oh, that's a tough one...

1. Scarlett's Walk-Tori Amos

2.The Roads Don't Love You-Gemma Hayes

3.Blue-Joni Mitchell

4.Rumours-Fleetwood Mac

5.The Thing That Feels-Hannah Fury/Something Ilk-Cathy Davey/It's Blitz- Yeah Yeah Yeahs

Liv's picture

I've put though into this:

1. Bob Dylan - The freewheelin' Bob Dylan  

2. Iggy Pop - The Idiot

3. Joy Division - Unknown Pleasures

4.  Neutral Milk Hotel - In The Aeroplane Over The Sea

5.  Nico - Chelsea Girl

Lynds_x's picture

1. Lady gaga - The Fame (but

1. Lady gaga - The Fame (but I did go see her last night so I'm influenced)

2. Lauryn Hill - The Mis-education of Lauryn Hill

3. Jamie T - Panic Prevention

4. Jay-Z - The Black Album

5. MGMT - Oracular Spectacular

 That was really hard, I wanna pick another 5