Welcome to AfterEllen.com!

Enter your AfterEllen.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Lesbian and Bisexual women in Entertainment and the Media

Lesbian Scientistics: The "Rolling Stone" comedy issue

It is a truth universally acknowledged that lesbians love funny women. So when this week's Rolling Stone showed up at Scientistics headquarters, we were beside ourselves with merriment, because Tina Fey, Sarah Silverman and Amy Poehler all made the cover (front, back and pullout) of the golden age of comedy issue.

Inside the magazine were loads more of our favorites: Mindy Kaling, Margaret Cho, Wanda Sykes, Phyllis Diller and Julia Louis-Dreyfus — an all-star comedy list!

We couldn't help but notice that the funny guys got lots more coverage that the funny gals. How much more, you ask?

We didn't dwell on that, though, because there was research to be done. Below we've condensed the content to help us determine which woman is funniest.

When I knew I wanted to be funny

Tina Fey: I knew I wanted to be funny around seventh or eighth grade. Mostly I wanted attention, and being funny was the most possible way for me to get it, I wasn't good-looking enough that I would end up in Playboy at 19. That wasn't gonna happen.

Sarah Silverman: When I was three, my dad thought it would be hilarious to teach me swear words, then have me say them to his friends. They would laugh and laugh. I realize now the laugh was pure shock value, but it felt really good, and I've been chasing it ever since.

Mindy Kaling: In junior high, there were a lot of really ugly guys who were popular because they were funny. I was like, "Wow, comedy is the great freer of hideous people." It was an incredibly liberating thing. If you ask a girl, "What do you want in a guy?" 99 percent are like, "I just want him to be funny." I thought, "If that applies to women, I'm set."

My worst bomb

Phyllis Diller: We've all bombed. Even Jesus bombed.

Tina Fey: We used to do prom shows at Second City — a show at 2 a.m. for kids after their high school prom to keep them from drinking and having sex. So you can imagine how happy they were to be there.

Wanda Sykes: I was working in a club in Newark, and somebody bent over and his gun fell out on the floor. And everybody was checking their coats to make sure it wasn't their gun.

Funniest TV Ever

Mindy Kaling: I don't think a person could love something as much as I loved In Living Color. It was just this great mix of the Fly Girls, which is exactly the kind of body I had when I was 12, and it had Jim Carrey and the Wayans brothers. It was a meeting of all the things I ever dreamed of being.

Tina Fey: Even I have drifted toward reality TV. On some level, I am a lazy housewife, and I watch cooking shows. I don't want to watch comedy. I get enough comedy.

Julia Louis-Dreyfus: The funniest television that I'm watching now has to be Fox News.

The Internet:

Mindy Kaling: I don't get a lot of time to go to a lot of stand-up, but I've been watching it on YouTube. This day and age, you can kind of see every stand-up show the next day because someone illegally taped it.

Amy Poehler: I find that most things are funnier live. Except for monkey's sniffing their own but and falling out of a tree. That's the only thing that translates. When you see monkeys scratching their ass and falling out of a tree live, you laugh, and when you see them on YouTube, you laugh.

In conclusion:

Agree or disagree with our choice? Who else should have made Rolling Stone's list? And would you not agree with out Scientistics team that the actual worst bomb is the Jager bomb?

Trish Bendix's picture

Mindy Kaling

I love Mindy. I just read a great interview with her in Missbehave, too. What a wonderful writer!
DKHO's picture

Funniest Women EVER?

Any such list really must include Whoopi Goldberg.  The woman's got it all: movies, talk-shows, stand-up, everything.  Nor should we overlook Lily Tomlin and Kate Clinton.
Alyssa's picture

well,

i love amy. i do, but i do think that tina is funnier than amy.
frogprincess's picture

Wanda Wanda Wanda

Wanda rocked it on the TRUE COLORS tour here in LA this summer.  I once saw her slay on the Tonight Show.  Talking about gay marriage before anybody else was...she did a bunch of other stuff too that was borderline edgy for the Tonight Show that night.  She was fantastic.  The audience and Jay Leno were a little - wow you're kind of walking out there on that rope....but Wanda set 'em up and knocked 'em down.  The ballsiest comedy set I've ever seen on the Tonight Show.
Anonymous's picture

Wanda Sykes

I mainly know her from the movie "Pootie Tang" her character is hilarious.  I remember she had a television show which do not last too long. 

I am liking the kiss between Wanda and the other woman.  Where is that scene from?

Jen Rae's picture

Jager :(

The Jager bomb is hands down, by far, the worst bomb ever. It's path of distruction far outweighs that of the H-bomb, Mars Attacks and Kevin Federline.
Imsuchanerd's picture

Lucille Ball and Carol Burnett

I realize these two women aren't the most popular picks of this day and age but what pioneers for today's comediennes!  I remember watching the Carol Burnett show with my family and LOVING the fact that this woman was making a living making people laugh!  And, to this day, I can't get enough of I Love Lucy re-runs.  "Vitametavegimen" is one of my ultimate favorites. :)

Other "funny women" I adore: My late grandmother, my mother, Lily Tomlin, Lisa Kudrow, to name a few. :) 

sleepylobster's picture

I love them both

I love them both, but Carol Burnett had a segment at the end of her show where she would take questions from the audience... live, and she was always hilarious. I don't know what other comedian would do that today. Today I can only think of Ellen Degeneres in even slightly approaching her in quickness.
Anonymous's picture

I have heard of Carol

I have heard of Carol Burnett through my mother and others.  They have explained how funny she is; an example my mother likes the skit where Carol Burnett wears curtains as apart of her dress.  Haha.  (I have seen that skit on television when they show comedy skits from the past)

Lisa Kudrow is funny and intelligent (I have heard and read).  I really like her in the movie "Romy and Michelle's High School Reunion", that is one of the most funniest movies ever to me!

I want to add Janeane Garofalo because she is hilarious in "Romy and Michelle's.." as well.  Others I would like to add are: Debra Wilson, Nicole Sullivan, Stephanie Weir, Mo Collins, and Alex Borstein (all from "MADTv" which is a favorite show of mine). And actress Jane Lynch.

jennifer from pittsburgh's picture

Pie Charts!

Made me think of Ross Perot.
But I would have to say that Wanda Sykes is the funniest woman working today. priceless timing and content. Decades ago I absolutely loved Joan Rivers. I loved her all the more because my father hated her. It seemed that she must be on to something if she could piss him off so much.
The thing about Tina Fey - she's probably the best comic writer right now, man or woman. The sheer volume of funny that she has to write is astounding.
ThinkArt's picture

hello!

Ellen DeGeneres

Molly Shannon

 

...and yes I agree with  Lily Tomlin, Lucille Ball, and Carol Burnett too

Mays's picture

Mindy Kaling

Hahahaha, I, too heard everything she said in Kelly's voice.

Love these women!

Anonymous's picture

Jenifer Lewis

Jenifer Lewis is hilarious!  I like the movie she stars in called "Jackie's Back", it is funny. 
Modern_Nature's picture

I agree

Tina Fey is my pick, she's outstandingly funny, hot enough to enter my dreams when Kate Beckinsale isn't in them, and she's got brains ( and those wicked hot glasses). I also think Liz Feldman is pretty damn funny too, nothing makes me laugh more then watching a talk show host hit on their guest, great fun.