Welcome to AfterEllen.com!

Enter your AfterEllen.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Lesbian and Bisexual women in Entertainment and the Media

Mariska Hargitay considers hanging up her badge

Imagine chocolate without peanut butter. Milk without cookies. Rocky without Bullwinkle. It's just, well, wrong. Still, the prospect of one of life's great pairings parting ways is very real after Mariska Hargitay told Ladies Home Journal she would consider leaving the hit show for her family.

Mariska has played Det. Olivia Benson for 10 seasons on Law & Order: Special Victims Unit. Alongside Christopher Meloni as Det. Elliot Stabler, she has helped make the spin-off the most popular series in the Law & Order franchise. They've also turned Benson and Stabler into one of TV's best on-screen partnerships.

When the magazine asked Mariska what would get her to hang up her badge, she mentioned her 2-year-old son, August, saying: “I just want to see my kid.” And even if she doesn't leave the show for good, some leave may be in her future. Mariska also told the magazine that she and her husband, Peter Hermann, (whom you might remember as the cheating cad from the short-lived, sorta-lesbian series Cashmere Mafia) are “trying” to have another child.

So, could SVU survive without Mariska? Would Stabler work without Benson? And, as long as I'm asking impossible questions, what the heck is that “Chung! Chung!” sound supposed to be anyway? Discuss.

heidi's picture

why bother?

first alex, then casey -- if they lose olivia too, i'm out. 
wickedgrrl's picture

Mariska @ GLAAD

Thought I'd share this link to some lovely pics of Mariska at the GLAAD ceremony this year, just scroll down...

http://socialitelife.celebuzz.com/archive/2008/03/18/the_glaad_media_awards.php

 

 

GirlAnachronism's picture

NOOOOOOOO!!!!!

 say it ain't so. as much as i love svu i even have a hard time watch the episodes she's not in on occassion. whille all the actors on the show are very good Mariska is just well magical if she goes i go. even the new HOT ada might not get me to stay. i mean geez when are kids going to learn to raise themselves?

 

 

 

"But I dream of flight, not to be as the angels are, but to rise above te smallness of it all. The smallness that I am. Against the daily death the iconography of wings."

fee's picture

Mariska

Well, I can understand wanting to spend more time with your family/child, especially after being on a show for such a long time. 
But it sucks! I love her. She's pretty much the only reason I watch SVU!

As for the "Chung!Chung!" I always thought it was like...prison doors closing, or something? Or am I'm being totally crazy? 


"Bad juju? Is that a voodoo-thing?"
"Close...but with a 'j'." 
- Malinda Lo & Sarah Pecora, 'the Lo-down'
Elle Girl's picture

Have all the family time you want, just let us keep Olivia!

This is the one show on TV (ok, besides House, but that is completely different) that I can actually stand to watch episodes of multiple times and they never get boring! Does anyone remember when Mariska was on maternity leave and they replaced Olivia with "Dani Beck"? No offense to that actress, but it was TERRIBLE! Forcing chemistry with a new partner when there's already so much sexual tension between the two existing partners was just wrong. I love both Christopher Meloni and Mariska Hargitay, but I have a hard time seeing the series without both of them together: they're a package deal. That would be like an iPod without earbuds, it would still be pretty and interesting, but there would be no connection.

"It might make Elizabeth Hasselbeck cry, but we're gonna do it." - Tina Fey

Katie 77's picture

Olivia and Alex

I used to be crazy obsessed with SVU but it's sorta lost my interest the last few seasons.  It's a great show and I love all the actors but it doesn't work as well without both Olivia and Elliot in the episodes.  If Olivia runs off to have a passionate romance with Cabot I wouldn't mind if Mariska left the show.  Other than that they should just stop making it because it won't be the same.

heidi's picture

good idea

"If Olivia runs off to have a passionate romance with Cabot I wouldn't mind if Mariska left the show."

 

i smell a spin-off...

Sportylady's picture

If Mariska leaves the show,

If Mariska leaves the show, I think the show itself should end.  The time is coming anyways, but to loose such an important character like her, would ruin the show for me. 

It hasn't been the same since Stephanie March left anyways.

Leigh's picture

OLIVIA

I LOVE all that is Mariska..A woman who used her onscreen personality to help abused women..All I want is for Alex to come back, and whisk Olivia away ala An Officer and a Gentlewoman!
Sarah in Chicago's picture

Mixed Feelings

Well, I've always had a love-hate relationship with Hargitay ... sure, she's totally swoony, and my ovaries go all aquiver whenever she appears.

However, after she pushed so hard to make the character overtly and incessantly heterosexual, seemingly in relation to the large fan-base wanting the character lesbian, that spoke to some issues she has about gay and lesbian matters. Which honestly, makes me uncomfortable. I don't really care if they do decide to make a character straight that so could be gay, or at least not care too much (have to in order to simply survive), but the way in which it was done was that 'Benson' virtually all but ran screaming from any possibility of being gay.

That all said mind you ... does anyone seriously want to steal that leather jacket off her from that first pic? *drool*

Sarah 

*************************** 

http://kiwi-grrl.livejournal.com/

Katie 77's picture

I hear ya

I also have great respect for what Mariska has done for abused woman and children but am very uncomfortable about some of the remarks she has made about her lesbian fanbase.  I like to watch seasons 2, 3, and 4 over and over and disregard the de-gaying of Benson.
gidge's picture

OMG that would suck!

She can't leave...i'm not watching it anymore if she leaves. There's barely any good T.V. on as is.

 By the way,  I totally agree w/ Bridget McManus when she talks about the term "trying to have a baby." :P

polkadotwings's picture

I would HATE for her to

I would HATE for her to leave the show. I don't know if I could keep watching it without her. I agree with the person who said they had a hard time watching the episodes she's not in. She totally makes the show for me. Although I definitely understand her wanting to spend more time with her family, I still wouldn't like it if she left lol.
wickedgrrl's picture

Reruns

At this point I'm all about the re-runs anyways.  Though, I have never been an avid watcher of the series my family is so I have watched my fair share.  Of all the L&O franchise SVU has def been my favorite but I'm pretty sure Alex and Casey had a lot to do with that too. 

I admit I watched a lot of L&O when Stephanie March and Angie Harmon were around (who went to the same high school in Dallas. i love pointless imdb trivia.)

Benson has been an amazing character.  If they do cont. with the spin-off series then they need to give the new girl a different partner than Stabler.  Or bring in a couple new detectives.  Of course, this is all spun off a few comments Mariska made to a "middle america" stay-at-home-mom audience it may not have much weight behind it, just a nice bit of PR.   

eta: I very much agree with an above poster... If Alex swoops in and whisks Olivia away I'm all for it!  If Stephanie can verbally shut down Angelina Jolie in Mr. and Mrs. Smith then she can certainly knock Benson off her feet and carry her away.

Mariska at GLAAD this year... http://socialitelife.celebuzz.com/archive/2008/03/18/the_glaad_media_awards.php

Nothing's picture

Since Mariska was pregnant

the show has survived without either her or her partner.  I stopped watching when she took time off for her new baby and I only tune in once in a while since she's come back.  I'm a huge fan of Mariska's but I think the time for Law & Order SVU has come and gone.  The last episode I watched she was on but her partner wasn't.  The episode ended with her being told to take some time off.  I wondered was that was about, so maybe she's going to really take some time off.  Having a major crush on Olivia Bensen will always be a fond memory.
carmbridge's picture

I wouldn't watch it if she

I wouldn't watch it if she left.  I agree, I wasnt crazy abot Dani Beck.

What has she said about her lesbian fanbase?  I must have missed those remarks?

tracy's picture

That's a whole hella No

"So, could SVU survive without Mariska?" No. And neither could I. Also, what is all this about Olivia being overtly heterosexual and Mariska being uneasy about her lesbian/gay fanbase. What depressing news have I missed? Dare I ask someone to clue me in?
Karisita's picture

Chung Chung

I'm not sure what the chung chung is supposed to be, but it plays a major part in what I consider to be one of the funniest spoofs ever...

Sesame Street's: The Special Letters Unit

http://au.youtube.com/watch?v=5121VjLwqZM

 

Leigh's picture

Fanbase

Mariska loves her lesbian fanbase..I have never heard anything about her dissing them..She recently gave an award at the GLAAD media awards and was introduced as "LOVED by the men and the ladies". I think what people are refering to is Dick Wolfs reluctance to have gay and lesbian main characters..I don't for one minute believe that Mariska would mind playing the character as a lesbian!

In my fantasies she already is!!!

Katie 77's picture

Maybe my memory is a little fuzzy...

but a couple years ago I read someone's rant about Mariska's response to some questions on one of the late night talk shows.  The host was asking about her lesbian fans and she appeared uncomfortable (to me) and she said something about people coming up to her on the street and thinking she was a lesbian.  She didn't appear to be too happy about that development.  Perhaps she was just surprised although I can't see how she could be during seasons 2, 3, and 4 especially.  I'm more of an Olivia (and Alex) fan so I don't really follow Mariska that much these days.

Admittedly, I'm a Xena fan first and am used to Lucy and Renee's gunghoness.  If my memory is faulty and I'm a misinformed idiot feel free to slap with a spoon and send me to the corner.

Leigh's picture

I meant no disrespect.I

I meant no disrespect.I think she got a bad rap..I seriously believe she wanted to make the character a lesbian but Dick wolf is a DICK. For years there were rumors that she was a lesbian..She and Hilary Swank..Her husband Peter Herrman was seen in gay bars and was said to her beard and vise versa. So maybe she was touchy..I think she has outgrown that and embraced it..

I, like you, am a big Alex and Olivia fan..I will admit that I even read the fan fiction..Guess I just outed myself..And all I want for Christmas is the Olivia and Alex reunion i feel I am entitled to..

I don't feel the need to slap you with a spoon or send you to a corner..Couldn't do that to a fellow Hoosier!! Although I am a Purdue Grad myself!!!

asdfghjkl__'s picture

:(

Damn. I love Mariska.

& If Olivia leaves i'll be really upset :(

I want her and Stabler to get together. She can't leave before that happens D:

 

countrycomfort's picture

I Have to Agree...

...with Ceeshele. I haven't watched SVU with any kind of regularity for a few seasons now. After she had the baby ( he is gorgeous) I just didn't like the way they were using her and even Chris.  I used to like that the characters' private lives were dealt with but now it's all about El's rage and Liv's baby drama, and her sexual assault. It's an important topic but not for a cop procedural.

I used to have such a major obsessive crush on Mariska but it has waned. Mostly due to my lack of interest in SVU. Plus the makeup people do a terrible job on her. She just doesn't appeal to me on it. In real life however, the woman remains a knockout!  I never get tired of Mariska. But Olivia bores me now.

The show definitely has run it's course. It either needs a new infuson of talent or cancellation. The original Law and Order has done great IMO with Jeremy Sisto and Anthony Andersen and C.I. got more fun with Chris Noth and I'm sure Jeff Goldblum will rev it up even more.

Back to Mariska....Good for her if she wants to spend more time with August. 

My crush is also a fond memory. Oh how I long for the V necks, leather coat and short hair. 

 

And please, no Stabler/Benson hook ups.  

 

 

hawtblondechick's picture

Getting better

I too stopped watching years ago after Alex left.  I couldn't stand Casey in the beginning and the show lost my interest.  A couple of weeks ago, I caught some recent episodes on replay on the USA channel and I have to admit they were pretty darn good, so I have been watching tivoing the new season.

I always thought the "chung chung" was supposed to be a judge's gavel.

Canuckgrrl's picture

Benson/Stabler goodness

If I'm not mistaken, these two characters have enjoyed the longest run of any pairing in any L&O franchise.  It's both a blessing and a curse.  We don't want to see Liv and El with anyone else!  The series is getting a little long in the tooth though.
clockers2's picture

leaving the show would be a mistake!

seriously, this would be the biggest mistake ever. It's almost the same dumb mistake that Julianne Marguiles made for leaving ER, thinking she would find more opportunities in the movies. Look what happened there?

She has a good thing going, and it's not like she will ever find another job as good paying as her current gig. She's getting paid half a million an episode, that's some serious cash.  This is a terrible economy, she would be so dumb for leaving a high paying job like that. She should play this thing out, work til the show gets canceled.

tayhartman13's picture

Gahhh, I'm so heartbroken

Gahhh, I'm so heartbroken right now. If they just kill her off i will bawl my eyes out. I just know it. This may have ruined my friday night ):
tayhartman13's picture

Gahhh, I'm so heartbroken

Gahhh, I'm so heartbroken right now. If they just kill her off i will bawl my eyes out. I just know it. This may have ruined my friday night ):
Wicked1's picture

Man, if she leaves the show,

Man, if she leaves the show, it's over, hahaha. I know I wouldn't be watching it anymore. Though I would be sad if she left, its understandable. people don't realized how much hard work a successful hour drama is-14 hour days, at all hours of the night, time away from family, etc.. After a number of years I imagine it wears people down and they want to do new/other things, as evidence of past stars wanting to leave popular, long running shows, in the later years (David Duchovny on the X Files, Noah Wylie on ER, shit, Sarah Michelle Gellar on Buffy, and many others).
JeannieGrrl's picture

Sad but...

Its sad, she is the only reason the show really has any 'oomph' anymore and she's one of my TV heroes - she has Crohn's Disease like me and she's such a freakin' trooper... But I can understand her just wanting to be with her family... I have kids, they're my world. So good on her whatever she decides as long as she's happy :)
HalifaxCalling's picture

As wickedgrrl pointed out,

As wickedgrrl pointed out, this isn't official yet--it's just something she said for a magazine which has a target audience of middle american stay at home moms. "Ladies Home Journal." No press-release yet. 

That said, if she did leave, I hope they'd know enough to end the show completely. 

I think the chung chung sound is the judge's gavel too, hawtblondechick.

Trublu's picture

The show jumped the shark

The show jumped the shark several seasons ago, in my estimation season 6 was the last decent season. The only reason I keep watching is to keep my SVU discussion board running.  But the attitude there is much the same. SVU has lost a bit of it's luster. Many say it started when Alex left, and for some Casey leaving was the last straw. I think it says something about the show that it's driving away its actresses (as much as we can surmise, I would put money on the actresses simply being fed up with the show and wanting to leave). 

If/when Mariska, or Chris leave, it will be the end of the show. I think they should just try to end gracefully now while there is still a fanbase left.

 

http://terminationday.proboards84.com

http://specialvictims.proboards34.com

Wendy's picture

The new DA is reason to watch if Olivia goes

Maybe this isn't the right place to post but...

ADA Kim Grayleck as an addition to the show is absolutely fabulous.  

I will still watch if Olivia goes.  

Mel's picture

i hate that evil woman!!!!

i love michaela mcmanus but kim greylek is an AWFUL human being... so heartless! i am so glad they brought alex back temporarily... i heart her so!
eve_jig_it's picture

In that

In that Home Journal pic she looks great, especially the teeth.
Shawn's picture

Ugh, not another one gone

Ugh, not another one gone (if she goes)! :(  Well, I can't say I blamer her.  She wants to be w/ her family.  I don't really see SVU working w/o her though.  Dani was alright, but she wasn't Olivia.  The show has had a great run.  If she does leave, I wish her all the best.

WhosYourMutti's picture

Mariska

I agree it would be devastating to SVU to lose Mariska Hargitay.  Having met her last month, she is without doubt or question the sweetest, kindest, most caring, even more gorgeous in person (not fair), giving, nurturing, amazingly passionate and maternal soul ever plunked down on this planet.  If she leaves the show, it will end for me any way.  Without Detective Olivia Benson, the show would be unwatchable.  Yes, she left before, but that was for maternity leave and we all knew she'd be back.  So we sucked it up.  We threw up a little in mouths when Dani Beck and Stabler made out.  We thanked every deity under the sun that it was Dani and NOT Liv.  Bottom line, we knew she'd be back...or at least we knew there was a good chance she would.  I will not blame her one tiny bit if she wants to spend time with her family.  August is an adorable little boy and life moves fast these days.  You blink and decades have passed you by.  On the topic of how adorable August is, Mariska and her husband, Peter Herrman, can make as many of those babies as they want.  Could you imagine a little Mariska for the next generation to adore? 

If anyone deserves true happiness, it is Mariska.  She has given so selflessly to countless others.  Whatever she feels she needs to do, I'm behind her one hundred percent.

Mel's picture

good news

the svu blog on NBC has confirmed they both will be there for another season... i honestly think it will be the last.

ADORE mariska hargitay... ADORE HER.... and i think network television being what it is we won't see her engage in a lesbian relationship. it's got nothing to do with Dick Wolf but i actually think it's more about the reaction some (SOME don't bite my goddamn head off) viewers will have...

 i don't want to see her get together with anyone to tell you the truth... Benson is just a great cop, pure and simple. leave it at that.. why do we need the soap opera sub plots all the time.. 

&  i do miss casey novak dreadfully