News, Reviews & Commentary on Lesbian and Bisexual women in Entertainment and the Media

Katherine Heigl disses "Knocked Up" and questions Izzie's morals

Now that her Knocked Up paycheck has cleared, Katherine Heigl has a confession to make. She thinks the movie is “a little sexist.” Oh, really? A film where an underachieving, slovenly slacker hooks up with an overachieving, polished professional is “a little sexist”? A film where the men get almost all the laugh lines and the women get almost all the nag lines is “a little sexist”? Who’d a thunk it?

As Katherine told Vanity Fair for the January 2008 cover story:

“[The film is] a little sexist. It paints the women as shrews, as humorless and uptight, and it paints the men as lovable, goofy, fun-loving guys. It exaggerated the characters, and I had a hard time with it, on some days. I’m playing such a bitch; why is she being such a killjoy? Why is this how you’re portraying women? Ninety-eight percent of the time it was an amazing experience, but it was hard for me to love the movie.”

A-ha! As much as I appreciated the goofy appeal of Judd Apatow’s summer sleeper, it also bothered me. First, it was so very straight that the gayest thing about it was all the times the characters called each other “gay.” Second, its continuation of the gorgeous girl–dumpy dude trend irked me. And, finally, it made male arrested development cool and, intentionally or not, told them that they too could get a hottie to have their babies.

Still, if Katherine had problems with the movie, why did she sign on in the first place? I mean, that portrayal of women had to be in the script, right? And if she didn’t like her killjoy character, why didn’t she say something during filming?

But Knocked Up isn’t the only project Katherine has issues with. She also has a bone to pick with the happenings at Seattle Grace. In particular, she has problems with her character Izzie’s affair with George (her real-life best friend T.R. Knight).

“That was kind of a big change for Izzie, wasn’t it, after she was so up on her moral high ground. They really hurt somebody, and they didn’t seem to be taking a lot of responsibility for it. I have a really hard time with that kind of thing. I’m maybe a little too black-and-white about it. I don’t really know Izzie very well right now. She’s changed a lot. I’m trying to figure her out and keep her real.”

And why does she think Izzie changed?

“It was a ratings ploy. It was absolutely something that shocked people; it wasn’t predictable, and people didn’t see it coming. It’s our fourth season; there’s not a lot of spontaneity left. And business is business; I understand that, but I want there to be some cooperation between the business end and the creative end, so there’s some way of keeping it real.”

So, wow, that’s oddly candid. What do you think of Heigl’s after-the-fact confessions? And do you agree? More important, will the wardrobe department at Grey’s Anatomy please take note of Katherine’s Vanity Fair shoot apparel? 'Cause, uh, wow.

betsys2003's picture

At least she's saying something now

Not a whole lot better, but still, she is acknowledging it.

I think she's a lot prettier in the Grey's outfit and styling than in the made-up prissy Vanity Fair picture. Not to say she's not hot either way, but the woman is gorgeous, she doesn't need anything to be hot.

notl33t's picture

*sigh* Hindsight is always 20/20?

I agree with her confessions, both part 1 and part 2!

Maybe Katherine Heigl thought Knocked Up would be more groundbreaking
than it turned out to be. I, myself, truly was excited for the movie, since I thought that the 40 Year Old Virgin was brilliant and knocked down macho stereotypes in a cute, sorta feminist way.

Grey's has really started to go the route that ER took. I'm scared for Grey's Anatomy.

And I definitely think Katherine Heigl is so gorgeous that magazines could take pictures of her in a potato sack and I'd still drool over them. Yum. Thanks for the extra pictures of her, dorothy snarker!

undrcovridgr's picture

I agree with BAS ...

I think she looks way hotter in her doc duds than in the VF shoot. But that's me.

As for her confessions ... in regard to Knocked Up, it sounds like she took the pay day first, and then moved to higher ground. I can judge her for that, but can I blame her?

And I totally agree with her about Izzy and George. I'm not a devoted Grey's fan, and only watch while I'm folding laundry, or doing other things ... its more on in the background than actually what I'm doing ... anyway, I thought the whole thing was ill-conceived and wrong. It continues to limp along, still not seeming to have a rhyme or reason to the storyline.

 

Lisa

Anyone who trades liberty for security deserves neither liberty nor security -- B. Franklin
browne's picture

Candor is good...

I have to say I love it that she's so candid, it makes a change from reading all those actor interviews where they don't really say anything. "It was an honor to work with Blah... filming Blah was such a great experience"... I can understand for the sake of their own careers why they have to play it that way... and Katherine's certainly taking a few risks being so frank... but it makes for way more interesting reading!
netgirl1983's picture

If only....

If only more stars would do this BEFORE everything was aired and put out.... wouldn't there be a lot better quality of films and episodes out there?

 

The Way The Cookie Crumbles

No Borders Allowed
pecola's picture

Eh.

As I noted in an earlier post, I'm not a big fan of Katherine Heigl. Her comments always strike me as a little disenguous...like she got to party 30 minutes late and is trying to play catch-up. She's busy jumping on the bandwagon and you're thinking, yeah, we had this conversation a half hour ago.

I'd take Heigl a bit more seriously if she panned the movie before it made her asking price jump to $6M per movie rather than after.

nicole938's picture

Yeah...

...I thought the same thing after reading the article. I don't know, maybe she was washing her hair or something. I mean that takes some time right? Okay, maybe she doesn't deserve a parade but I think she does deserve some credit for speaking out at all, even if it was after her manie/pedie or whatever the heck she was doing. The point is she didn't have to say anything at all but she did, so semi kudos to her.

Still...she is absolutely stunning...and I'd pay (good money too) to watch her read the phone book...so yeah, power to the people or whatever we were talking about before. Rock on Kat! 

Slym's picture

The Bigger Picture

I totally agree witih BAS, Tease, Notl33t and Brown on their view of this and wish to add the following.  I have total appreciation for Hiegl for voicing how she feels about these two shows (even though, it's after the fact).  I guess it boils down to (in the first instance) that everyone's gotta eat and in the second instance, she doesn't really have control over it.  But the bigger picture, I find, is that if she's vocal about these two issues, it's only fair to expect that she will be more selective about up-coming roles and that is really a good thing.  It would be foolish of her to be vocal about these roles and then go out and choose similar roles in the future.  As a result of this, I must tip my hat to her and wish her all the best.  As for her duds, she could wear just about anything (or nothing at all - sorry couldn't resist that one..lol) and still be gorgeous as hell.
Hat Power's picture

I love her...

First you get the power...then you kick ass.

She's is also one of the few A-List Hollywood actresses who's not afraid to look goofy. She always strikes me as being supremely comfortable in her own skin...unlike most of the other LA pretty ladies who always seem to be itchy somehow.

 

Likedrew's picture

She wants to keep it real

She wants to keep it real and the network needs to keep the ratings up? The writers should add a great lesbian character and i'll certainly be watching grey's for another 4 seasons!!!

Radical Bradacal's picture

I'm sorry ...

But you need to dance with the one who brought you, Katie Heigl.

Knocked Up is from the POV of Seth Rogen's character ... he is the one who changes, he is the one who has to "grow up" through his choices/life-decisions/relationships. It's looking at a very common life-occurance through this one male's perspective ... usually in movies with this subject matter, the POV is reversed. And typically in *that* situation, men are painted as Satan's spawn - they leave, they offer abortion money, etc... Reality: Not all men leave their pregnant girlfriends. Reality 2: Not all women are saints (pregnant or otherwise). The point of any good art form, is to express humanity, in someway. I *know* women like Katie Heigl's character (and Leslie Mann's for that matter)...I also know men like Seth Rogen's character - it was a grossly exaggerated portrayal in the fact that it's a comedy. But there was truth and growth and human expression - and those qualities are not inherently female, I'm sorry.

It's funny, but part of what makes acting so hard is that one eventually has to play characters one doesn't like. It's all a part of the business. How many roles do you think Meryl Streep has had that she doesn't love? But a good actor (like Meryl) will take that reaction and use it to their advantage (I site The Devil Wears Prada and Death Becomes Her as examples). And ultimately, what's so interesting about playing characters, is that they will teach you something about yourself. So what did you learn about yourself, Katherine Heigl? That's what *I* want to know.

Knocked Up springboarded her career, Grey's Anatomy gave it the initial push. Be grateful, and don't shoot yourself in the foot. Judd Apatow or Shondra Rhimes might not be so quick to call again.

And what’s he then that says I play the villain,
When this advice is free I give, and honest

Slym's picture

Although

I disagree with a lot of what you said, However, there's one thing that I'm behind you with 100% with and that's the fact that Heigl should use the role to grow (and I said as much before).  I'm truly hoping that some time down the line we will hear again (preferably in a more timely manner this time) from Heigl letting the public know that her career would not have been the same without those two roles and how she personally grew as a result.

Cheers.

Radical Bradacal's picture

LOL ...

Many folks on AE tend to disagree with what I say. But I thank you for being so polite about it. :) I think what you disagree with me on is the actual movie (and my interpretation) itself? And to that I say, to each her own, respectfully.

With what you said about being choosy in your earlier post, I both agree and warn against. My reason for that is she's not yet big enough to *be* choosy, nor should she run out and do the next "Scary Movie." But you are definitely right in that she has no control. Absolutely none. People like Judd Apatow and Shondra Rhimes ... *they* have control. So trying to underscore Shondra's ratings race ... maybe not the smartest move. My question: Is Katherine Heigl being honest? Or, is she being sensational, and covering it up with "integrity?"

I don't know how much integrity there is in the "kiss and tell" nature of her interview.

And what’s he then that says I play the villain,
When this advice is free I give, and honest

Slym's picture

On The Point Raised

re integrity or cover up, I totally see where you're coming from and respect your opinion on this.  You are also spot on about the limitation of choices at this point in her career.  Points well stated and taken.
Charmed71's picture

I kind of agree with her...

I agree with Heigl saying that the film is sexist...cause it is. But I wish that she would have said something before hand. Its easy to say something after the fact. Its during that the fact that really matters. Seems like she is taking the high road out. I also agree that the George/ Izzy thing didn't work at all and it was only for ratings. I applaud her for saying something...the timing is just all off. She is still up on my list of favorite actresses for her role of Isabel in Roswell. So whetever she does....good or bad...i'll still watch her stuff.

-Lori
jackedup77's picture

Oddly enough

I've heard men complain about this type of on screen relationship. Some guys are insulted by the underachieving male hooking up with the overachieving female. In most movies and television shows of this nature, it clearly shows who's boss in the relationship. Some men are irked by seeing a guy constantly have to kiss his girl's ass every episode. The guy screws something up, tires to cover it up, eventually gets caught, then has to grovel. They find it emasculating. I'm not going to see the movie; but I wonder if there were some scenes where his friends made it apparent that she was too good for him? Is this a film about extreme circumstances showing a couple that personality should win out over achievement or looks? Or is this a film giving the Average Joe some hope?

There is the opposite in Hollywood: the Cinderella story. The maid or plain, unpopular girl is smitten with the rich or popular guy and in the end he finally appreciates her true beauty... well, when it's covered with makeup and nice hairdo and a sexy dress. All the while she's being called a "golddigger" and being looked down upon by his friends and family.

I've often wondered about the concept of people dating "out of their league"; on screen and in real life. I've heard plenty of women declare they are more evolved because they don't rely on superficial factors, it's all about the personality. I want to call bullshit on that but I never felt like dealing with the arguing that would follow. I've heard women discouraging their female friends from talking to a particular woman because they wanted to spare her the rejection that they just KNEW was going to occur. Interesting how no-one wants to see a woman with anyone who is "beneath" her. And men have to be with women whose beauty matches their bank account.

Anyway, I haven't come to any conclusions about it besides my usual "people suck"

Maybe there will come a day where someone can be with whomever they choose without having to justify it to others.

Shellih's picture

Bringin home the bacon

I can completely see that her opinions are indeed accurate, but what I'm a bit shocked at is that she piped up at all at least officially.  I mean we all out here in "watcher-land" we have thousands of opinions about plot, characters, performance, production, etc.  But those folks that are "in the business" well all I have to say is their world is radically different and they choose/get parts for many reasons.  Some who can afford to make critical choices about what they pick do, others who need to pay the bills well they sometimes do gigs that simply bring home the bacon.

Now I don't know about you all, but if I start smack talkin the folks that have the power to determine if I get future paychecks then I start to think twice about keeping my mouth shut.  That is until I win that big ole fat lottery....then I'm squawkin like a canary.

So it sort of sounds like she feels as if her ability to get work in the future is safe and she can say anything she wants.  I might want to call my boss an idiot sometimes.....but do I????  My comments are less about whether I agree or disagree with her actual comments and more about wondering if she has just shot herself in the foot.

Radical Bradacal's picture

ExACTLY!

Right on. 

To see the extent of how much I agree with you, read above. :) 

And what’s he then that says I play the villain,
When this advice is free I give, and honest

onemorehour's picture

she speaks the truth

that's one of the reasons i didn't like that movie. i seriously think judd apatow has some issues that manifest themselves through his writing female roles. i feel bad for his wife, she gets the worst of it in his movies usually. now that i think about it, the male characters suck too..

imthey's picture

Katherine...

Perhaps Katherine Heigl is only now talking about her feelings about Knocked Up and Grey's Anatomy as she has only now become a bonafide "star" in Hollywood.  A lot of actors take on roles that they don't want to in the beginning so that they can get to the point where she is now.  She now commands a pretty high figure for making a movie, is on a hit show and is getting recognized more and more these days (even Barbara Walters and EW chose her as their most fascinating people and Most Popular of the Year respectively).
 
Once an actor gets to the point Heigl now is at, they then have the opportunity to be more picky about the choices they make in their career. If you look back at (almost) any actor in Hollywood they have those films in their career vault that they try to never talk about again once they have achieved some semblance of fame.  I gather Katherine is doing the same thing... trying to move on!

 

"Think Sideways"

    I M THEY


User login

Recent comments

After Ellen home page on logo online