Creativity & ViolenceWhilst I agree with Stephen King's overall theme in this essay: http://www.ew.com/ew/article/0,,20036014,00.html?cnn=yes I think I take exception to this part: "For most creative people, the imagination serves as an excretory channel for violence" Hmm. I write crime novels for a living (just about), and whilst I do use my imagination to create conflict, I don't fantasise about it. Is this what he's implying? Or have a missed something? Maybe I'm become over-sensitive since someone told me that it was a sick thing to do as a career (and I don't write anything near as violent as say Tess Gerritsen, or Karin Slaughter). Submitted by Anonymous on April 21, 2007 - 10:33am. |
Recent blog posts
New forum topicsActive TopicsNew Comments
|


on excretory channels...
But the rest of his sentence was “[w]e visualize what we will never actually do,” and I have no doubt that for SK, that’s probably true, given the stuff he writes.
I actually think the imagination serves as an excretory channel for all kinds of stuff. The ability to channel your thoughts, feelings, and ideas results in works that may be violent, or fantastic, or erotic, or funny, or purely whimsical. Sometimes I’m even surprised by the stuff that comes out of me!
Well, not really - it takes a lot to surprise me!
oh, and I don't think there's anything "sick" about writing crime novels! Tho I am interested in what kind of research you do.
huh
I think the article is too general, too vague, and very narrow in focus all at once. I also think that the written word is broadly misunderstood, though reading is still popular, it is not nearly as popular as it once was. So, how about people who create violent video games, or tv shows, are they sick?
I am in the process of editing a novel for publication, and if one were to read it from this standpoint (that the article discusses) I am sure I would be locked up, or something. My stories tend to focus on women in brass bras, with big swords, going to war... The variations on the theme range from women with stone axes, to women with laser guns, but the theme is the same, powerful women, who will not hesitate to chop their enemies to pieces... it is a formula as old as writing, of course, and I am being simplistic about the stories when it comes to other content... but I dread to think of a world where only mild, politically correct, tepid writing is acceptable. Some deranged Ted Kazinski, or this Cho freak, and their manifestos, do not equate to writers imho, or anything that we write. Anyone with a pen can write, but making a craft of it, or an art of it, or doing it for the sake of it, are entirely different to that, imho anyway...
oh no no
It's a shame...
That authors who have become famous, such as Stephen King, or Patricia Cornwell, can make these assumptions and be taken seriously. Lucy, I haven't a doubt in my mind that the sentance applies to you, or to anyone else, either. My imagination serves me just about everything but violence, it's just not who I am!
I can understand how you'd be shocked at reading such a thing and a little out-raged. It was like when I was watching an interview with Patricia Cornwell and she gave her opinion about Tom Cruise, something along the lines of him being a fanatic, idiotic man, etc. Now whereas I may or may not agree, who is Patricia Cornwell to say that about someone? OH, I'm sorry, that's right, she's a published author whose made a lot of money. How foolish of me to forget that in this day and age, what someone famous says MUST be true! Pft to that!
Luce, you just keep writing girl, and let Stephen King believe whatever he wants! :)
Are we really free to speak?
If that were true that
If that were true that people would need to hide from me for the things I write about are clearly the sign of an unstable mind. Actually I am slightly mad and I admit it for all of us creative types are always walking the typerope of sanity and madness am I right?
Honestly, even though I write some rather ghastly morbid stories that does not really make me the violent sort. Actually I'm the least violent person around and am known for keeping my temper no matter what the situation is. What I am is a morbidly curious type that likes to dive into the deepest parts of the human mind. Writing about peoples greatest fears and drawing them out on paper.
Anyways, I'm just saying what others have already stated. That just because we have the ability to imagine the most gruesome of things does not make us violent. Now if we went out and acted upon those things we wrote about we would have to begin to worry.
jaa ne
Kat