Welcome to AfterEllen.com!

Enter your AfterEllen.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Lesbian and Bisexual women in Entertainment and the Media

Lesbians and karaoke: Laugh-riot, cringefest, or good clean fun?

Earlier this week Lori and I unexpectedly found ourselves at an L.A. lesbian karaoke bar with Karman and Bridget McManus, watching a drunk lesbian in a bad sweater butchering John Cougar Mellencamp's "Hurts So Good." It hurt, all right, but not in a good way.

But Bridget put the audience in stitches with an over-the-top rendition of Queen's "Bohemian Rhapsody" which involved running around in circles, ranting about how she's "just gotta getta out of here," and fake-sobbing "Nothing really matters" while slumped over a stool. I laughed until my face hurt.

Then someone else took the stage, and one bad version of a Pat Benatar song and a pretty good Phantom of the Opera duet later, and I'm still undecided: Lesbians and karaoke — like peanut butter and chocolate, or like peanut butter and an intoxicated lesbian in cargo pants who lost a bet and now we all have to suffer for it?

I've only done karaoke once myself, and then only because the bar was empty, it was my friend's birthday, and the music was so loud it was more like lip-synching (I can only carry a tune well when I'm singing in a group, not solo). I don't even remember what song it was, except I think it was something country that I knew from childhood ...

Which brings me to my next question: for those of you who karaoke (yes, I've decided it's a verb): What do you sing? And do you sing it seriously, or over the top? And for those of you who don't karaoke, what's the one song that might get you to do it, if the bar was empty and no one else would know? Or if you were in your living room with friends?

I'll admit I'm tempted by Carrie Underwood's "Before He Cheats" — before you scoff, have you seen the music video? It rocks!

Seriously, how can you hear that song and not want to sing along? But don't tell anyone I said that, or I'll dig my key into the side of your pretty little souped-up four-wheel drive...

  • Sarah Warn's blog
  • Login or register to post comments
  • amberb's picture

    Love drunken karaoke!

    I won't get up there until I've had at least 5 beers, but then it's no holds barred. Keep in mind that I'm a horrible singer.

    My favorites include Since U Been Gone (everyone sings along and you can bounce up and down a lot), Baby Got Back (you don't actually have to be able to carry a tune), and Papa Don't Preach (you can channel Madonna and pretend you're strutting around with a leather jacket thrown over your shoulder like she did in the video).

    On night a friend convinced me to do Take Me or Leave Me from "Rent" with him. I got to be Maureen. It was a trainwreck ... but sooo amusing.

    You should totally do Carrie Underwood. The song and video are both awesome -- although it's hard to picture Carrie shooting whiskey and knocking out headlights with a  Louisville Slugger. Can she even lift one of those?

    OrangeGirl17's picture

    "You should totally do

    "You should totally do Carrie Underwood. The song and video are both awesome -- although it's hard to picture Carrie shooting whiskey and knocking out headlights with a  Louisville Slugger. Can she even lift one of those? "

     LOL! Hell yes, she can! She is from Checotah, OK - and grew up on a farm! Whiskey and teaching men "lessons" are recreational sports around here... Okie women don't put up with a lot of ***t.

    A Muse's picture

    awesome

    I would have paid to see Bridget do that :P

    ------------------------------------------------------
    THE UNOFFICIAL JILL BENNETT FANCLUB WEBPAGE
    http://www.freewebs.com/ujbfc

    Heather01's picture

    ditto!!

    ditto!!
    fever ray's picture

    Bonnie Tyler - Total

    Bonnie Tyler - Total Eclipse of the Heart, because it's such a classic karaoke song. And heart-breaking. Just like my singing, really.

     

    Berna's picture

    I like karaoke

    but I still haven't done it yet. I would have to be really drunk to do that. Or maybe in a group of people. Anyhow, I like watching people doing that, it's fun.
    Zleznjiyh's picture

    Singstar

    I have all the records on my sisters singstar games... :D

    Now, singstar at home is one thing, karaoke out is totally different... Often I get sucked in to it by a friend going all " WE HAVE TO SING", me shrugging since I have had 4 beer/ciders/drinks saying choose a song. And when I get the mic in my hand I won't let go. But I do enjoy listening to various renditions of songs, laughing at the badness because it amuses my music nerd part.

    I blame my education.

    Phantom's picture

    Fellow Singstar-fan (whoring it since 2005)

    Yep, definitely sameways here.
    It got to a point at one time, when noone wanted to sing with me anymore because of their guaranteed loss. :(
    Nevertheless...
    Karaoke's luff, period.

    Nelfy's picture

    best.party.game.ever

    I just love singstar, it's the best game to play at a party. I like most of the songs and it can be so much fun when you make fun of some of the songs. I think they should have a queer game with melissa etheridge and kd lang and georg micheal and so on... that would be sooo great. or a movie version, that would be cool too. I went to a karaoke bar sometimes, but I would only sing a few songs that I knew really well, like Shania Twain's "Man! I feel like a woman!"

    I would have love to see bridget - you don't have a video of that by any chance?? 

    "Normal is not something to aspire to, it's something to get away from." ~ Jodie Foster

    camnista's picture

    one day...

    damn, i was half-expecting video of the aforementioned events to follow after the jump. 

    there is a hardcore karaoke girl inside me that i have yet to let out. i have only been once, and didn't have enough drinks in me to make it up there...though i am itching to.  one day....

    Chase's picture

    Tell me more

    Come on Camnista, sing your heart out. So, what songs would you do IF you had enough drinks to make it up there into the spotlight.
    camnista's picture

    well...

    hmmmm...i am secretly really into Heart, so probably "Barracuda" by Heart. I'm wondering what this says about me......  :P
    Chase's picture

    Barracuda it is!

    I think it says that you have a wildness inside you and want to get up  and sing your heart out. Good song, sexy, wild, badass "you'd have me down on my knees, wouldn't you barracuda"

     

     

    camnista's picture

    i'm tempted...

    hmmmmm.....that just might be it. i'm tempted to do it now...
    Brunette's picture

    My Best Friend Wedding..

    Come on...Cameron Diaz singing? real bad? and then winning the crowd? Thats a good one, can't get enough of it.. lol

    The only time I karaoked, it involved Drag Queens, "we are the world", and of course, Mister Jose Cuervo!! "He" does has some seriuos power of convincing me to actually go in public and ...sing..ha!

     

    Cassandra's picture

    Good times.

    Oh man, I love karaoke. I mean, I hate it, but I also love it.

    I only tend to do songs I absolutely love and can fully commit to, or else you end up standing there during the instrumental going, "Why am I up here again....?"

    A small sampling of the atrocities I've been responsible for: A Little Respect by Erasure, Crying and Crazy by Aerosmith, American Pie, Achy Breaky Heart, Common People and Hotel California. I'm sure there are loads of others but I (mercifully) can't remember them.

    One of the best karaokes I've ever seen was a guy doing Kate Bush's Wuthering Heights, complete with dance moves. It was awesome.

    I've always, always wanted to do The Devil Went to Georgia but I've never felt strident enough yet. Proud Mary, too, and Baby It's Cold Outside when I find the right dueting partner. Someday!

    "it's hard to picture Carrie shooting whiskey and knocking out headlights with a Louisville Slugger. Can she even lift one of those?"

    Carrie Underwood can do anything she wants!

    tiff2's picture

    Thankfully all the karaoking I've done are in private rooms...

    If I were in a karaoke bar, I think I'll be able to empty the place quickly. I love karaoke though. It doesn't matter how bad you are, it's just fun to sing your favourite songs out loud with your friends.

    When I go to the KTV(what we call karaoke here) with my friends, we basically line up all the english songs available and sing for at least 3 hours. We cover ABBA to NSYNC to Katharine McPhee to Justin Timberlake. And this is just for english songs. I haven't even mentioned the ones in Mandarin.

    When I'm singing, I try to sing it realistically, unless its a song that you can go OTT on such as Dancing Queen. The funny thing is since my voice is low, I usually have to cover the guy parts of songs, or I sing the low parts while my friends come in on the higher parts. But lately I've been belting out in the higher range too. I haven't killed anybody's eardrums....yet.

    shamWow's picture

    My first and last karaoke song was ...

    I got you babe from Sonny & Cher

     

    hahahaha it was pretty funny because me & my best friend are both ingredibly untalented when it comes to carry a tune. The problem was the people with whom we played singstar - they were all good at it ... and they made some mean jokes (*ssholes!)

    But being bad at it doesn't stop me and this friend of mine to have a myspace band lol, so if you're into real bad but superfunny karaoke songs, go to our site -->

    www.myspace.com/thedudlorchester
    Pyewacket's picture

    No solos for me.

    Tipsy group karaoking is the best!  And it doesn't matter how good or bad you are...all it matters is that you are having fun!  I think Love Shack by the B-52s for such occasions is my favorite but I can well understand the attraction to a good robust karaoke version of Before He Cheats!
    Monty's picture

    Not well, but

    I do manage a passable Rock and Roll All Nite by KISS when playing Karaoke Revolution.
    frammie's picture

    Careless whisper

    The only karaoke I ever did was Careless Whisper from George Michael, and only because I was on the other side of the planet...

    There may be some Chinese people who'll never want to hear that song again, though.

    Holly's picture

    Since U Been Gone

    Since U Been Gone is my goto song everytime I do karoke. It's such a fun song to completly sing off key too.
    A***da's picture

    Tracy Chapman

    haha, I never have and -with god on my side- never will karaoke... Buuuuut.... if I did it would have to be "Fast Car" by Tracy Chapman, or "Hands Clean" by Alanis... fortunately for humanity, that day will never come... I wouldn't do the girls any justice.
    Leahashra's picture

    Of Tunes And Traps

    I've done karaoke a fair few times.

     Like...three times.

     The last time, a group of friends (yes, lesbians) sang Journey's "Don't Stop Believing" and horribly and tragically sober--thank goodness the rest of the bar was drunk enough for us.

     I've a decent voice, apparently jazz is my style because I pulled a wicked Diana Krall last year, so I'm not one to run from karaoke. I'd rather be the one cheering on the drunken, funny folk--would've loved to see Bridget singing. Actually, wait, I would pay gold to see Karman get up and give a tune a try. Seriously.

     Karaoke and lesbians=peanut butter and chocolate. Hands down. We do it so well even when we would do better not singing at all. :-) 

    angel winters's picture

    I would

    attempt to sing Madonna songs...Attempt!!

    dido1047's picture

    It happened once…

    My “friends” gave me a little too much liquid courage and sent me one stage to sing I Can Only Imagine. I got as far as the second chorus before tripping over the mic and passing out on stage. BTW, we were at a Baptist church function…I was the most popular girl in the youth group after that one!
    grilledokra's picture

    I love karaoke

    I love karaoke, give me "Eye of the Tiger" anytime, sober or intoxicated, and I will sing it will all the passion in me. And someday, I will sing the song in tune, too.

    I wish I could give a karaoke performance even just 1% as awesome as this one...

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FU0xTkqDvyQ&feature=related

    Jinx's picture

    Wow!

    grilledokra wrote:
    I wish I could give a karaoke performance even just 1% as awesome as this one...

    You and me both!  Wow, what a voice she's got!

    Eliza's picture

    Erasure - A little Respect

    Erasure - A little Respect is high up there amongst others. I think the best approach to Karaoke is to go with the cheese. Cheese it right up, and you'll find that you have a winner.

     

    Call me Al is always a winner, and around this time of year, Fairytale of New York is always an A lister. That's without even breaking out the musical barrel.

     

    A long road

    http://www.asearchforlove.blogspot.com/

    Eliza's picture

    D'oh!

    How could I forget Bonnie Tyler - I need a hero?

     

    A long road

    http://www.asearchforlove.blogspot.com/

    Radioactive Girl's picture

    Cringefest....

    I went to a bar in London a few months ago and stumbled across a lesbian karaoke night. It was a total cringe fest! The reason? Most of the singers where taking themselves too seriously! The put a whole lot of emotion in to the songs with a lot of fist clenching and head shaking! It was terrible... but funny! Funny in a bad way, like trying not to laugh because someone’s feelings may be hurt. BUT if it’s all for a laugh, your jumping around, you can't sing and it's not serious then it is great! Good singers shouldn't go up either, because it’s normally boring.... simply because they are too good.

    But thumbs up to people who go up and sing in any case because you need guts. I rarely have the guts unless i have drunk a certain amount of beer. I play in a band and sing and I think is 100 times harder to sing at a karaoke night. The last song I sang at a karaoke night ( + beer) was Mr Bombastic by Shaggy... it was funny... and terrible!

     

    www.myspace.com/slowgun

    IfOnly's picture

    I love songs with too much (many?) words

    I've actually put a lot of thought into this exact question. Why?, you ask. Well, because I think that sometime in the future I will be dared, or maybe I'll lose a bet, and I will have to get up and karaoke (yes, verb). My thoughts went something like this: Which song would I love to sing? Total Ecplipse of the Heart is no 1. But wait, that bit with the powder keg? I don't even know what that's about and it's too much lyrics sung with too much power without breathing time. No, that won't work. Ooh! Tracy Chapman's Fast Car. That would be awesome. Again with too many words but this one's do-able. But oh so depressing. Then it came to me. Son of A Preacherman. A feel good song. A lot of words. I know it by heart, every beat. And I don't care about the meaning of it.

    Now Singstar is a whole other thing. There's no singing involved in Singstar, it's all about cheating the game, and it's easy too! But it's fun. Fun, fun, fun! Best party game ever. Favourite? Total Eclipse of the Heart.

    I've only karaoked one time, but it doesn't count. I was forced to at a b-day party and didn't get to choose which song. The punch line: It was recorded and the CDs were given out as gifts at the same party.

    katy Gnosis's picture

    Karaoke to Shakira

    Its almost tradition ever since my cousin got a karaoke for Christmas like 5 years ago that we unleash the classic Shakira songs in Spanish after a little too much eggnog...Also Andrea Bocceli and some Alejandro Fernandez but yeah thats REALLY when we have gone overboard with our Grandpas medicine cabinet...

    eighTTen's picture

    for fun...

    i guess i karaoke to what i can sing.Even i know i sing somehow worse or so-so..i will still sing.For the fun.Hahaha...

    Most of the time me and my friends will sing to oldies songs.Like Mariah Carey "Hero" or BSB or some Malay songs.The fun of singing together and be crazy at the same time.That's what you call "drunken singing"

    Why not..sing and dance to her music;)

    Vickie's picture

    My karaoke secret:

    "Baby Got Back" - Sir Mix-a-lot. Cheese it up and you'll have a crowd of amused people, or, if you're really lucky, a crowd of bootylicious gals boogying right in front of you. This is why people become rappers, my friends.
    ice cream's picture

    celine dion/meatloaf

    "it's all coming back to me now"

    performed with equal parts passion and tongue-in-cheek 

    Kirsty's picture

    karaoke is the best thing ever!

    Me and my mate always go on the karaoke its always either elton john and kiki dee- dont go breaking my heart or a bit of anything else thats just as cheesey you have to love to london karaoke bars they are amazing!
    kittyofthemohawks's picture

    no doubt don't speak

    is usually what me and my mates wail away to, whilst trying to sound as monotone as possible.

    secretfox's picture

    queeraoke

    My best friend and I did a legendary rendition of sk8er boi...knee slides and everything. That'spretty cool to rock out to.

     

    Otherwise, gotta love 'Proud Mary,' 'Hey Mickey,' 'Material Girl,'...

     

    Can't believe you guys actually have lesbian karaoke bars. Closest thing we get to Karaoke for queers over here is a token night where you're guaranteed to be belittled by the brutal drag-queen host (regardless of whether or not you were asking for it!)

    Gweeky's picture

    took five shots of bourbon

    and equal amount of beers to stand up (among a group no less) to do "Dancing Queen" (don't you laugh!!) and "Like a prayer" just over a year ago at a Xmas Karaoke party. We were told that we rocked the first and ruined the second (I think there was a two or three drinks inerval between the songs, so I couldn't say I'm surprised that our abilities deteriorated).

    BUT: all the time I was trying to pluck up the courage to stand up on my own on that tiny stage and sing "Jolene". I ain't no Dolly but I really love that song. And maybe I will stand up there and butcher that lovely song sometime in the future. (By the way, the guy who won did an excellent rendition of "Hector" by Morissey).

    rotezora's picture

    I've never partaken

    and I was out with my girlfriend recently and she wanted us to go into a karaoke bar. I couldn't even tell her. Should I come out?

    A friend and I used to enjoy Sunday afternoons at a pub and they used to have karaoke with people from a local old people's home. We really loved it, got to know their names, who was flirting with whom, etc. Any way, after a couple of months, people started looking at us with a "put out or get out" look. We knew we couldn't compete. So we got out permanently.

    Good times, good times...

    offkilter's picture

    Alanis

    Two years ago I spent my birthday in San Antonio w/my sister who persuaded me to get up there - after drinking.. oh everything - w/her. You know. For moral support. The excuses afterward ranged from "I was singing you just didn't hear me" to "my mic wasn't plugged in". Nevertheless, I was left hangin' to handle You Oughtta Know - which is actually quite fun to sing. That's the beauty of karaoke - it truly doesn't matter what you sound like as long as you're having fun. Who cares! If people really cared about this issue would karaoke machines regularly show up at BARS? Oh and if my sister ever asks you to sing w/her for moral support - she's a damn liar and you'll be going at it solo.  

    NOLAGypsy's picture

    I Karaoke in Korea, Can You?

    But seriously, karaoke (or "noraebang" as it's called in Korea) is huge in Seoul. It's something the uptight, uber-conservative, middle-aged businessmen and the purple-haired, leather collar sporting, post-teen punks have in common -- the Koreans love to get drunk and sing...badly.

    Don't get me wrong, there is a plethora of foriegn folk who give it a whirl, too -- myself included. Some of my sapphic sisters and I like to scratch our singing itch every so often. In fact, there are several karaoke spots very close to the gay heart of the city, fondly (or not, depending...) referred to as "Homo Hill".

    The Korean style is much easier for the stage-shy, as it's less of a bar and more of a collection of separate rooms that your rent by the hour that have large tvs, speakers, and various other karaoke apparati (usually including a tamborine or two, which Bridget would love).

    While I would love to sing (and, despite better judgment, attempt to sing on occassion) songs in the stylings of Mariah, Whitney, or Alicia, my karaoke is much better recieved by an audience when I do (even more) campy versions of Queen, the Eagles, White Cherry, Rick James, etc. Cher is about as feminine as my voice can go these days.

    NOLAGypsy's picture

    Gay Karaoke in New Orleans

    Oh, I also wanted to say that for any of you in the New Orleans area that there used to be (and, I believe, still is) a fun karaoke fling at one of the gay bars in the French Quarter called, "Good Friends." It's on St. Ann a couple of blocks from Bourbon, and in the middle of gay New Orleans (though pretty much all of New Orleans is a little gay).

    Sadly, the regular MC of the show is no longer working there (another unfortunate side-effect of Katrina), but she was a rather fun butch bartender who would always open the show with her fabulous rendition of Connie Vannett's "The Pussy Cat Song."

    For any lesbian who likes to karaoke, this really is an excellent choice. For those unfamiliar with the song, google it --trust me, it's worth the google effort.

    Honestly, everyone knows someone who has "just a friendly little cat."