Welcome to AfterEllen.com!

Enter your AfterEllen.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Lesbian and Bisexual women in Entertainment and the Media

Women top the 100 Best Comic Book Covers

Last week, Whitney at Pop Candy gave us the heads-up about the countdown of “100 Best Comic Covers” at 1979 Semi-Finalist, aka Kelly Thompson.

Kelly admits to including “a high number of badass chick covers, as I am a badass chick.” Judging from her picks, I’m inclined to agree. Here are a few highlights.

98. The Amazing Spider-Man #29

I don’t remember seeing this cover before — and I think I would’ve remembered. The John Romita Jr. drawing of Spidey’s GF Mary Jane beautifully captures the conflict of being in love with a superhero.

63. Wonder Woman #198

This Phil Noto cover makes me think that Wonder Woman somehow got trapped in a Norman Rockwell painting — and boy, is she pissed.

51. Astro City #4

This Alex Ross classic is another of my favorites, although I would rank it in the top 10. The expression on the woman’s face is a story in itself — and the contrast between her and the female superhero is what Astro City is all about.

40. Optic Nerve #2

I hope you read Optic Nerve. Adrian Tomine has a gift — and this was one of his first covers. Anyone who thinks comic books have no depth needs to see this illustration.

30. Love and Rockets #5

Several Jamie Hernandez covers made the Top 100 — this is my favorite. I love this aviatrix — and her rockets.

19. The Spirit #4

Plenty of comic book covers show a man carrying a woman. Flipping that image is reason enough to love this Darwyn Cooke illustration. But the detail is what pushed the cover into the top 25.

1. Batgirl #45

Hmm. I heart James Jean, but I’m surprised that this cover is No. 1. Kelly loves the badass expression on Batgirl’s face, the juxtaposition between Batgirl and the stylized villain and the high heels. OK, I made up that last one.

Of course, I can’t choose a No. 1 at all. (Even deciding which covers from Kelly’s list to show here felt like Sophie’s Choice.) How could I ever choose between my two favorite Strangers in Paradise covers?

Or Buffy and Wicked Willow?

And my heart would be broken if I left out Fone Bone in love from Bone #11.

So, I leave it to stronger people to choose the best of the best. What is your favorite comic book cover? What do you think of the selections for the Top 100 at 1979 Semi-Finalist? If you have an image of your No. 1, feel free to post it in the comments.

  • the linster's blog
  • Login or register to post comments
  • katemc39's picture

    I was totally unaware...

    ...of this list.  Thanks for sharing!  Some of those current Detective Comics cover could certainly qualify...
    Melissa Hsu's picture

    Maggie

    I was hoping that Love and Rockets would make the cut! Every issue of that series is awesome on so many levels. It's so difficult to find a good LGBT-friendly comic that features female characters, let alone Latinas.

    I'd really like to see it made into a film someday.

    Girl-clad lion.

     

    tinwen's picture

    Some of my favorites:

    Some of my favorites:

    And if European comics are allowed:

    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

    Ian McKellen: "I said, Hands up who thinks they are part of a minority group, and all the hands went up."

    the linster's picture

    European comics

    Of course they're eligible - this is our list and we can do whatever we want!
    Mags's picture

    Comic Covers

    A few of my faves.

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    Very occasionally, if you pay attention, life doesn't suck.
    -Joss Whedon

    music_lover's picture

    Runaways!!!!!

    I got the first few Runaway books from a giveaway at my library. I liked it so much that when I had the money, I went out and bought more, without the knowledge that it would have the lesbian/transgender plotline. I always heard and read that there wasn't many LGBT friendly, and then there one was in my hands!!! I have gotten a few of my friends to read it, and they have bought some of the books too, cause they wanted to see what happened, since I don't have all of them yet.  
    Mags's picture

    Love it!

    I'm a big fan of Joss Whedon, and the first time I had heard of Runaways was when I was at the bookstore in the graphic novel section and I saw Whedon's name in big gold bold writing on the cover of Runaways: Dead End Kids. I bought it and I love it, but I haven't had a chance to read any of the other ones.  

     

    Very occasionally, if you pay attention, life doesn't suck.
    -Joss Whedon

    snazzynic's picture

    Fone Bone!

    I'm reading the Bone series right now and Fone Bone is so cute it hurts.

    Also a couple covers from the Y: The Last Man series are lesbo-rific. I'm not a huge comic book reader (but I'm trying) and they're on the top of my list.

    the linster's picture

    Yay!

    I just read that Jeff Smith is going to do another Bone series. I hope it's true!
    Mara's picture

    I quite like ECHO

    http://www.ifanboy.com/comics/comics/terry_moores_echo/6/cover-large.jpg

    _ _ _ _ _

    "Be who you are and say what you feel, because those who mind don't matter, and those who matter don't mind." (Dr. Seuss)

    the linster's picture

    Definitely

    Echo is one of my current must-read comics. The covers are so evocative that I would be hard-pressed to choose just one. The story took a few issues to hook me, but now I can barely wait to see what's next.
    Mara's picture

    I concur

    I like to get several issues in one purchase so I can read them back-to-back :)

    Back to SiP: Tambi rocks, and I quite like this cover, too

    http://www.strangersinparadise.com/images/issues/3.79.gif

    _ _ _ _ _

    "Be who you are and say what you feel, because those who mind don't matter, and those who matter don't mind." (Dr. Seuss)

    Roach's picture

    The more I look at the Buffy

    The more I look at the Buffy comics the more I think I should be reading them! I was a massive Buffy fan.  Are they worth a read?

     

    "if you're gonna die, bake a nice fucking cake"

    ~Dylan Moran

    Lia's picture

    I think so

    If you were a massive Buffy fan, you would probably enjoy the comics, I think. They are a fun read, certainly. ^_^
    the linster's picture

    Give Buffy a try

    I needed about 3 issues to get into Buffy Season Eight, but I love it now. I think I had to adjust to the rhythm of the dialogue written instead of spoken. But the Joss sensibility is still there.
    Hopeless_Savage's picture

    You should definitely check

    You should definitely check them out!

    You can get the paperbacks pretty cheap these days so no worries there.

    StuntDouble's picture

    This is good!

    I really love the SiP nouveau covers from Vol. 3, Issues 51-53. 

    The Gotham Girls (#1 - 5) covers are my all-time favorite. 

    I also quite liked the latest Supergirl cover (#43). 

     

    the linster's picture

    Nouveau covers

    I love that SiP series, too, and almost included them. But once I started looking at Terry's covers, I got so distracted that I had to cut myself off and go with the first two I thought of.
    GrrrlRomeo's picture

    Buffy Season 8 No. 3

    Surely there must be a mistake. This is the most awesome of the BtVS covers:

    I <3 Jo Chen.

     

    I don't know what my favorite Promethea cover is.

    _____________

    Tweet: @GrrrlRomeo

    the linster's picture

    Oh yes!

    Jo Chen is just amazing. And evil Willow is sexy Willow. I like this cover a lot -- the close-up with the reflection of Buffy in her eye just gives me chills, though.
    Mags's picture

    *shivers*

    Gives me the chills, too. Whenever I see that cover I always think of her saying, "Bored now." just before she obliterates Warren. 

     

    Very occasionally, if you pay attention, life doesn't suck.
    -Joss Whedon

    riotgrrrljaz's picture

    agreed

    this is my favorite cover too! i had this on my desktop forever when i first saw it lol

     

     

    _____________________________________________ 

    We Want Revolution Grrrl Style Now! -BIKINI KILL 

    Andi Torak's picture

    Final Crisis Revelations

    Final Crisis Revelations issue 2: Renee Montoya as The Question looking scary and powerful and sexy as hell.

     

    Final Crisis Revelations

    MetalHead's picture

    A few of my favorites

    First, a few Montoya covers, because she's so cool she deserves her own section:

     

     

     

     

     

    Some great Adam Hughes Catwoman artwork: 

     

     

     

    Wonder Woman showing everyone who's boss:

     

     

    One of my many favorite Hack/Slash covers:

     

     

     

    Witchblade:

     

     

     

    And finally, everybody's favorite 4000-year-old Egyptian lesbian vampire goddess, Purgatori:

     

     

     

    (Sorry for the image overload)

    ChuChu's picture

    Hothead Paisan

    DORKiest's picture

    Hothead Paisan

    That previous one made me laugh, but I don't know if I should be laughing..

    PretaniVirago's picture

    Speaking of badass chicks...

    ...check out some Purgatori...

    Purgatori - Mischief Night (Halloween cover variant)

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Purgatori

     ...or Belladonna...

    Belladonna - Pure Rage cover variantBelladonna 

    ...or the Queen of badass...Xena...

    Dark XenaDark Xena #2

    Xena #2 Virgin incentive coverXena Annual 2006 - virgin cover 

    "Courage in women is often mistaken for insanity"

     

    scorpio54's picture

    Pree-1990s Comics

    Just to prove you can find older comics with powerful women on the cover, here's issue #11 of Howard Chaykin's brilliant early-1980s comic AMERICAN FLAGG! - which was way ahead of its time.

    .merican Flagg #11

    the linster's picture

    Cool

    I've never seen this comic -- thanks for posting it. I love the cat with its own little machine gun.
    scorpio54's picture

    American Flagg!

    It's actually been collected recently in a couple of TPBs, so the stories are available. Here's a cover gallery of the original comics. I almost posted the cover for #22 here but settled on the more sedate #11 instead:

    http://www.comicrelated.com/gallery/americanflagg.html

    My Sunshine's picture

    Great thread.

    Great thread. Purgatori?Wonder Woman/Hack Slash are my favorites.

    I saw a cover which had two schoolgirls making out, I forgot the name of it though.

    1979semi-finalist's picture

    Thanks for linking - and a correction!

    Hey

    Thanks for linking - of all the sites, blogs, forums, etc., that have picked up these posts you guys are definitely the nicest and least critical - I'm going to have to hang out here more often.

    I did want to make a correction though - that first cover - the Amazing Spider-Man #29 with MJ on the cover?  It's by John Romita Jr., not Lee Weeks.  There was some conflicting info about it on the web and since I don't own that issue I wasn't able to confirm, but I got confirmation today and it's Romita Jr.  If you're able to correct your post great - if not, I guess we'll let this stand as the correction.  Apologies to Mr. Romita Jr. and Mr. Weeks for the confusion - and to you Linster for the inconvenience.

    Thanks again for linking - and reading!

    Best,

    Kelly

    the linster's picture

    Corrected!

    Sorry it took me a few days, but I made the correction. Thanks for letting us know – and great list!
    Sam's picture

    Wormwood!

    I love this list.  Here's one from Wormwood that I like.

    http://www.bloody-disgusting.com/photosizer/upload/Wormwood.jpg

    ElusiveJ's picture

    You ladies are representing

    You ladies are representing Buffy and Runaways admirably, so I have to speak up for the women of Fables.

    Fables #8: Rose Red as the boss of The Farm, and what a cute boss she is.

    Fables #71: Cinderella is the most badass woman in Fables!

     

    hypothesis's picture

    Damn

    How'd I miss this blog post?! Awesome read, it's made me wanna go and find my favourite covers too. And thanks to everyone for sharing theirs, very enlightening!
    mathilde's picture

    Belgian book

    There is a french gal from Brussel(capital of comic books), that is going to publish a lesbian graphic novel. Coming out soon Le bleu est une couleur chaude (blue is a warm color).

    Check out her blog: http://djou-bd.over-blog.com/