News, Reviews & Commentary on Lesbian and Bisexual women in Entertainment and the Media
>

Ayn Rand

Currently I'm reading The Fountainhead for my American Literature class.  I don't know why, but for some reason this novel is hard to put down.  However, I got pissed off at the debatable "rape" scene especially after our teacher asked us to write a response detailing why Ayn Rand would celebrate this scene.  Maybe it was simply because I felt that the female character involved was pathetic for wanting a man to dominate her and "defile" her.  Of course I couldn't tell my classmates that...they'd chide me even more for being a femi-nazi.  I'm really not, but at my conservative college I guess I qualify as femi-nazi.  They should meet my sister who happens to go to a women's college. 

Anyways, I did a little research on Ayn and what I found certainly wasn't promising.  She was considered a traitor to her sex by some feminists.  I also found out that she thought homosexuality was morally wrong and that it was a character flaw.  Of course that gives you -50 cool points in my book. 

Basically I dislike Rand as a person, but her book is fascinating somehow.  Anyone else have any experience with Rand?  Just looking for some opinions/good discussion.  In particular if anyone wants to comment on the rape scene, that would be great.  We had a huge debate in class today but I still don't feel as if we resolved anything.

smokinbluegrass's picture

Rand

Well, Atlas Shrugged is in a 3-way tie for "my favorite book ever." (I've read it more than 30 times.) The Fountainhead, though, not so much. Probably because even though I started it as many times as I read AS, I never could finish it. I've read most of her "non-fiction" writings on objectivism, too. Still, The Fountainhead is pretty much a stone-dry well for me. The main thing to remember about her is that everything she writes in the fiction genre is pretty much a treatise on objectivism. As for the rape scene, which I have not read, sounds like a fairly common psychological phenomenon, the "rape fantasy." Yes, it sounds appalling, but it's common, both in life and art. For more on that, read Margaret Atwood's "Rape Fantasies."

edited to add: I just found this link. It's a discussion board on Rand's use of rape fantasies. It's a few years old, though. (http://forums.4aynrandfans.com/index.php?showtopic=2435) 

 

~Talk Derby to me.~

jackio's picture

Like Smokin, Atlas Shrugged

Like Smokin, Atlas Shrugged is one of my favorite books but conversely, I disagree with a lot of her objectivist theories. I can understand her ultra-capitalist attitude in that she grew up in the repression of the former USSR but I roll my eyes at much of it. Plus, I saw her on the Phil Donahue show years ago and was completely disillusioned by what how rude and dismissive she was toward audience members who dared question her beliefs (yet I still love the book--go figure!).

User login

AfterEllen.com NYC Meet-Up on May 18th

We're having a get-together on May 18th in NYC for our readers, with some of our staff and vloggers, and the cast/creators of 3Way. Go here for details.

Recent comments

After Ellen home page on logo online