Welcome to AfterEllen.com!

Enter your AfterEllen.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Lesbian and Bisexual women in Entertainment and the Media

Natalie Portman gets ready for some hammertime with "Thor"

Natalie Portman is going to be the God of Thunder’s girlfriend in the new live-action Thor movie. While I sit back and let you absorb the what the who? of this news, I have to say my first reaction was to grumble.

Look, I have nothing against Mr. Hammertime. Also, nice hat. But in the long list of female movie characters that annoy me, “superhero girlfriend” falls somewhere between “hooker with a heart of gold” and “sassy best friend.” While there is nothing wrong with them per se, they’re just clichés and lazy storytelling devices.

And more to the point, why is the actress always the superhero’s girlfriend? Why can’t she be the superhero? Why can’t they get female superheroes right? Oh, Wonder Woman movie, where are you?

The list of female superhero films is thin and largely inauspicious. Catwoman? This is no way to say thank you for getting that Oscar, Halle Berry. Supergirl? Don’t get me started on that damn skirt again. Elektra? Well, that’s just a Victoria’s Secret commercial with kung fu.

Now, this new Thor film could turn out great. None other than Kenneth Branagh is directing and newcomer Chris Hemsworth (who plays Thor) looks perfectly capable of wielding a hammer.

Natalie will play Jane Foster. She was a nurse in the comics, but reports say her character will be “updated” for the movie. Gosh, maybe that means she gets to be a doctor now.

While I hope for the best with this film (the presence of Natalie and Kenneth does give one hope), I’m also somewhat resigned to the fact that — as with so much mainstream entertainment — the woman again seems to be the second fiddle, the arm candy, the damsel to be rescued from distress.

Wouldn’t it be nice if Natalie got to have the hammer instead?

Megan Rose Gedris's picture

Amen!

Amen!
scorpio54's picture

Superhero girlfriends

Jane Foster was Thor's girlfriend in the early 1960s. Since about 1965 this role has been taken by the goddess Sif, a fellow warrior. In recent appearances Jane Foster has indeed become a doctor.

Whenever kickass female superheroes are mentioned here I'm always surprised no one brings up Big Barda. A seven-feet tall, armour-clad warrior, she was created by comics legend Jack Kirby in 1971 and when we first see her in MISTER MIRACLE #4 she's wading into a fight and laying into all about her with her mace. The former leader of the frankly psychotic Female Furies, she's fled the world of Apokolips and its despotic ruler Darkseid in order to link up with Scot Free aka Mister Miracle, who she later marries - and how many couples are there in comics where the woman towers over the man? He's the only person she ever displays anything remotely resembling a softer side to.


There's one exchange in later years when they're unsuccessfully trying to live the surburban life that always makes me chuckle. It begins with Scot getting a call from the police to tell him that two men have attempted to mug Barda.

"Oh my God!" he says, appalled, "Are they alright?"

Ren's picture

Barda!

Hooray, someone else who knows of Big Barda.

I do hope the rumours of bringing back the New Gods are true, the death thing was heartbreaking and pointless. :(

We need Barda back, she was brilliant in Birds of Prey.

oscartg's picture

No

I won't be watching this due to the presence of "The Plank" as Thor. I hope St.Jack or FantaTan doesn't start getting big movie roles soon as well.
Obscura Wild's picture

Natalie with a hammer

I've been a fan of Natalie Portman since Star Wars, despite, well, being in Star Wars. And I fell in love with her in V for Vendetta (I mean really, she didn't have much to work with the way the Wachowski brothers adapted it. But the prison scenes had me in tears). So I have to say: Who wouldn't want to see her as the hero for once? (I'm not counting V for V here. Evey just doesn't play as big a role in the movie as the comic.) Besides, if she can do all that crazy Star Wars costuming, I bet she'd look better in Norse god(dess) wear anyway.
Strawbs's picture

Il watch it

Because its got Natalie in it, I'm there.
Ashley's picture

Love Natalie

Portman could make a movie worth viewing, simply by appearing in a role as an extra in a crowd.

She had me at "Where the Heart Is".

girlbeatsdrums's picture

The role doesn't sound

The role doesn't sound promising, but...Natalie Portman!! <3
emileezer's picture

remember this?

The little girl in Adventures in Babysitting always wore a thor hat.  I LOVED that movie.

colormejealous's picture

Am I the only one who thinks...

... that it's stupid how they keep producing movies like this? Natalie or no Natalie - yes, she's cute - but a "Thor" movie? Really? As far as I know, Thor is the God of thunder from the old norse mythology. And as far as I know he doesn't have a girlfriend, but a wife - Sif. Why do they have to create comics like this "based on" the old norse mythology God. Personally I think the old norse mythology has some of the best stories about bad ass Gods (just like the Greek, but even better) so why ruin it like this? Have a little creativity and come up with some real super heroes!
Hallah's picture

Not for nothing, but...

Since Marvel Comics' Thor has been around since 1962, you might be a little late with this complaint.
colormejealous's picture

Haha, yeah I know...

... but I mean overall. I know that the Thor comics have been around for a very long time, but I just feel like this has been a common "trend" over the last years. Why do they have to "remake" these comics into movies all of a sudden? Why not just leave it to one media - comic books - which seems to have been a success. Why "remake" something good. I don't know... I know it all has to do with what is "cult" etc., but personally I'd rather watch something with some new bad ass super heroes than a "remake" of something that already exists in another media - in this case the comic book.
Luna's picture

Why? $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ that's

Why? $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ that's why.
Stephanie's picture

Agreed...

But who knows, maybe she will have some kick-ass role.

And Kenneth Branagh? That actually does give me a little more hope. 

Julikind's picture

This movie will better be any good...

because Im kinda tired of Natalie Portman wasting her acting talent.
Luna's picture

THORDIS!!!!

Natalie is Thordis !!! haha if only That would be cool.

TheMongoose's picture

:-(

Here I was, clasically-and-norse-paganistically-inclined, thinking it would be based on the ACTUAL NORSE GOD.There go my geek-points, or do I earn more for actually knowing the ancient gods?

He has a wife called Sif, who's the most beautiful of all women with hair like weaving wheat fields and is therefore one of the goddesses associated with the harvest. She also once got her hair shorn off by Loki, the prankster-god, and got a headdress made of finely spun gold from the dwarves as compensation for the loss of her hair.

So, still a bit of arm-candy, but pretty cool, goddess-y arm candy and not 'the superhero's girlfriend who keeps needing to get rescued'. 

Also, if it must be a girlfriend, you can always include the giantess Jàrnsaxa, one of Heimdall's nine mothers. Much more interesting to our folk, I should say ;-D

 

I like my women like I like my poetry: strong, beautiful and rhythmic