News, Reviews & Commentary on Lesbian and Bisexual women in Entertainment and the Media

Jane Campion thinks women are fantastic, but men have all the money

On Sunday, Jane Campion was one of many directors honored at the Cannes Film Festival. One of many men, that is, but the one and only woman.

When asked why female directors are so scarce, Campion didn't mince words:

"I just think this is the way the world is, that men control the money, and they decide who they're going to give it to."

Well, that seems true enough. Only 3 of the movies at Cannes this year were directed by women: Marjane Satrapi's Persepolis, Naomi Kawase's Mogari No Mori, and Catherine Breillat's Une Vieille Maitresse. (I'm guessing it will be a while before most of us get to see any of those — if you're one of the lucky few, give us your review.)

But Campion also seemed to suggest that if women did have control of all the money in the world, they'd share it:

"When I think of what's fantastic about women, it's their generosity, their intuitiveness, their capacity to trust emotions, to be emotional, to nurture, to promote peace, to care about the planet's environment so their children can inherit it," she said. "Those qualities aren't sexy for guys, but (they're) quite natural in women."

Wait. Nurturing, peace-loving earth mothers? Hmm. That sounds kind of traditional, especially for someone who's generally considered a feminist director. But I'll admit that I often have no idea what Campion's trying to say. I saw Sweetie in the early '90s and am confused to this day. And although I found The Piano and An Angel at My Table brilliant, I also found them befuddling. Luckily, Campion's success stands as a feminist achievement, no matter what her films might stand for.

Campion's next film will examine the romance between John Keats and his "young neighbor," Fanny Brawne. I wonder who called the shots in that particular pair?

  • scribegrrrl's blog
  • Login or register to post comments
  • browne's picture

    I often think that women

    I often think that women like Jane Campion and Germaine Greer - who similarly idealises women as endlessly generous and nurturing compared to 'lazy', 'selfish' men - will be in for a disappointment if we ever get to the day when women do rule the world. I mean look at a leader like Margaret Thatcher - not exactly warm and fuzzy, was she? Not too much caring or nurturing going on there.

    I don't think I'm particularly generous, and there are certainly men out there (and women as well, of course) who've done a lot more to promote peace and the environment than I have. I'm always suspicious of people who make huge generalisations based on gender.

    gitd's picture

    hmmm...

    >> Jane looks like Gloria Romero (Ph)

    maybe Campion is overgeneralising without pointing out the differences of women. but i believe she is just trying to say that men are not as great as women in general :)

    ~ the greatest law is not punishable yet rewarding ~

    Trix's picture

    Typical of her

    Sounds like she's still spouting that cultural feminist "women are all goddesses or victims (or both) and men are swine" line that she's fond of (well, it seems to boil down that way).

    Can't stand her movies, frankly, except for the cinematography. I wish NZ film directors weren't so wanky and abtruse (with perhaps the exception of Peter Jackson) - it's embarrassing.

    inalagirl's picture

    Jane Campion

    Hey, give her a break.

    Judging by that photo,she's no spring chicken. I'm thinking she probably comes from that era where cultural feminism was the "bees knees".

    Oh and lets leave Maggie Thatcher in the dark, distant past, where she belongs. One would be hard-pressed to describe her as human, let alone female.

    Agent Starling's picture

    Quote: Oh and lets leave

    Quote:

    Oh and lets leave Maggie Thatcher in the dark, distant past, where she belongs. One would be hard-pressed to describe her as human, let alone female.

    True, but take heart - she's got to die soon. And what a glorious day it shall be. :o)

    dj z's picture

    I love her films

    Sweetie was the first film I saw that was outside the Hollywood mainstream, and I have been in love with Jane Campion ever sense. I don't really care if she has post-structuralist views on feminism. She's beautiful.

    User login

    Recent comments

    After Ellen home page on logo online