Welcome to AfterEllen.com!

Enter your AfterEllen.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Lesbian and Bisexual women in Entertainment and the Media

Rachel McAdams and Helen Mirren don't necessarily mirror reality

This year’s list of Pulitzer Prize winners and finalists includes a large number of women. Of course, like many women, I’m thrilled to hear this news, but another part of me is thrilled for what this will do for pop culture. What’s the connection you ask? Well, I’ll tell you.

Last weekend I went to see the new movie, State of Play, an entertaining thriller about D.C politics and journalism. In the movie, Russell Crowe plays a seasoned reporter who teaches a naive blogger (played by Rachel McAdams) the ropes of journalism.

While he schools Miss McAdams, he also lectures his boss, the uber sexy Helen Mirren, about journalistic integrity.

I enjoyed the movie and I liked Crowe’s character, but I kept thinking, why does Crowe have to be the teacher/wise reporter? Why can’t it be his boss, Helen Mirren, teaching him the ropes? Why when we see movies about news reporters, do we always see the seasoned male teaching the ambitious, but inexperienced, female reporter?

Hopefully art will imitate life and we’ll see more movies in the future of hard hitting Pulitzer toting female reporters. Here are some of the winners from this year's Pulitzers:

Public Service Journalism: Las Vegas Sun, and notably the courageous reporting by Alexandra Berzon

Explanatory Reporting: Bettina Boxall and Julie Cart of Los Angeles Times

Music History: The Hemingses of Monticello: An American Family by Annette Gordon-Reed (W.W. Norton & Company)

Annette Gordon-Reed

Drama: Ruined by Lynn Nottage

Fiction: Olive Kitteridge by Elizabeth Strout (Random House)

Congratulations ladies. Keep up the great work.

CailinBainne's picture

The Life of David Gale

In The life of David Gale Kate Winslet played a journalist who had to bring around an annoying male intern with her. Just thought I'd give you an example

 

“The trouble with me is that I am a vindictive old shanty-Irish bitch." Eleanor Medill Patterson

Arafel's picture

I didn't get the sense that

I didn't get the sense that Mirren's character needed to be schooled at anything. She came off as understanding everything, but also as a women who was under a lot of pressure from the corporate overlords who are ruining journalism.

I really enjoyed the movie overall, and thought it might have been one of the better ones I've seen in the last 10 months or so.

Sorry I missed Church; I was busy practicing witchcraft and becoming a lesbian - refrigerator magnet answer to Pat Robertson.

Kyra's picture

She's gorgeous

Rachel McAdams....never ever go away.

 

DameRhetorica's picture

Broadcast News

Holly Hunter's Jane Craig (top) certainly didn't need any men telling her what to do, and her character was based on the real-life example of Susan "Z" Zirinsky (bottom), a CBS executive producer who more than holds her own.

Hunter as Craig

Z

thatgirloverthere's picture

Changes

I haven't seen the new 'State of Play' but I really like the BBC original. In that the character of Della is not naive (or a blogger). The main character in that does seem do just what he wants to regardless of the boss but it never seems like he is better or more of a teacher than him. Yes the boss is 'him' in the original, something which I would have assumed would have helped the chances of Helen Mirren character being a strong one in the film, guess maybe not.

When I see this film I imagine I won't be bothered by the male/female roles of the film, more the fact that they've gone and stuck cliche where there need be no cliche and was none before.