Welcome to AfterEllen.com!

Enter your AfterEllen.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Lesbian and Bisexual women in Entertainment and the Media

Megan Fox is not the next Catwoman

Megan Fox, I just wanted to let you know you can have this Catwoman costume — when you pry it from mine and Michelle Pfeiffer's cold, dead hands.

It's none of your business what we were doing with it, and yes, we also have the whip, and it's none of your business what we were doing with that either. The point is, you and I both know that Chris Nolan is not going to cast you in the next Batman movie. It's not that you're not awesome as a &mdash what's your role in Transformers, again? Oh, right — bikini-wearer, but superheroes and robots are not the same thing.

You know who doesn't seem to know that you're not going to be the next Catwoman? The Internet. It's hard to open up Google Reader these days without finding six or seven blogs claiming that you've locked up the role. It is out of control this week, thanks to an "article" in The Sun. They've even put your head on Halle Berry's body. (I agree: it's an abomination.)

So, why don't you take some time from your busy schedule promoting Your Jennifer's Body to shoot down the rumors? I'll be over here casting the actual nextCatwoman. It will save Chris Nolan lots of time, and we can finally put this issue to bed.

Potential Catwomen now that we know this Megan Fox thing is never going to happen:

Anne Hathaway — The flip side of the corrupt Catwoman is the vulnerable Selina Kyle. You have to believe one to believe the other. We like Hathaway tortured (Rachel Getting Married), but we loved Get Smart so much that we bought it on DVD. Why not combine the tortured/action magic. That's what Batman is all about.

Eliza Dushku — She's not your typical A-lister, but part the pull of Batman is the Indie-gasm we get from seeing Maggie Gyllenhaal and Aaron Eckhart rock summer blockbusters. Dushku is a cult favorite and might be just the kind of Batman villain coup we've come to love.

Rosario Dawson — She was the voice of Artemis in the new Wonder Woman animated movie, and Catwoman's sultry inflection is almost half the battle. It's time for Dawson to make the full throttle leap to permanent superstar, and Catwoman could be the way for her to do it. Plus, Sin City proved that full-on leather agrees with her.

Emily Blunt — How about a British Selina Kyle and an American Catwoman? That'll befuddle Batman/Bruce Wayne! (Her accent throws us, that's for sure.) Like Dushku, Emily Blunt brings the Indie(ish) card into play. She doesn't have any action credentials to speak of, but after seeing her in The Devil Wears Prada, we know she'd have no trouble welding a firearm.

Eva Mendes — There is something naturally feline about Eva Mendes, and we can't overstate the importance of lips inside that Catwoman face mask. She's a seasoned green screen-er after playing Sand Saref in The Spirit, and there's no doubt she's got the seductress thing down.

Leave your casting suggestions in the comments, and let's stop this Megan Fox thing once and for all.

  • StuntDouble's blog
  • Login or register to post comments
  • Sarah's picture

    How about...

    Jordana Brewster..? :)

     

    I really liked the idea of Cher being Catwoman. I was incredibly disappointed when I found out those rumors were false.

    Babyjune's picture

    Jordana!

    I think Jordana would be an excelent Cat Woman. 

    My votes would also include Angelina Jolie, Carrie Ann Moss (I miss her wearing leather, what can I do?), and Eva Green.

    Strawbs's picture

    Eliza Dushku

    For The Win.

    Hell to the ye-ah.

    Melissa Hsu's picture

    Yup.

    my thoughts exactly.
    DrNo's picture

    I vote for Eliza Dushku

    She can be bad or sweet plus, Dushku can rock out in leather

     

    Eliza in Leather

    Mags's picture

    I concur.

    That she can. That she can. 

     

    Very occasionally, if you pay attention, life doesn't suck.
    -Joss Whedon

    Kate Mac's picture

    Forget Eliza....

    What about you! Yes YOU Dr. No. <insert purr noise.> We might need to do a lil bio about you on our blog! Hit us up if we can. We have our fingers crossed.

     

    "Yeah we both got dreams we can chase alone or we can make our own."

    www.lezzbuzz.com @lezzbuzz  www.shedate.com

    Melissa Hsu's picture

    eva eva eva

    Eva please!
    j's picture

    agreed.

    im so tired of straight men nudging me with their elbows and begging me to agree with them that megan fox is hot. whatever. anyone with boobs can run around in a bikini next to a hot car (a la transformers). im over it.

    either eva or rosario as cat woman for the win, for sure.

    but the picture of anne hathaway with that cat mask has me rolling all over the floor clutching my sides, giggling like a child.

     

    -j (http://homou.blogspot.com)

    Mars's picture

    EMILY BLUNT!

    I could see her as cat women.... 

    Maybe I shouldnt watch the episode of house were there are people with horse fetishes while Im fantising about emily blunt as my cat....

    .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .  .

    SneakerHead's picture

    Michelle Rodriguez

    i'll say it again, Michelle Rodriguez!!
    deathbyblonde's picture

    Let's see if I can add a few

    Well, Emily Blunt and Rosario Dawson already good ideas...

    How about:

    Amy Acker-  She is good at playing cute and eeeevil.

    and, since I'm thinking about Joss Wheden, how about one of my all-time faves:

    Christina Hendricks - Especially if they're going with a sex-kitten thing for her in this movie.

    Sarah Paulson - Because I love her lots and she is sexy as all get-out, but in a bit of an unassuming way and has a bit of a retro vibe to her.  And she can act.

    Eva Green -  If she could do the the "mild-mannered pedestrian alter-ego".

    Dru42's picture

    You mean Joss Whedon,

    You mean Joss Whedon, right?

    Anyways I totally agree on Amy Acker. XD 

    TPol's picture

    Hmm

    who better to defeat Megan Fox than....Olivia Wilde!! Have you seen her eyes? Purely feline!
    Thembani's picture

    Hm...

    Eva Green is an excellent suggestion.

    How about:

    Jennifer Garner
    Uma Thurman
    Lucy Lui

    My wishful-thinking suggestions:

    Lena Olin - The woman can do the two-faced badass + vulnerable thing like nobody's business.  I'd pay to see that movie.

    Monica Bellucci  - It might require some serious suspension of disbelief that nobody would recognise her accent.  But seriously, Monica Bellucci in a cat suit, wielding a whip?  ...Ahem.

    Salma Hayek - Same for the accent, but again.  Cat suit.  Whip.  Hayek.

    Jennifer Beals - Cat suit.  Whip.  Beals.

     

    Luna's picture

    Summer Glau 

    Summer Glau  !

     

     

    -I speak in random thoughts

    Lunakiss's picture

    I Got One Question About This New Catwoman Remake

    What was wrong with Halle Berry playing the sulturous bad/good-girl kitty? Why is there a need for a new Catwoman film? Okay that was two.

    skyocence's picture

    Oh there is need...

    ...cause as much as I like Halle Berry, that movie was utter crap in pretty much every department - I didn't even like the full catwoman costume. I think that Ms Berry would agree.

    The mark to meet, in my opinion, is Michelle Pfiefer's potrayal of catwoman. Once they have that, they just need to build from there and they'd be set.

    Lunakiss's picture

    Michelle P Did An Excellent Job W/ Catwoman

    My mom didn't like Catwoman w/ Halle Berry at all. I liked the mythological background of catwoman but I guess a lot of people don't. I like Catwoman w/ Halleberry.  Michelle actually has her beat.

    If they're going to do Catwoman, I hope they add a storyline or something. Don't make a Catwoman film just to get another smokin' hot actress in a kitty suit.  I need substance w/ my cat ladies. -Gen Xers at work.  Speakin of Cats...do ya think they'll bring Thundercats to screen?

     

    Débora's picture

    eliza!!

    she's the one 4 me!
    dilo's picture

    Kate Beckinsale!!

    All these ladies are great suggestions!!!, but i will go with Kate Beckinsale...i remember that leather outfit for her role in Underworld..HOT!
    Marion's picture

    omg YES!

    We've all seen her "leather-ness" in that outfit when she was Underworld and HOT DAMN she looked SEXY to the MAX! ^_^
    pancreas's picture

    Eva Green or Eliza might be

    Eva Green or Eliza might be nice but Michelle P is the original and I don't think we need another. There are plenty of other Batvillains that haven't been filmed yet.
    Penny Winterr's picture

    I want casting against type

    I nominate Amy Adams.  She's only played sweet types, but I'd love to see her break out the claws.  HAWT!

    For just sheer mind-numbing sexy voiceedness and gorgeosity, Eva Green.

    letterstoveruca's picture

    I love Amy Adams, but I do

    I love Amy Adams, but I do not think she plays the villianess role well.  Adams was quite horrible in "Cruel Intentions 2."  Granted, what wasn't bad about "Cruel Intentions 2?"  Still, I just can't see her pulling off the dark sexiness that is Selena Kyle/Catwoman.

    My vote is for Christina Ricci or Chloe Sevigny.

    Penny Winterr's picture

    That was early on for her

    She's grown so much as an actress (I've seen all her movies, some many, many times).

    I don't know if she'd want to go there, but I'd love to see it!

    letterstoveruca's picture

    I agree it was early in her

    I agree it was early in her career, but I she hasn't grown that much, at least from what I've seen.  I'm actually an Amy Adams fan, but her performance in "Doubt" is comparable to "Catch Me If You Can" and her performance in "Enchanted" is similar to her performance in "Drop Dead Gorgeous," which was actually before "Cruel Intentions 2."  I love Amy Adams, but I just don't think she is right for Catwoman.  Anyways, to each his own.
    McPants's picture

    Agreed

     I'd like to see her break out the claws. Prrr and RAWrrrR..

    I think Rachel McAdams would rock the catsuit too

     

    ---------------------------------------------------------

    You're boring baby when you're straight.

    Sarah's picture

    Actually...

    I'd like the idea of Jennifer Beals playing Catwoman than anyone else..

    majordoctorsam's picture

    ah, yes

    I can get behind this casting.  as a complete batman nut, I've been having a hard time with these new incarnations.  And casting catwoman is beyond difficult after lee meriwether, eartha kitt, and michelle pfeiffer.  not to mention the spot on voice of Adrienne Barbeau.

    and now I'll go continue to geek out in a quiet corner.

    "this is why emotions were bad - they made her think about inappropriate and unsettling things."

    Kate Mac's picture

    Little bit o' Bette Porter Makes the World Better

    I think this is the best suggestion yet. I didn't think of it but when I read your post I whole heartedly agreed!!! Dean Porter was FANTASTIC and I think as cat woman she could be amazing! Nice idea!

    "Yeah we both got dreams we can chase alone or we can make our own."

    www.lezzbuzz.com @lezzbuzz  www.shedate.com

    Julie's picture

    Eliza Dushku!!

    So easy to imagine her in a Catwoman suit.  I think Olivia Wilde from House would be awesome too, just not sure how well she would do in an "action" film.
    La Sopa Atómica's picture

    If I were casting...

    I'd go for Eva Green first.  I think she can pull off the duality that is Catwoman just fine.  And then there's that voice of hers...yummy!

    I'd consider either of the Underworld chicas too...Kate Beckinsale or Rhona Mitra, they can rock that leather outfit's world.

    And call me crazy but I'd love to see Julianne Moore as Batwoman/Kate Kane.  I know she's prolly a bit old for the part, but whatever, she's a smokin' redhead. 

    Kortney's picture

    O.W.

    Well, since Megan Fox (stop hating) is out of the running apparently, my totally irrelevant vote goes to OLIVIA WILDE.

    Or, for some reason the idea of Kate Walsh in black leather makes me all kinds of happy :)

     

    venus sans furs's picture

    Kate Walsh wouldn't even be

    Kate Walsh wouldn't even be in the first 10 names that came to my mind, but now that you've said it I find myself intrigued and completely open to the idea of her as catwoman (or even poison ivy if Nolan decided to go the eco-terrorism route).
    weeklyhowls's picture

    Kate Walsh

    Omg, Kate Walsh as poison ivy? that's a GREAT idea. i would loooove to see that!  :)
    venus sans furs's picture

    It's catWOMAN

    I don't think any actress under 30 should even be considered for catwoman. You listed a lot of way-too-young candidates. We need a woman in the role.

     

    (my one exception is Olivia Wilde and even then my bias for her hottness doesn't quite win out over who catwoman is).

    phantomavatar08's picture

    Finally!!!

    I was reading through the comments thinking the exact same thing!  Glad you pointed it out, though, saved me the trouble.  For some odd reason Birds of Prey has been on my mind all day, and the thought on who I would cast as Catwoman was one of the focal points.  We need someone who can pull off not just the sexy, asskicking, claw wielding....what was..oh, yeah, well not just all things Catwoman, but also the tenderness, nievety, kindness...wha-- Man not again, well also everything that embodies Selina Kyle.  As far as the look, I don't know why but I'm really inclined to a lady of color.  Preferably an actress that actually is of color, but I'd settle for one that can pull it off, convincingly.  Eva Mendez and Jennifer Beals come to mind.  Lena Olin and Sarah Shahi might be treding the edge, age wise.  If it is someone white I think Kate Beckinsale could deffinetly walk in Michelle's boots, though I doubt anyone'll be able to fill them.  As for Emily Blunt, I might have mentioned before, but to me she would totally kill as Oracle, but that's just me.  Okay, semi-rant over.

     If I ever start the think straight, this heart'll start a riot in me

    -Paramore(That's What You Get)

    emznz's picture

    The baroness....

    Siena Miller was awesome as the Baroness in GI Joe, she can definately pull off leather...
    polkadotwings's picture

    Rosario

    I really like the idea of Rosario Dawson. I really don't know anything about Catwoman so maybe I'm not the best to choose someone lol, but I think it seems like a good idea.
    Paraphase's picture

    Milla Jovovich, Famke

    Milla Jovovich, Famke Janssen, Katie Sackhoff, and Angelina Jolie would get my vote for Catwoman. Maybe Mia Kirshner, she always tapped into the darkside with Jenny
    Anna's picture

    Odette Yustman!

    *faints* She is my selection. :D

    I wish they would make BATWOMAN before any of the others when it comes to films of comics. I've fallen in love with her :p

    Psynomi's picture

    Olivia Wilde FTW!

    Olivia Wildr WOOT WOOT! Hell yes...

    Olivia in leather, can you think of anything better in the world?

    phantomavatar08's picture

    Yeah...

    ...Everything I'd find under the leather! ;D

     

     

    If I ever start the think straight, this heart'll start a riot in me

    -Paramore(That's What You Get)

    katemc39's picture

    Good suggestions all around

    I'm liking everyone's suggestions--particularly Anne Hathaway, Odette Yusman (and though I don't think she's right for the part--I love ANY mention of Famke Janssen).  I'm going to add Charlize Theron to this game.  But, only if she dies her hair for the role.  Selina's a brunette.
    Jill's picture

    What!!!!!!!!!

    What!!!! Megan Fox ISN'T going to be the next Catwoman. . . .THANK GOD!!!!

    I think StuntDouble should be the next catwoman, she'd look hot in leather!!

    Jill

    Fia's picture

    hmm

    olivia wilde, rebecca romijn, jeri ryan or rhona mitra for the role, i reckon they'd be pretty good.

     

    but i can definitely see kate walsh as a role of poison ivy, that'd be amazing

    Dru42's picture

    I'd go with Eliza Dushku or

    I'd go with Eliza Dushku or Amy Acker.

    Or like someone said Lena Olin. lol. She is awesome. Though Jeri Ryan could also be interesting. XD

    Loren the Strange's picture

    I think...

    Eliza Dushku would make an absolutely wonderful Cat Women. 

    Olivia Wilde, I think that one is self explanatory. 

    Also, Malin Akerman? Heh, well that one is a guilty pleasure. 

    However, Megan Fox? No, no, no. I am so completely over her and all of the media attention she causes. So glad she won't be Cat Woman.

    Shug's picture

    I LOVE Megan Fox

     I really do.

    Whats with all the hating on Megan Fox????? I think she would have made an awesome catwoman. I've seen interviews with her and she seems really funny and likeable I think shes bloody marvellous. It's not really her fault shes utterly stunning...pah!

    So lets stop be catty :P and give Megan some love...........meoooooooooooow!!

    JUST SHUG.