Welcome to AfterEllen.com!

Enter your AfterEllen.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Lesbian and Bisexual women in Entertainment and the Media

Discrimination in Italy

I'm italian and I know that in Italy people aren't so open minded as they wanted to be or to seem like..

Where I live who is gay is discriminated, we are always treated in different way,like we are mentally ill and also we are always target of stupid jokes and words..

Nobody want to admit that people in Italy suffer of pain about us, they are afraid of what they don't know and they refuse to understand that everyone is egual..we are all the same..It doesn't matter with who I go to bed with if it's a man or a woman, the only thing that has to be important for the other is if I'm a good person or not..Isn't it right? Am I wrong?


newmexiconiki's picture

It's a global issue!

It's the same where I live in the good ol USA. Also, I just saw the news clip of the violence at the pride march in Hungary. Last year,the pride march was banned in Moscow, and I can only imagine the global scale of violence and hate against homosexuals. On the Human Rights Campaign website, I learned that it is still legal in 31 states to be fired for being gay, and in 39 states for being transgender (log on to lobby your reps in favor of ENDA, and thank Udall!) I worry about my job; I do not show any physical affection toward my gf when we are in public because I worry about the repercussions (job, hate crimes, etc.) It's a scary world! I agree with you that we are basically the same, but I guess some people don't hesitate to use violence and hate to uphold their views.  I don't get it, either.
allergictonuts's picture

It's sad

It makes you want to scream at people "why do you have to hate me for who I am!? Love is love to me.  That's what makes the world go round.  If everybody was attracted to the same person, we would all be fighting over each other.  Why does it matter who I choose to share my bed with? What does that have to do with my job performance.  What does that have to do with my parenting skills? why does that anger you!?!"

People love to play follow the leader and tha'ts just how it's going to be until they realize that discriminating people because of their orientation is the same as hosing people down because of the color of their skin.  We will continue to fight these human right's wars until the end of time because man will always find another reason to exclude people because of their inability to see from another's point of view.

I say fight for what's yours....My ex and I walked down the street hand in hand every time we went out. Of course we recieved comments and stares but we didn't care.  We were too caught up in a shared moment with each other to really notice.  There will always be people who refuse to accept change, but you know what? they probably have something in their closet that they are desperate to keep hidden. 

nevar's picture

ehi! donde sei? ;)

ciao! ma ci sei stata al gay pride a roma? lì c'era una bella atmosfera e ho avuto un po' di speranza ..anke se le cose sono difficili da cambiare nel breve periodo credo.

a volte mi ci incazzo ankio. ma come le cambi le teste delle persone? ci vuole tempo, pazienza e coraggio.

nevar's picture

trad: hey! where are you from? ;)

sorry I can't translate..but what I mean is that everywhere exist intolerance and prejudice, and people are often scaring (and scared themselves). and change their minds is not easy.

besides I went to Gay Pride on 16th june in Rome. and what I saw was good. I saw people. I mean women and men, gay and straight. all together. and even if hiding myself is still the better way to live for me, I'm hoping in a better future. people can change. we need to be patient and brave.

SD's picture

Homophobia is everywhere but in different forms

I’m guessing the homophobia in Italy and overseas is probably worse than what we’ve got in the US, but it’s still here in the US, trust me. You'd think that with all the visibility we have in the US that there would be less discrimination, but there isn't. Especially in a rabidly Republican Southern red state, not wanting to stereotype or anything. They say visibility is increasing and people are becoming accepting, but somehow I don't see that happening when I walk around with my gf even when we don’t display any PDA.

What's even worse is the way people are so transparent with their views. Anti-gay comments and actions are so frequent that describing them here will probably shock you. Hate crimes and discrimination go unreported and people blackmail you if you dare report them. Outing yourself without preparation is not a risk a lot of people are willing to take here.

It is especially so when your neighbors are supporters or involved in focus on the family or CWA or other extremely homophobic organizations. You just wish you could scream in their faces and show them all the evidence that gay parents are like any others. When your family themselves are supporters of such religious right views coming out and actually being accepted and loved can only become real in a fantasy, imaginary world. A world where acceptance is actually possible because it isn't here that’s for sure. Being an adopted child of a different color and background in such a family can make you feel different and left out. You feel obligated to meet the expectations of your family even when you know it will kill you slowly.

 My family hasn't come to any of the parties and anniversary celebrations that we've invited them to and ever since they have had some doubt that I wasn't the "perfect" person they'd always wanted and planned for me to be, they have excluded me , explicitly and implicitly, from family events in the hope it will make me reconsider. Some family members still keep in contact with me quietly rather than openly, so as to not catch the wrath of my parents. It's such a suffocating feeling to meet your parents in a supermarket or in a shop and then for them to avoid talking to you and meeting your gaze. When basic questions or requests such as "How's it going?”, "Mom and Dad, why don't you love me anymore? Why are you avoiding me?Can you answer me this..that ever since you got me, have you ever loved me once even for a moment? Did I never bring you a moment of happiness and joy even for a second? If I have just tell me that you love me now. Just once.” go unanswered. They are either dismissed with “Stop making a scene. You’re not a child anymore and we can’t handle your mental and emotional problems. You know what we expect of you.”

Or if they are answered they are answered in homophobic terms, "We saved you, we took care of you when your mother had an unwanted pregnancy. We loved and cared for you, but then you had to follow the wrong path. You've never been normal, always behind your age, and you've always had mental and emotional problems. You've put us through so much and  on top of that we’ve had to put you through a number of ex-gay programs, but it hasn't worked. The role-play activities, the mental and health interventions, the focus groups with those who were freed from your lifestyle, the reparative therapy counselors, the priests and the bible sessions. We've given up on you and sometimes we wish we hadn’t saved you.” I feel like saying that it’s because what I am is natural for me and that is why you can never change that about me. What you’ve done is worsened any mental and emotional problems I may have had previously. Religion has nothing to do with it. I feel like asking ' Have you also given up on your love for me. Or was that love and care you gave to me and other similar children based on us growing up to fulfil your dreams and hopes. Is that why you consider me a failure? If you didn’t want to love me and care for me unconditionally why did you “save” and adopt me?” I know there is no point as their homophobic views are so engrained that nothing I say and do can change that.

Sometimes I wonder if my birth parents would be as homophobic as my adopted parents. What made my birth mother abandon me and would it have been better for her to have just aborted me. Maybe it would have been. Now that I think about it, it may have been the better decision. Totally contradictory to what I’m supposed to believe, but whatever. I’ve realized that life is not black and white, people are not good or bad, it all depends on the situation. Coming to this site has opened my mind and allowed me to think outside the small box I built for myself. Though I doubt I've made a great first introduction here. :)

Unconditional love is a lie. It’s a myth. Parental love is based on meeting their expectations. Love between friends is based on doing what everyone else is doing and love between partners is based mostly on compromise. I’ve learnt that love is more about taking than giving. Of course there are some people who are wonderful, as I have found through my travels, but they are few and far between. If it wasn't for the understanding nature of my current gf and her love of the place I would have moved to some other more accepting place. She tells me that greater visibility is what is needed to make people more accepting and that we should live boldly without fear of social repercussions.

Don’t know if my long story has helped. But just know that you are not alone in your feelings of not being accepted. It’s here in the US as well and probably in most other countries. Though the degree and nature of it may vary. Growing up Catholic myself, I can’t imagine what it must be like in Italy, home to the most homophobic priests around, but all the best.

Anonymous's picture

What I got from US society

What I got from US society compared to many european countries I would guess we are a helluva lot better off in Europe!

I do get annoyed myself at people complaining about the situation and in the mean time not realising that if they keep hiding nothing will ever change! Obviously each has to make her own choice but when you do choose, stop complaining about the result of your choices! If you are not willing to take the risks, don't expect others to do it for you!

 

 

"call me old fashioned but I prefer feminism that leaves a little something to the imagination!"

newmexiconiki's picture

Everybody's situation is different

Thanks to Rhianna and allergictonuts for sharing...it reminds me that we have to take heart in one another. Most of all, I think it's important to give people the time and space to deal with the issues. There are so many people in the world who are haters! We definitely don't need to hate and judge each other or show intolerance because different people handle being "out" differently.

Until you walk a mile in my shoes.....

Anonymous's picture

I hope you don't think I am

I hope you don't think I am "hating" people ! All I am saying is you can't complain nothing is changing in your house when you don't leave your closet!

But if somebody wants to live in the closet they should just do that!

 

"call me old fashioned but I prefer feminism that leaves a little something to the imagination!"

SD's picture

Leaving the closet

I'm not sure you were refering to me, but let me clarify. I never got the opportunity to prepare myself for coming out or leaving the closet, I was caught in the closet, if that makes sense. When I was just 16 my parents caught me reading a graphic lesbian book, and that was all that was needed for them to realize I wasn't like all the other kids. I got two warnings, but the third time they caught me with some lesbian related material was enough to break their tolerance. I will never forget that day. It was my first but not my last gay bashing, at the hands of my own parents. I can even remember the details. My dad used his favorite cane, the antique one that had been passed on from one generation to another in our family and it had often been used to discipline us in the past. It didn't work in this case, but i still retain some marks from the experience.  

 That was enough for them to put me through a number of ex gay programs. Somewhere from one program to another, I told them it was a natural attraction for me, something I couldn't change and when I found out the word for those feelings I told them I was a lesbian . In an ideal world I would have come out to them and my parents and family would have been accepted and loved for who I am, but I don't live in an ideal world.

I wouldn't come out to a stranger though. Too many bad experiences for me to attempt that. In the small town that I live in most seem to have a general idea, but hardly mention it.

I'm not saying this because I want some sort of sympathy from people. If I did I would have told this much earlier. Everyone has the right to have their own opinion of others. If someone thinks I'm a wretch or tarded or whatever, I may be, and they have a right to express that. I only hope people would consider the complete picture before judging. I've made the mistake of judging before understanding before, and trust me it's not a good mistake to make.

I would rather people hate me and say hurtful things about me than like me. Hate is more tangible and a longer lasting emotion than mere liking. It is the one true emotion I have known all my life and I like seeking hate from other people in whatever form it may come. That must make me a masochist or something. 

Anonymous's picture

Rhianna!

My remark was a general one. And a response to the previous poster.

 

"call me old fashioned but I prefer feminism that leaves a little something to the imagination!"

allergictonuts's picture

victory

Rhianna's story really hit home to me.  I myself was adopted and for some reason I could never do enough to please them.  I never had the opportunity to come out to them as I have since severed all ties.  I find that it doesn't matter who that person is, or how strong the bonds that you share are, If they don't support you, love you, and create positive energy in your life, then you don't need them in it.  Some might call it a coward's way out, but I believe my quality of life is much better for the lack of negativity they would have created.  

That's not to say that I haven't had with my own homophobia/gay bashing experiences.  I share a 3 BR house and at some point realized I was gay.  After letting close friends and family know, I came out to my then roommate.  She broke down and tried to take me with her.  She screamed in the streets that I was a pervert, she called the Child protective services on me because in her mind a lesbian should not be around children.  I endured humiliating interrogations, court appearances, drug testing, and I almost gave up on life.  The day finally came where I had lost my job, the house owner said we had to move out, my gf broke up with me, and I was terrified because the only thing left to lose was my beloved child.  I went to the court pleading for help and an angel saved me.  I went home and meditated/prayed (whatever you want to call it) and that very night she (roommate) was lead away to the phsychiatric unit.  I regained a little strength to fight for my rights, and I was able to obtain a permanent restraining order against her.  

A few months after it was all over, it was voting time at the polls.  I went to vote for the first time in my life. Guess who was sitting at the polls checking people in.  I yelled for everyone to hear me.  "I voted Democrat for GAY RIGHTS!!!!"  I looked her in the eye and walked away. 

So my friends, keep fighting.  Our day will come.  And yes, there will always be hurdles.  But if there were no problems, you'd have to call it Heaven, and I'm not ready to go there yet.  I have some things I'd like to accomplish first.

SD's picture

Thanks allergictonuts

Thanks allergictonuts for sharing your experience with us. I'm glad that someone else out there could relate. It means so much to me to know that I'm not alone in having these feelings and experiencing these situations. You've been through so much and I'm so glad that it all worked out right for you in the end.

 I couldn't agree more when you said that you can never do enough to please your foster parents. And I completely agree with you that there will be hurdles in our path, but we have to fight them and cross them. If the world was perfect it wouldn't be earth but heaven. But I still have hope in a tiny corner of my heart that one day the world will be free of prejudices and we can really have heaven on earth, as they say.

All the best,

Rhianna

newmexiconiki's picture

Just yesterday

I went to a KD Lang/Lyle Lovett show in ABQ. There were plenty of lesbians there, and still the crowd was full of homophobes. I had to leave my $180 seats because the people in front of us were so hateful and rude. I found a better spot far from the stage where a group of women were dancing and having fun. I went home after a small group of rednecks began to harass the women calling them ridiculous and ugly. I cried on the way home. The standard operating procedure among the women seemed to be, "ignore it." I just wanted to fight but ended up feeling hopeless. I had purchased the tickets with so much hope that it would be an evening of respite from "the closet." As it turns out, the message was sent loud and clear that I should stay in it, because, as a lesbian, I am ridiculous, ugly, and don't have a right to enjoy myself in public. I could live out of the closet in the midst of hardship and harassment (and it seems that other gay people will look away or ignore it) or I could continue living in the closet feeling some sense of shame for who I am but not having to deal with the harassment and hurtful treatment. I guess the final option would be to move to a larger metropolis where there are more people like me, but I get the feeling that's what all these small town a**holes and haters want and I hate to give them what they want. What's sad is that I know there were a lot of good straight people there (the ones next to me were almost as uncomfortable as I was with the folks in front of us), but the few awful ones are so vocal and hateful that they drown the others out.
SD's picture

Thanks for sharing that newmexiconiki

Thanks for sharing that newmexiconiki. I know what you mean when you feel like your outnumbered and unable to tackle the homophobes around. I find it unusual that there would be many homophobes around in a KD Lang concert. You'd think the people there would be at least queer friendly. But by sharing this story here you've made us more aware of such incidents and given us an opportunity to think about how to react if ever we were in such a situation. And I thank you for that.

I definitely know what it feels like to want to be out of the closet all the time, but know that is not always possible. Especially living in a small town. I'm sure the atmosphere would be better in a larger metropolis, but to move would make you feel as if you were giving in to the demands of the homophobes. In larger cities I'm sure that if someone was called a homophobe they would at least try to maintain that they weren't. In small towns you get people who proudly wear the homophobe label as if it were a badge of honor. How are you meant to talk reason with people like that who acknowledge that they are homophobes and they are proud of it?

It seems that as lesbian/bi women we have to often make a trade-off with ourselves of whether it is better to stay in the closet or come out. Would the potential for harassment and being called names be greater than the potential enjoyment of being out? If only homophobes understood what a day in the life of an openly out person felt like maybe that would cause them to rethink their views.

Anyway, hope the actual on stage concert was great. I'm sure it was.

All the best

Rhianna

Anonymous's picture

That story is a good

That story is a good example!

If I had been there my focus would not have been on the message send by a few rednecks! Instead I would have been angry with the people who ignore them.

If this was a concert with KD Lang I am betting the lesbians far outnumbered the a**holes and had people been "out and proud" they would have been put in their place and hopefully think twice the next time! But they got away with it and will do it again for sure ! Probably because everybody was waiting for someone else to speak up. If you were afraid to do it alone you could have asked these other people next to you how they felt about what was going on and suggested to say something together.

The only time the few can drown out the many is if the many let them. So I say: speak up! Get angry!(not hateful) Be vocal and drown out the homophobes instead of letting them drown out you. Or at least ,like the famous line says; do not go gentle into that night! :)

edit: all just my opinion of course.:)

 

"call me old fashioned but I prefer feminism that leaves a little something to the imagination!"

newmexiconiki's picture

I'm with you...

I agree with you... we need to speak up. Unfortunately, the sisters did not outnumber anyone. I'm not kidding; we are a serious minority here in the southwest. While I was there, I thought about how a different seating arrangement might have different results. What if we all had just gathered to be near each other? Instead, there were a couple of us in every couple of rows. So, even at a KD Lang show, we were isolated and alone in a very straight world.

Interestingly enough, I did challenge the rudest of the haters (forcefully, logically, and not too hatefully). Although their remarks and hate continued, they were unwilling to face the confrontation. One cowboy with a belt buckle bigger than his brain said really awful things and yet just nodded and ignored when the comments were returned. The woman in front of us who made fun of KD and the women in the crowd during the WHOLE set, never turned to say anything to me directly in spite of the fact that I challenged every smart ass remark that came out of her mouth. I could tell her boyfriend wanted to slide into the cracks in the cement, though, and I hope it was from shame at his girl's atrocious behavior.

You are right... we cannot go gently into the night or silently to our grave... still, there are no easy remedies as long as the world ignores us and treats us as if we are invisible unless they are ridiculing us. Even in the mainstream media (I'm thinking of an episode of Talk Soup that made fun of Rosie and other middle aged lesbians) lesbians are portrayed as ugly, undesirable, full of drama, and crazy. I don't think shows like "Bad Girls" "Workout" and "Curl Girls" are really helping to improve the image (except for the fact that the girls are all attractive), but maybe I'm wrong. I guess the point is just to get the image out there so that people realize we are human. Ugh...now I'm just ranting but I'm so grateful that we are having this conversation.

Thanks, Italy, for a good thread.

Anonymous's picture

I am also enjoying this

I am also enjoying this conversation and I am very happy you stood your ground but sad it didn't work. I agree with you, there are no easy remedies, we can but try our best!

Also I totally get your rant. Though I have to say I am not sure it's a gay thing the image on tv. Let's face it...any and all of these "reality"shows are in fact creating a negative image of human beings in general :).

 

 

"call me old fashioned but I prefer feminism that leaves a little something to the imagination!"

Harpy's picture

...

I hope it is not taken the wrong way when I say that this is really a great thread.  These posts have greatly moved me. 
___      
Putting links in my signature because no one looks in my YouTube thread!
Anonymous's picture

May I say that I personally

May I say that I personally ( for very selfish reasons) am glad you think so Harpy! Reading your posts in another thread made me worry I might be one of the people you prefer to avoid and I am sincerely hoping this post means I am not? ( it may be silly of me but I am still a bit insecure! or realistic. I know I can irritate the H*** out of people ;))

 

"call me old fashioned but I prefer feminism that leaves a little something to the imagination!"

SD's picture

The thread

I'm glad that this thread is doing so well and that I have a place to release my many repressed emotions. I think it would be safe to assume Gali that you are not one of the people that Harpy may be refering to. You've posted 5 comments here, so you've obviously added to the value of the thread.I believe, however, that my pessimistic and over the top posts will cause people to avoid me.

 I'm sure I'm one of the people that Harpy would like to avoid. But I hope not.And I definitely believe my posts are more irritating than yours.;) If you anyone would consider your posts irritating at all. But then again I've always been insecure.

Harpy's picture

...

Nope, not at all.  Neither of you.  I wish I wouldn't have posted that the other day though.  :-P
   
I think it's pretty admirable that you posted that you reconsidered some of the things you've posted previously.  :)
___      
Putting links in my signature because no one looks in my YouTube thread!
Anonymous's picture

That's sweet of you Rhianna

That's sweet of you Rhianna but I am afraid it is not as safe to assume as you assume:) I am glad though you are also enjoying this conversation!

 

 

"call me old fashioned but I prefer feminism that leaves a little something to the imagination!"