Welcome to AfterEllen.com!

Enter your AfterEllen.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Lesbian and Bisexual women in Entertainment and the Media

"Top Chef" mini-cap: What part of lesbian do you not understand?

Someone has a crush. Wait, sorry, let me rephrase that. Someone has a totally inappropriate and terribly misguided crush. Yeah, that's better. You see, Stefan has a huge crush on Jamie. He has even made a pair of pants for Jamie's stuffed animal. And this isn't the first time he has given her small tokens of his cluelessness.

As Stefan himself puts it, “I think she is sexy. I love Jamie.” Fair enough, Stefan. Jamie and her kick-ass tattoos are sexy. But there is one teeny, tiny little problem.

Jamie: “Stefan, come on, does the word 'lesbian' mean anything to you?”

Yep, that'd be the problem. Deluded, thy name is straight dude chasing a lesbian.

As the chefs enter the kitchen, they find host Padma Lakshmi but no guest judge. Instead, this Quickfire Challenge will be palate against palate as they play “Identify the Ingredient.” They draw knives to be paired off and then go head-to-head seeing who can name the most ingredients in a sauce. Jamie gets paired off with Stefan. Sadly, he wins their round and then tells the cameras, “How about that ass whipping?” Boys are so weird.

In the final round, Hosea and Stefan square off. Hosea prevails and feels great about it afterward, and not just because he gets immunity. He says, “Stefan is tough, he has a huge ego ... And I out-palated him.” In fact, the other chefs' general bemusement and downright loathing of Stefan is a recurring theme in this episode.

In the Elimination Challenge, the chefs again draw knives to get placed in teams. Radhika is very clear about whom she does not want to be teamed up with: “I would rather be on Satan's team than Stefan's team.” As an added bonus, Satan would be a whiz at flame grilling.

The chefs get split into groups of “Old,” “New,” “Borrowed,” “Blue.” You see, Padma is throwing a bridal shower for one of her girlfriends. But who is the lucky lady? Well, none other than Top Chef judge and Food & Wine magazine editor Gail Simmons.

They break into Team Borrowed (Jamie, Ariane, Radhika), Team Blue (Fabio, Leah, Melissa), Team Old (Jeff, Stefan, Hosea) and Team New (Gene, Carla, Daniel). At Jamie's suggestion, Team Borrowed goes with an Indian-flavored lamb dish. Team Blue goes with Chilean sea bass from the deep blue ocean. Team Old goes with a trio of heirloom tomato dishes. Team New, inexplicably, goes with build-it-yourself surf 'n' turf sushi.

As they start cooking, Tom comes in to check on their progress. He seems particularly perplexed by Team New, which has had a problem with its rice and is also including Daniel's “fusion barbecue sauce” with its sushi. I think Tom sums up all of our reactions best when he asks, “Barbecue sauce?”

Back at the house, Stefan and Carla are on Jamie's bed. Stefan is trying to get Jamie to kiss him. No, I am kidding. He even tells the cameras later, “Me and Jamie, we kind of have like an edgy thing going on.” Well, if by “edgy” he means “lesbian” and by “thing” he means “totally uninterested,” then I guess he is right. Alas, he means it the literal way.

Jamie: You have the hots for the lesbian ...
Stefan: If you win the challenge I get a kiss.
Jamie: You can kiss my cheek, if you're lucky.
Stefan: No, you can kiss my mouth.
Jamie: NO. I can't even believe we're even having this discussion.
Stefan: (Kissing sounds.)
Jamie: You are so gross. Uuuughh!

Elsewhere, a happier and 100 percent more likely couple is playing cards. But it seems, despite all their flirting, Hosea and Leah are “just friends” because she has a boyfriend and he has a girlfriend. But what happens at Top Chef stays at Top Chef, right?

The bridal shower begins, and Gail tells her assembled guests that they are “the largest table of hot-looking ladies I've ever seen in my life.” I think if you put Padma at any table, you could probably accurately make that statement.

In the kitchen, the real drama is underway. Team New is dealing with soggy rice and Daniel's decision to put mushrooms on Carla's salad without asking her first. He also uses the word “spluge” when discussing his food and says the women will want to take their clothes off after tasting it. I think I just threw up a little in my mouth.

Team Borrowed is having its own problems with the lamb. Ariane has cut the cooking time too close and now it's a race against the clock to make sure they don't serve it too raw. But all the other chefs help with plating, and a crisis is averted.

Gail's boss, Food & Wine Editor-in-Chief Dana Cowin, serves as guest judge for the Elimination Challenge. As the courses are served, the ladies' reactions can be summed up best as Team Old — yum; Team New — what is this and why do I have to eat it?; Team Borrowed — yummy yum; and Team Blue — this looks like old-people food.

At the Judges Table, teams Old and Borrowed get called in first as the favorites. Jamie's puree gets props, as does Ariane's lamb and Jeff's tomato sorbet. As Dana is set to announce the winner, Jamie says under her breath, “I want this win.” And then, well, I think what happens next can best be explained in pictures.

Ariane wins and Jamie is the unhappy bridesmaid once again. Poor Jamie, the Cougar Cook snuck in and stole your Calphalon winnings.

But the unhappy almost-winner has nothing on the miserable losers. Teams New and Blue get called in and Tom spares not the rod for he clearly thinks these chefs are spoiled children. While Carla and Gene admit Team New made mistakes, Daniel says he was “unbelievably happy” with his team's dish. I have no doubt that he is also “unbelievably happy” with the unbelievably stupid way he shaves his beard.

Tom then tells Team Blue that if they continue to cook the way they have, he “doesn't see you three being here much longer,” and he tells Team New, “I would love to send all three of you home.” Yeah, that's going to sting in the morning. But only one can leave so who gets PYKAGed? Blessedly, Daniel.

A stunned Daniel tells the cameras afterward that he didn't think the judges understood what he was doing, and he probably would have been able to stay longer if he had thrown his teammates under the bus. He then compares Top Chef to football, and I rejoice, again, at his departure.

Next week: Martha, Martha, Martha! Stewart, that is, will be the guest judge.

ColetteLala's picture

Jamie's Big Bag Of BS

Jamie really pissed me off last night. I was completely turned off at her "I should have won", "I'm always in the top three", "Always a bridesmaid, never a bride" BS. She's need to stop her complaining about never get enough recognition. All of the other chefs clearly know she's a top contender and a major threat. Her selfish attitude and always crossing her arms like a pouty baby is getting a bit tedious. She needs to grow up and cook her ass off and win this damn thing!

Having said that, Ariane should not have won either. How hard is it to cook a piece of meat? I can cook a juicy turkey or a not so rare piece of lamb, but you don't see me going around calling myself a "chef". Chefs are innovative, risk takers, creative.  All Ariane has proved is that she can cook without screwing something up.

Bug Eyes (can't remember her name) should have stood up for herself and flung those mushrooms at that disillusioned bearded guy.

I didn't care too much for Fabio when the show started, but he's really growing on me. I was on Team Jamie, but after last night I'm on Team Fabio.

Anyone else think Hosea and Leah's significant others are none too thrilled with them today? Who goes on tv and admits to flirting AND have a significant other waiting for them at home? Morons!

Joyous's picture

*giggles* Bug Eyes

I think I distinctly remember Rahdika sayin in the first episode that she doesn't want to be seen as an Indian chef because she's indian but can cook any type of food. Why does everythin she make indian style of indian flavored?
jennifer from pittsburgh's picture

TC

For Rahdika to use Indian flavors and influence makes perfect sense. In seasons past a lot of chefs have exploited their ethnic strengths for great gains. Casey (French, finals season 3), Antonia (Italian, final 4 season 4), and Ilan (Spanish, winner season 2) readily leap to mind.
To ignore your core experience just to be different can lead to unnecessary peril.
Joyous's picture

...

Well "She describes her cooking style as globally eclectic with a huge spoonful of love" That's on her bio and in that first episode she herself said she didn't want to be pegged because she had background in all types. Top chef has to be elcectic, not just one note. Hung won on technique even though he did mostly asian. Radhika has been in the bottom often.
jennifer from pittsburgh's picture

TC

Yes, but Hung did cook Asian, didn't he? He didn't distance himself from his primary style, although yes, he did augment it. As did Ilan. But your point is taken and probably correct about Rahdika. If she doesn't view her style as being primarily Indian, but globally eclectic, then maybe she's still searching for an identity for her own style, or she simply embraces everything and just needs more experience to refine her skills. Either way, at some point she's going to have to step it up. But then isn't that always the way?
LogLady's picture

agreed...

...with your points, but 'joyjoy' is correct in stating that radhika explictly said she'd rather not be known as "the indian woman who only cooks indian food" i understand her wanting to show off more of her influences, but when she makes such a bold, big statement and then goes 100% against it (hasn't she made an indian influenced dish in every challenge where it was at all possible? and only strayed from that when the challenge demanded it?) smacks to me of disillusionment on her part...either way in the long run you're right, at this point she needs to get in the game, she is not a serious contender imho....

Joyous's picture

yes

Maybe she is tryin to work with what she knows. And as you said, moving out of the comfort zone can spell disaster. I hope to learns to stretch out a lil more as time goes on
ColetteLala's picture

Stefan Theory

Here's a theory: I don't think Stefan is into Jamie at all. I think he's just trying to mess up her game and get under her skin. He obviously realizes that she's talented and is a serious contender and he's going to do whatever he needs to do to sabotage her. He's arrogant enough to think he can turn a gay girl straight so I wouldn't put it past him to be lying about the whole thing.
Formerlurker's picture

Someone as arrogant as

Someone as arrogant as Stephan wouldn't be at all threatened by Jamie, professionally.  I really don't think he's just trying to get in her head.  He wouldn't feel the need for that.  He assumes he can beat her fair and square because in the World of Stephan, he is God, so why resort to sabotage.  Sabotage is for insecure people who aren't as arrogant and egotistical as Stephan.  Yeah, he's really interested, probably because she is really cute and sexy and a big challenge for him.  Bleh! 
Formerlurker's picture

How embarrassing is

How embarrassing is Stephan's pursuit of Jamie?  I know some men see lesbians as a challenge, but he is really making a fool of himself on TV. 

I can totally understand how Jamie could feel dissappointed about coming so close each time and not winning.  She's very competitive.  That's not really a bad thing.  I like her and I'm pulling for her to win.  Even Ariane thought Jamie would win.  Th whole dish was her idea.  All Ariane did was cook the meat.  It's not that hard to do, but it's very easy to screw up if you aren't careful.  Personally, I think the person who created the flavor combination should have won.  Jamie got robbed.

I am really starting to like Ariane, and I love Carla.  She was trying to be a team player and not throw her teammate under the bus, but he totally ruined her dish with his ridiculous mushrooms.  Maybe she should have had a better response ready for Tom.  He was really unfair to her.  He can be a bit pompous sometimes.  Seriously, she couldn't fix the dish because she didn't discover that Ugly Beard had sabotaged her dish with the mushrooms until they were in the middle of plating, and then it was too late.  Maybe she should have said so, but then Tom would have criticized her for throwing her teammate under the bus, and he still would have said she should have taken better control of her own dish.  He isn't always reasonable. 

 

jennifer from pittsburgh's picture

TC

I'm still so pleasantly shocked at Ariane's culinary turn about that I'm a bit thrilled every time she finishes at the top. The Stefan fixation on Jamie is...I don't know what it is. Typical, I guess. She should just tell him to take a hike, avoid discussing it further with him, and leave it at that. I mean, no one is forcing her to accept gifts from him, right? She's encouraging him by accepting gifts and continuing to have a dialog. But then, maybe she's wants the ego stroke. Who knows? I don't care about the whole issue.
Formerlurker's picture

I think it's better to get

I think it's better to get along with someone you might have on your team in a challenge.  Besides, there is no point in burning bridges or making an enemy.  If Stephan wins or becomes a huge success, Jamie may want a job in his restaurant someday.  I've had men flirt with me before.  As long as you don't tease or lead them on, you can still be friendly.  Eventually they get over it and move on to more promising prospects, and you still have a friend.

rubbaduck's picture

the judging

the judges don't see all that we do until they actually watch the show themselves. no one knew that the lamb dish was jamie's idea. just like they didn't know how the mushroom fiasco originated. they could tell by carla's face something was up, but like they said, she should have spoken.
LogLady's picture

chances are....

....they did know the lamb was jamie's idea, those judging tables can take upwards of 2 hours (a friend was a contestant and he told me) there are a TON of things that we don't see and it's most likely that everything that we saw happen they heard about, albeit secondhand....ah the magic of editing....
hmmm's picture

not sure ...

We can take what we want from this, but I read this on Tom Colicchio's blog http://www.bravotv.com/Top_Chef/season/5/blogs/index.php?blog=tom_colicchio&article=2008/12/speak_up_listen_up#breadcrumbs :

 "A note about the winning dish: Viewers typically think that we judges are privy to all the info the viewers have by the time everyone's at the Judges' Table, but we're not. The cameras were rolling when the cheftestants conceived of their dishes, the viewers heard the chefs at the supermarket, in their loft, during prep in the Top Chef kitchen, but the judges don't see any of that footage in advance. While I pay a visit to the kitchen and ask some questions while the chefs are cooking, we basically just sample the food at the challenge and judge it from there. We give the chefs a chance to explain, clarify, and illuminate us when we're questioning them at the Judges' Table, and I, for one, wish they would use that opportunity more than they do. Jamie's carrot puree was terrific; Ariane's lamb was perfect. That's what the judges knew, and what they based their decision on. Jamie could have spoken up and taken deserved credit for having conceptualized the dish and been the team leader on it, but she didn't. That information would have been salient to the judges, who loved the whole dish, and it might have tipped the scales in her favor and earned her the win."

Formerlurker's picture

Are you a contestant on the

Are you a contestant on the show?  Which one?
Que9's picture

Team Jamie

I love jamie. And I get why shes upset, being a top contender and always finishing so close. Shes just a very competitve person that holds herself to high standards. I dont think her wanting the win or being upset about losing has anything to do with any person but herself. She just expects a lot from herself and gets frustrated when she rise to her own expectations.

That being said, the whole Stephan liking Jamie thing is kind of hilarious and kind of put offish. I think that he probably does have a crush, I mean come on shes really really cute, but at the same time they joke about it so its not threatening to her. They clearly banter about it, I dont think she is at all worried that hes actually going to try anything with her. Which makes it tolerable and kind of funny. Because big bad Stephan, is making little cutsie outfits for Jamie's stuffed animal.

Steph Has's picture

right there with you!

I am so on TEAM JAMIE!

 I think she is adorable! And by far the best lesbian chef the show has had yet.

I read an interview with her and she refused to mention her dating status because it was irrelevant to her being a chef - which I respect and totally makes me swoon even more.

 But does anyone know her dating status? Come on  SF lesbians I know the circle can't be that big!

Jenna's picture

I HAVE THAT SAME STUFFED DOG!!!

So Jamie and I have the same stuffed dog, so I spent the first 5 minutes of the episode freaking out about that.

 

Mostly I just can't believe Daniel and is lack of ability to see how bad that dish was.  I have to agree with Tom, if it was me I would have sent all of them home, but I think they made the right choice by sending home Daniel.  Carla annoyed me the most with her lack of input!  I have some classical training in culinary arts, and if someone put something on my dish without telling me, I would have freaked on them.