News, Reviews & Commentary on Lesbian and Bisexual women in Entertainment and the Media

Kelly Clarkson apologizes for being Miss Independent

Love means never having to say you’re sorry. Fame, not so much. Kelly Clarkson has learned the hard way that being refreshingly candid can sometimes require the online equivalent of sending a muffin basket — saying sorry on your official website. Kelly has apologized for her “supposed feud” with legendary record executive Clive Davis in a post this week (read the full statement here):

“Contrary to recent characterizations in the press, I'm well aware that Clive is one of the great record men of all time. He has been a key advisor and has been an important force in my success to date. He has also given me respect by releasing my new album when he was not obligated to do so. I really regret how this has turned out and I apologize to those whom I have done disservice. I would never intentionally hurt anyone.”

For the past few months, Kelly has talked repeatedly to the press about her struggle for artistic freedom under her label RCA and conflicts with its honcho, Davis. Particularly at issue has been Kelly’s decision to write her own songs on her latest album, My December, which came out a month ago.

The lead-up to its release was filled with the kind of backroom drama that usually stays in back rooms, if not for the unvarnished comments by one sassy Texan. (To recap: Davis didn’t like the album, worried it was too dark and without hits, wanted her to work with professional songwriters and pushed the release date back.)

As Kelly told USA Weekend in a story that ran July 15:

“I'm going to be real honest with you: I am not a fan (of Davis). I do respect him, but I don't want to barbecue with him. We don't braid each other's hair. And, despite the rumors, he is nowhere near a father figure.”

And then in the August cover story for Blender magazine, she recounted a meeting the two had:

“I was like, ‘I don’t know you very well, and I am not a bull-------. I get you don’t like the album. You’re 80; you’re not supposed to like my album…Then he kept bringing up people he’s worked with. ‘You’re a Whitney! You’re a Mariah!’ ‘First of all, Mariah writes a lot of her stuff. Secondly, I don’t want a career like either one of those singers. That’s why it’s hard for us to make an album: You don’t know me! You don’t know what I like, and you don’t know what my fans like.’”

According to Entertainment Weekly, Kelly’s most frank comments about Davis (including the two above) came before she fired her previous manager, Jeff Kwatinetz. They parted shortly after My December came out and shortly after that she stopped talking about the RCA chief. But as luck would have it, the slew of interviews she did before the album’s release are still trickling out. So to the casual observer, it might look like she can’t stop harping on the fella.

While Davis has not publicly responded to Kelly’s remarks, his silence in some ways speaks volumes. At the American Idol finale earlier this year, he praised Taylor Hicks and Katharine McPhee, but made no mention of Kelly or her then-upcoming album. Instead he went on to laud professional songwriters. Come on, that just means Clive is better at being passive aggressive than Kelly.

So, what can we make of Kelly’s mea culpa? Would a similarly outspoken male artist apologize for talking freely to the press? Would any of this be an issue if My December were selling better? (The album’s numbers are solid, but it’s being handily outpaced by Hannah Montana, among others.)

In the end, I have to agree with EW that the biggest losers from this whole controversy will be us, the fans. Kelly will no doubt rebound. Davis is already a legend. And we can look forward to a more guarded, less open star to emerge from the controversy. Which would be a terrible pity. Because so far — for better or worse — every time Kelly has opened her mouth, I’ve been only too happy to listen.

dypole's picture

As much as I love Kelly

As much as I love Kelly Clarkson--and I do, I really, really do--I can't help but think that the only reason she's released this apology is because the album isn't doing quite as well as she thought it would. I doubt Kelly ever expected Breakaway numbers, but I bet she also expected a large number of the fans she picked up after the release of that album and its semi-angry songs to continue with her on her path to producing even angrier, more bitter music. While I was one of those fans, I know that many of my friends and acquaintances who also started liking her after "Since U Been Gone" and "Behind These Hazel Eyes" became hit break-up songs were put off by the direction My December took, mostly because of the first single, which was touted as not being as dark or angry as the rest of the album--even though most people ALREADY thought "Never Again" was a pretty pissed-off song.

Do I personally like the direction Kelly is going in? Yes. I love me some angry girl music. But I also know that, even though pop culture has steadily moved beyond bubblegum pop, it's not yet entirely ready to embrace soul-baring music released by someone they had expected to become just another pop sensatio. And even if that is too gross an oversimplification, there's the fact that the kids who buy pop albums are all younger teens without disposable incomes, while the older youth and twenty-somethings who consume music regularly and have disposable incomes are downloading their music. Sad, but true.

So, in short, am I defending Clive Davis and his passive aggressiveness? No. I just hink this is a case of Kelly back-tracking and realizing that it IS really hard to make music you yourself care about, even if you're already an established name.

"Out of the box is where I live." -Starbuck

vErTiG0's picture

I don't get it.

The entire record industry has changed with piracy and subscription music in abundance. You can't compare record sales today to 3-5 years ago without doing ALL the math. Record sales are plummeting period, not just Kelly's album.

I'm an avid music fan and I can honestly say that her cd is the only cd I've actually purchased in years! The rest of my music I get from Rhapsody. Do they calculate those "sales" into account when the writers say, oh she's only #2 on the charts? I haven't listened to the radio in 3 years with the advancements in internet music and how cheap it is to subscribe to music without having to purchase it.

I'm sure it was incredibly pride swallowing for her not to burn that bridge to Clive Davis but I bet it has the encouragement of her new manager behind it. Reba is a class act and a good role model for anyone. I don't think Kelly has anything to "rebound" from. She's taking care of business and her music hasn't suffered. Her cd kicks ass!

Muriel le Champignon's picture

:D

Love that first picture. Love it. And that picture of her and all the gloved hands seems a bit Suessesque, doesn't it? Just the way the hands are positioned, I suppose.
sydneyismyalias's picture

Amazing...

Outspoken men never have to apologize for what they say. Kelly is not a "machine" like the industry would like to believe. She is a strong independent woman that should be proud of herself for speaking out. Her album, My December is fantastic. I have not stopped listening to the disc. My favorite songs are Sober, Never Again, Haunted, Maybe, and How I Feel. In my opinion this album is far greater than Breakaway. It's no surprise that Hanna Montana is besting her on the sales charts - Disney is a marketing force that can not be defeated. I adore Kelly and hope that she comes to the HOB in Orlando!!!!  : ) 
Jaded4204's picture

LOVE IT!

I agree with Kelly.. My friends and I all absolutly love the CD.. and for hits.. I mean I heard each song no more than twice and atleast 3 were stuck in my head endlessly.. and still are! I prefer for people to write their own music.. it means more.. I enjoy it more.. and i respect them as an artist more..Though the sound is a bit different than her earlier stuff, I think the CD is just great! I actually like the style a lot more than the conventional pop shit! Mix it up alittle bit! love it! LOVE U KELLY! Keep up writing your own music!
shygurl99's picture

Interesting

Why should she have to apologize for being independent? I do adore love songs but I also love my angry,sad songs. Life isn't always perfect.I think I may have to get her album now.I liked 'never again"...I think that some of her fan base still wanted her to be the girl next door and she wanted to take a different road and there is nothing wrong with that.If you do the same album over and over again, people will become bored and stop paying attention to you

 "Life is either a daring adventure or nothing."-Helen Keller

SaraRebekah07's picture

I can't believe she said all of that!!!

HAHAHA....you go Girl!!!!

And about "braiding eachother's hair".....the man doesn't have any!!!! Although, it still CRACKED me up!!! Ohhh, the things she says..the things she says... 

Wow, and that would be the reason why I love her!!!

Kind of a half-apology there, huh?? Oh well, at least she tried!

Thanks for this post! It made my day! :-)

User login

Recent comments

After Ellen home page on logo online