Welcome to AfterEllen.com!

Home »
jamie murnane

Nerve's "40 Sexiest Frontwomen" includes gay and gay-friendly musicians

While I usually tend to scoff at most "best female" whatever lists, I gotta hand it to Nerve for its compilation of the Forty Sexiest Frontwomen in Rock History. Sure, it may seem gratuitous or sexist at first, but Nerve is all about sex, so it works. And even if I don't agree that The Kills' Allison Mosshart should come in last, I can appreciate the list's inclusion of the gay ladies.

Gossip's Beth Ditto comes in at No. 39, with the Nerve editors saying, "what's perhaps most appealing about her, oddly, is the strong sense that she hates lists like this and generally could not care less about her perceived sexiness."

So true. It seems Beth Ditto could care less where she falls on any random blog's list, which makes me love her more and want to make her No. 1. So, she'll just have to learn to accept that.

At No. 30, is electrosexual extraordinaire, Peaches, though you could argue she's not exactly a frontwoman, but a solo act — unless you count her backing band, The Herms (short for hermaphrodites, naturally).

"How one makes the career leap from schoolmarm to Moses-bearded electrodiva is beyond us, but we're not going to look a gift horse in the crotch," says Nerve. Agreed! Oh, and Peaches' new album, I Feel Cream, will be released May 5.

Coming in at about half-way down Nerve's sexy frontwoman scale is Carrie Brownstein. The Sleater-Kinney (I may never get over their breakup, fyi) guitarist is attractive, for sure, but it's her live performances that make her sexiest, I've always thought. And Nerve agrees: "Whether it was her onstage grin or simply the quality (and quantity) of her guitar solos, any bonehead in the audience could tell that Brownstein really liked being in a rock band."

Seriously, there's no bigger turn off than a musician who looks completely bored. Brownstein was always into it, which makes people into her, even more."

Joan Jett gets the closest to the top of this list, at No. 5, "with her porno lips, rockstar proto-mullet and runway body." Why that alone doesn't qualify her for No. 1 is beyond me. But I do completely agree with the Nerve editors when they say her "profound historical importance to women in rock belies the fact that at fifty, she's still doing her thing and looking staggeringly good to boot."

While that's it for the queer inclusion (out of 40, it's not great odds, but they are certainly great choices), the rest of the list includes some truly great musicians, who just so happen to be sexy, including Rilo Kiley's Jenny Lewis, Yeah Yeah Yeahs' Karen O and Le Tigre's Kathleen Hanna.

I could go on and on, but you can see for yourself.

Anyone missing you think should be included, or any surprises with Nerve's choices?

Comments

riotgrrrljaz's picture

i really like the list! they missed 2 tho'

first, it's really cool that they put kathleen hanna in #3!

these two women are more in the heavy metal scene and i'm surprised they weren't on there because they're beautiful.

1-Angela Gossow from Arch Enemy

2- Otep Shamaya from Otep

but other than that I agree with the list!

______________________________________________ 

We Want Revolution Grrrl Style Now! -BIKINI KILL 

jamlawgirl's picture

Otep

Yep huge oversight there. Don't care if you're into metal or not, the woman is pure sex.

 

Jen Sabella's picture

Missin' Kathleen!

She needs to come back into my life.
xénos's picture

I agree on plenty

and I love how the main article picture is of Jenny,

but I would have put Emily Haines on there.

 

Trish Bendix's picture

Allison Mosshart

Allison is my fashion idol, even when she looks kind of dirty. She deserves to be higher than number one, but not higher than Carrie B.
Bodhi's picture

I can respect a list that includes Carrie Brownstein

But I don't get Peaches. Sorry.
Emma's picture

Tunstall

As long as Jenny's there I'm all good. And Karen O, Regina, Feist and Fiona were there too so it's a pretty nice list. I'd have put KT Tunstall in there though, she's amazing.

___//♫♪ let your girlfriend do what your boyfriend can't

Captain Jax Havok's picture

what the hell?!

where was hayley williams!? >:[ i'm appalled!!
jamie's picture

I would guess that her age

I would guess that her age has something to do with it.  Hayley is really attractive (and is almost certianly a big homo, despite dating whatshisface from NFG), but she qualifies as "barely legal".  Maybe the editors didn't want to be creepy.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
once ironmade,
heart or spade
no one can steal you 

 

emma-face's picture

Hayley

Hayley Williams should most definitly be on that list...at number one! 

 And she is gay - my proof lyrics to that's what you get "If I ever try to think straight this heart will start a riot, start a riot in me"

amor vincit omnia

I.saw.sparks's picture

Allison would be my n°1!!

Allison would be my n°1!! And Beth Ditto my number two! They are both so amazing on stage (even more when they are together on stage! I saw The kills and the Gossip on stage all together---awesome^^)
alex's picture

great list!!

neko case and nico? chan marshall? janis and stevie nicks? love it. topped by tina turner? heck yes.

-------------
http://rightmindleftcoast.wordpress.com
Paperback-Writer's picture

Omg! I love this!

Jenny Lewis as the cover was great. She is amazing.

Also, did anybody read this person's story on when they met Chan Marshall?

"Once upon a time in Hollywood, we snuck backstage at MTV's Shortlist Awards in search of a quiet place to smoke. Leaning against the garden wall, alone, was a willowy brunette. She took a sparkly strand of her tank dress and tied it around our head like a bandana. She lit our cigarette and asked our name. She had a low voice and a tough-and-skittish alley kitten vibe. She smiled a lot and encouraged us to follow our dreams. We fell in love. And only found out months later it was Chan Marshall. — M.L."

I would have fallen in love =)

Lisa's picture

good list.

but yeahh, like someone else said emily haines should be on the list in my opinion.  i read the full list and was glad to see Regina Spektor on there though..

Kingbee's picture

Thank you for that Carrie B

Thank you for that Carrie B picture. Drool. That is all.
Steph's picture

Nina Persson!

AH! I'm so excited to see Nina Persson on that list! (from The Cardigans). that band is SOOO underrated. breaks my heart.

Having said that, I'm surprised Maja Ivarsson from The Sounds wasnt on that list. That woman knows how to work a stage!
Jeannette's picture

THE SOUNDS!

I totally agree!  MAJA NEEDS TO BE ON THERE!  God, I love that band.

Joan Jett - my first celeb crush on a girl -- or at least the first one I recognized as a crush -- so very glad to see her on there.  I also had a big thing for Brody Dalle from The Distillers 'back in the day', followed by Karen O -- oh my lord, Karen fucking O.

Also:  Janis Joplin, Stevie Nicks, Tina Turner, Kathleen Hanna, Debbie Harry, Gwen Stefani, Chrissie Hyde, Patti Smith -- very glad to see all of these lovely ladies up there.

mitch's picture

Wow

I can't believe Joan Jett is 50! She looks great for her age.
jamie's picture

Sleater-Kinney

You are not alone.  I probably will never get over their breakup either.

 

 

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
once ironmade,
heart or spade
no one can steal you 

 

Shespider's picture

no Maja Ivarsson?

Are u kidding me? she's so badass on stage they need to see this video http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O4oSWHn3bPA  gahd look at that jump lol. she's so hot! and I love The Sounds...and I agree Emily Haines should be there too. 

 

 

The boat of life is rocking And you may stumble too, So while you talk about me...someone else is judging you.

Bob Marley - Judge not

Gret's picture

No Pat Benatar!

Pretty good list.  Would have expected Pat Benatar on it though
CailinBainne's picture

Good enough list but

I would have liked to have seen Brody Dalle, just look up the distillers live performances at reading on youtube and even though she might have been high off her head she looks absolutely amazing.

“The trouble with me is that I am a vindictive old shanty-Irish bitch." Eleanor Medill Patterson

boo99's picture

Where's Brandi Carlile?

What? No Brandi Carlile?  What about Shirley Manson? I would have had them both in there for sure.......maybe that's just me?

Gotta love Deb Harry, Joan Jett, Liz Phair, Siouxsie, Stevie & Karen O - HOT! HOT! HOT! 

Great list! 

 

 

lovecatcadillac's picture

My two favourites...

Are Lisa Rieffel and Shirley Manson on the list? They are both pure sex onstage!
Janay's picture

Thanx!!!! Changed My Life

haha i'm such a dork, if anyone has learned anything by following me on Twitter the last few days is that i'm completely madly deeply now in love with Sleater-Kinney!!!!!!!! I want to marry Carrie Brownstein she's sooooo hot!

Thanx for this article, cause I read this and thought "i better check them out" cause I read about them quite a bit on AE, and so I did just that early yesterday and um..wow I'm in love i LOVE them, i see what the "big deal" is and hype is right on point! In fact there should be more hype I was completely blown away...

Now I'm depressed cause after being on the deep emotional level with the music, it sunk in that they were not together anymore and my heart is breaking a little bit:-( 

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 

"I know how I was born and I know that I have no choice. I know it may not show on the color of my skin, but I know it’s in my heart and in my soul."-Sara Quin

HelenS's picture

Another gay lady on the list...

hi! Kate Pierson of the B-52s is on the list and she is now out and proud. Also I can't believe Kim Deal isn't there. I would also pick Jennifer Herrema of Royal Trux / Rtx. And how about Wendy Melvoin of Wendy and Lisa.
pancreas's picture

Shirley Manson

Any list of this nature without her is worthless.
Theagenda's picture

I think I will be on this

I think I will be on this list someday. 

 

 

ha! funny. 

single_syllables's picture

I agree with HelenS - where

I agree with HelenS - where the hell is Kim Deal??  Pffft.
Captain Jax Havok's picture

and another thing

where was lacey mosley?? :/ she's gorgeous!
Home » Nerve's "40 Sexiest Frontwomen" includes gay and gay-friendly musicians

ACTIVE FORUM TOPICS