Welcome to AfterEllen.com!

Enter your AfterEllen.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Lesbian and Bisexual women in Entertainment and the Media

TV’s “most underrated actresses” rate high with us

If AfterEllen.com knows anything, it’s actresses. So when erstwhile AfterEllen.com blogger carolinagrrrl, who now collects embarrassing stories for dude TMI! (and occasionally attends class at law school), tipped us off to EW’s latest list, “16 Wildly Underrated Actresses,” I wasn’t surprised that they’re all quite highly rated by us.

As usual, the list could use more diversity (the selections were EW readers, not the editors), but all of the choices are good ones. Here are some highlights:

Alyson Hannigan, How I Met Your Mother

Yes, she’s underrated. And yes, we know it’s ridiculous. Alyson was a revelation as Willow, but when I watch HIMYM, all I see is Lily. It’s an acting miracle.

The women of Mad Men

Remember when Elisabeth Moss was Zoe Bartlett on West Wing? Or when January Jones was Ashton Kutcher’s girlfriend? Or when Christina Hendricks was flat-chested? OK, I made up that last one, but you get the, um, point.

Katee Sackhoff, Battlestar Galactica

Face it, Starbuck would not have been as, well, Starbucky without Katee. And if you need convincing that she is indeed underrated, consider this: Nip/Tuck recast her character Dr. Rowe with Rose McGowan and apparently thought no one would notice. Wrong.

Brooke Smith, Grey’s Anatomy

Sigh. As much as I love Calzona, I will never forgive Grey’s for summarily dismissing Brooke without explanation. The reader who nominated Smith said that Sara Ramirez deserves a spot on this list, too. Agreed.

Maura Tierney, ER

I can’t imagine ER without Abby. And much like Abby, Maura provided consistently brilliant, intense and often raw performances without ever winning an Emmy. Take care of yourself during breast cancer treatment, friend, so you can show us your acting magic again soon.

Yunjim Kim, Lost

Kim has long been recognized in Asia, but her stellar Lost performance has been thus far unrewarded at awards festivals. My love for Lost waxes and wanes, but my love for Sun never fails.

Sarah Shahi, Life

Oddly, Sarah is listed in the publicity about the list, but is not in the EW gallery. Weird. Not that it stops us from knowing a smoking hot talented actress when we see one.

Another odd thing about EW’s list is the lack of African American actresses, especially given the possibilities. Chandra Wilson, Wanda Sykes, Vanessa Williams, Pam Grier — I could go on and on.

But that’s your job. So, check out the “official” list and tell us what you think. Who makes your list of underrated TV actresses?

  • the linster's blog
  • Login or register to post comments
  • sparklet's picture

    I'm surprised Lisa Edelstein

    I'm surprised Lisa Edelstein wasn't on there.....
    milk's picture

    Me too! I was so sad she

    Me too! I was so sad she wasn't even nominated for an Emmy this year, her acting on House has been nothing but superb.
    sparklet's picture

    I know!!! She has done some

    I know!!! She has done some phenomenal work, and it isn't being recognized. So frustrating >_<
    Suzzie's picture

    Aaaah Starbuck

    I love Katee Sackhoff, Alysan Hannagain, Brooke Smith and Maura Tierney, and when I go on about any of them, the only one my friends have heard of is Alyson (yes we are indeed on first name basis) thanks to Buffy in part, but mostly American Pie (a film I hate on the prinicple of being a flute player)...and there are so many other underated actresses out there it's sad...although it being late and my being useless I can't think of any others right now :S sorry!

     Good article btw

    Puff's picture

    Joining the Starbuck love

    Katee Sackoff (and pretty much all of the BSG girls') were never given a lot of recognition for what they did. I know I'm NOT going to watch a BSG without Katee's Starbuck, the 6's and 8's!
    ChavaAv's picture

    Yesss.

    Brooke Smith.  For the WIN.

     

     

     

    אני קורא, אז אני פשוט צריך לשמוע אותך

    Way2Gay's picture

    What exactly is underrated about Pam Grier?

    I've never been impressed.

    I've never even been indifferent.

    Mostly, I've just been irritated by her acting.

    But if we're talking underrated and overlooked, I'd nominate the women of "Big Love." Every single one of them.

    dragonlady07's picture

    YES

    yes yes yes. to all.

     

    yes.

    SaffronLove's picture

    Gotta agree

    about Pam Grier.   I just don't get the "wow" factor.

    ------------------------------------------------------------ 

    The most beautiful smile is the one that struggles through tears--Graffiti on a bridge outside NYC 

    dragonlady07's picture

    unless...

    y/n?
    SaffronLove's picture

    um, yeah

    m'kay.  Guess I should limit my "wow factor" comment to acting.

    After all, there is no other Foxy Brown except Ms. Grier.

    ------------------------------------------------------------ 

    The most beautiful smile is the one that struggles through tears--Graffiti on a bridge outside NYC 

    Brooklyn's picture

    list includes...

    Mia Kirshner, Sheetal Sheth, Marylynn Rajskub, Elizabeth Mitchell, Chandra Wilson

    BAS's picture

    how do they define "rated"?

    All of those actresses deserve recognition, for sure. Actually, I think Chandra Wilson might not have made the list because she has actually gotten noticed for her work - hasn't she been nominated for an Emmy at least a couple times? Same with Wanda Sykes - everywhere I look lately she's there. (not complaining, in case that's unclear!)

    I don't really keep good track of how the mainstream media/awards are "recognizing" people, so I don't know who is missing out. But I would put much of the "supporting" cast of Grey's there just because they still seem to be supporting when they definitely deserve to be leads - Sara Ramirez, Sandra Oh, and Chandra Wilson for sure.

    On the comedy side, both of the women in How I Met Your Mother are great. Alyson Hannigan of course, but Cobie Smulders too and she seems to be even less well known. I've also been watching the next show, Accidentally on Purpose, with Jenna Elfman, who is pretty much a comic genius. The rest of the cast and the writing are not the greatest, but she is awesome. I remember her being great in Dharma and Greg too.

    Deco's picture

    Good list. Any execs reading this??


    When you consider the doubt and even open hostility that Sackhoff faced taking on a female version of Starbuck and how she later made the role her own despite this - and brought the fanboys (and girls) to their knees in the process - how could people still not see what talent and personaltiy she brings to the table? I can't picture many actresses that could've pulled that off.
     
    So glad to see Brooke Smith on the list. Gone (from TV) but not forgotten. I'm one of the disgruntled-as-long-as-I-breath people concerning her shoddy treatment from Grey's. My standing hope is that she gets some envelope-bustin' role on a cable show with some guts and gets the acclaim she deserves. 
     
    And Elizabeth Mitchell should def. be on the list. Love her. 
    nicole eggett's picture

    maura tierney

    i loved her on ER especially when she acted with sally field, that was really good television
    polkadotwings's picture

    same here

    She was amazing on ER. And her with Sally made some of my favorite episodes.
    AudreyD's picture

    Four More

    I agree with the person who suggested Summer Glau on the EW list. That one episode of Terminator where she visits the library every night was stunning. Also, I know not many people watched In Treatment the first season, but Mia Wasikowska, who played the young gymnast, was exquisite. And newly underrated is Lea Michele of Glee. She was on Letterman a few weeks ago and he had no idea how amazing she is. And then there's Lauren Graham. Until she wins an Emmy, she will be underrated in my book.

     

     

    Becca's picture

    I totally agree with you on

    I totally agree with you on Lea Michele and Lauren Graham 

    Don't argue with my superior wisdom, okay? -Dana Fairbanks <3

    Becca's picture

    Woo Alyson Hannigan is

    Woo Alyson Hannigan is legen-wait for it!-dary!!

    Don't argue with my superior wisdom, okay? -Dana Fairbanks <3

    Lauren's picture

    I agree the most with the

    I agree the most with the Chandra Wilson comment. That woman's talent is outstanding. She doesn't get enough praise.

    Ditto on Sara Ramirez. And I think Jessica Capshaw is flourishing on Grey's - seems she is a great actress too! I've never been impressed by Shahi's acting, but she is real hot, so I'm surprised she's as under-rated as she is!!!

    Go here for my view on all things lesbian: http://allthingslesbeau.blogspot.com

    Viorica's picture

    Wow, Elisabeth Moss looks

    Wow, Elisabeth Moss looks SKINNY. Didn't she (or her character) have a baby at some point? It looks like she's wearing a corset or something. Ouch.

    ______________________________________________________

    "The state does not belong in the bedrooms of the nation"- Pierre Trudeau

    Jazzie's picture

    I definitely agree with

    I definitely agree with Maura Tierney being underrated. Same with Parminder Nagra, and anyone in ER who wasn't George Clooney. God, I miss that show...

    I'm glad they included Allison Mack on the EW list. She's probably the best thing to come out of Smallville, and let's face it, Clark would be completely lost without Chloe, let alone Lois.

    carolinagrrrl's picture

    I am loving this list.

    I am loving this list.  (And the shoutout--thanks, Linster!)  Definitely with many of you on the Chandra Wilson sentiments, and Sara Ramirez should have definitely been officially on the list. 

    I would also suggest Kerry Washington and Allison Janney. I know Janney has had some bigtime roles and has a dedicated following, but she still doesn't get the notoriety she deserves. I used to think the same thing about Jane Lynch, but Glee is definitely changing that.

    ----------------------------------

    www.twitter.com/carolinagrrrl

    www.dudetmi.com

    Nerdtron5000's picture

    Totally agree with Katee Stackhoff but i was kind bummed

    to see no Katey Sagal love-  She was hilarious as Peg Bundy, Cool as hell as the voice of Lielaa and now shes one of the best parts of FX's Sons of Anarchy.  

    I love Katey Sagal and think shes immensly underated...both as an actress and as an incredibly attractive middle aged woman.

     

    Thats my nerdy two cents.

    dragonlady07's picture

    OT

    <3 pats

    Kay's picture

    CSI girls

    I'm glad they included Marg Helgenberger, but if they were going to pick an under-rated actress from CSI, they should have picked Liz Vassey.
    garanger's picture

    Sarah Shahi =  NUMBER ONE

    Sarah Shahi =  NUMBER ONE
    luv girlz a lot's picture

    yeah, sarah shahi is

    yeah,

    sarah shahi is amazing.

    CindySR's picture

    Kristin Chenoweth

    Kristin Chenoweth has to be the MOST underrated actress EVER!

    I mean, God, the women has talent, is incredibly hot, sings like you could have never imagine a petit lady like that could sing...

     

    And yet... she still can't get a job!

    I just don't get it...

     

    ---

    "Another life saved by girl on girl action"

    monica_ca's picture

    But she just won an Emmy

    I'm not sure that you can still consider her 'underrated' after that.
    CindySR's picture

    Yeah but...

    I do because not even with that emmy she can get a job...

    Not even with an Emmy! How can you call that? Unfair? Injustice? Stupid? I still believe she is underrated as her, now dead, show was...

     

    How is that no one can see the magic in this woman? Well no one who can give her a show... I mean.

    ---

    "Another life saved by girl on girl action"

    Totiki's picture

    Tracie Thoms should have been on it

    I fell in love with her when I saw her in Rent(how cute was she as Joanne?) and think she is brilliant and so versatile as an actress. When I saw her in other stuff(Like Cold Case) I didn't recognize her, she has that ability to change her face I think. I wish she'd be in a romantic comedy...Preferably a lesbian one but I'll take anything

       

    ...not that I'm not objective  

     

    the_chill's picture

    Poor choice of words?

    I know that all of you at AE are probably some of the most sensitive and thoughtful writers out there when it come to political correctness, but I have to admit to be taken slightly aback when I read:

    "Get over that breast cancer, friend, so you can show us your stuff again soon."

    I know it was meant as playful, but telling someone to "get over that breast cancer" in conjunction with "show us your stuff again" (even though I know you were refering to her acting skills) is a tad distastful in my opinion...please don't hate me.

    monica_ca's picture

    I completely agree

    Seemed to be a very 'awkward' sentence at the very least.
    the linster's picture

    Yikes!

    Indeed, I meant her acting skills. I reworded it -- thanks.
    SaffronLove's picture

    I vote

    Tyne Daly.  Easily the most underrated television actress ever.  

    ------------------------------------------------------------ 

    The most beautiful smile is the one that struggles through tears--Graffiti on a bridge outside NYC 

    Totiki's picture

    Oh yes. I loved her on

    Oh yes. I loved her on Judging Amy. Is she a regular on anything now?
    SaffronLove's picture

    Dragon Dancer

    She is supposed to be on "Burn Notice" sometime next year, and has made appearances recently on TV (she was in a "Grey's Anatomy" ep.)   

    Cheers!

    ------------------------------------------------------------ 

    The most beautiful smile is the one that struggles through tears--Graffiti on a bridge outside NYC 

    Lunakiss's picture

    Recognition of Underrated Actresses

    I love the show Lost and I could never keep my eyes off of Yunjim Kim, definitely one of the most underrated actresses. She has a  stunning appeal about her-her acting, her aura, her looks-everything. She had me  at the movie The Joy Luck Club.

    I'm so glad you mentioned her.  

    I agree w/ the posters about Tracie and Jasika 

    twitter me @ www.twitter.com/brownskinfaery

    DV8's picture

    Underrated Actresses

    Jasika NicoleJasika Nicole on Well, I have to add my women from "Fringe" . . .  Anna Torv and out lesbian Jasika Nicole . . .  Who I think totally rocks!  I hope to see her in some more stuff soon!  Plus she is really hot!!  LOL  I also agree with all who were mentioned above!  I agree wtih Traci Thoms -- She ROCKS ALSO!

    Just for information:   Jasika Nicole from

    In case picture does not appear (having major problems today! LOL) http://www.flickr.com/photos/dv8bydesign/?saved=1

    LIVE  LOVE  LAUGH      On Twitter  @DV8ByDesign

    InTransition 's picture

    I think

      I agree with most of the picks up there but  Lena Headey  should have been there as well, she is amazingly talented and unfortunately under-used.

    ~ I've been spending too much time in California
    Where your feelings change but seasons never do
    And in my dream last night I felt a storm was coming
    But awoke to sunny skies of baby blue...
    And I've

    InTransition 's picture

    I think

    (accidental double post. internets having isues. sorry)



    Openwide01's picture

    Please come back

    I love me some brooke smith