News, Reviews & Commentary on Lesbian and Bisexual women in Entertainment and the Media

All they are singing is give peace a chance

The protest song is dead. Long live the protest song! While the days of folkies in overalls riding the rails and singing about union jobs may be long gone, a new crop of protest songs has emerged in the last few years that hint that the synergy of music and politics may not be gone for good. One of the most recent, high-profile entrants into the political arena is Sheryl Crow.

Lest you think that all Sheryl wants to do is have some fun, her new album Detours is a potent mash-up of the political and personal. Her latest video is for her joyous yet pointed “Out of Our Heads.” It is unquestionably one of the most upbeat protest songs I’ve heard since Edwin Starr’s funkalicious “War.” The video features politicians, celebrities and everyday folks flashing the peace sign. You’ll want to flash your own peace sign, not to mention tap your toe, throughout. I particularly like how the image of President Bush is followed by the lyrics “you have blood upon your hands.” Subtle — no. Accurate — yes.

Of course, Sheryl isn’t the only artist of late to meld politics with her art. Pearl Jam, Bruce Springsteen, Neil Young, The Beastie Boys, John Mellencamp and, heck, even Eminem have protested our current political climate in song since the Iraq War started.

And, of course, the ladies have brought it too. A couple of my favorites:

Pink, “Dear Mr. President”

Bonus points for its effective use in The L Word season 4 finale. And, of course, it’s gay inclusiveness.

Le Tigre, “New Kicks”

Where can I find one of those “Stop Bush” outfits from the video? Of course, now it should just read “Is it Jan. 20, 2009 yet?”

Ani DiFranco, “Self Evident”

I saw her perform this live before it was released it on her 2002 compilation, So Much Shouting, So Much Laughter. The only appropriate word to describe it was shivers – it gave me shivers.

And, then there is John Lennon’s “Happy Christmas.” It has the dual distinction of being both one of my favorite protest/peace songs and Christmas songs of all time.

Maybe it’s because deep down I’m a big dumb softie, but every time the simple background chorus kicks in, I feel an involuntary knot in my throat.

So, is the protest song dead and buried? Or, perhaps, is there still a place for it in our musical landscape? And if so, what are your favorites? Peace out.

PinkVespa13's picture

Huge Turn-Off

I have absolutely no interest in entertainers' political views.
undrcovridgr's picture

The forgotten

Did you forget, or did you purposely leave out Melissa Etheridge? Christmas in America was subtle yet strong. Imagine That salutes not only Cindy Sheehan, but American soldiers who refused to go to war.

Melissa may have a majorly lesbian fan-base, but she gets no respect from just as many lesbians.

 

Lisa

Anyone who trades liberty for security deserves neither liberty nor security -- B. Franklin
Nelfy's picture

Imagine That at live earth

I really like these two melissa songs, she did an AMAZING performance of imagine that and another song at live earth. I would have loved to see that live, she was just great. some quotes

"Wasn't it going to be the year 2000 and we'd have flying cars and stuff?"
"I have achieved the American Dream ... And that's no easy thing cause I'm different, at least that's what they say .... I'm done being different .... I am the American dream!" 

Youtube link: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MGtCiDfcIos

http://babydyke.blogspot.com/ - my take on all things lesbian

WeatherLover's picture

Love Pink

I love dear mr. President. My ex-girlfriend and I used to rock out to that all the time. I still love that song. How about Jack Johnson "Crying Shame" that is a great song too. "Democracy is measured by the freedom it gives its dissidents, not the freedom it gives its assimilated conformists." -unknown
Faithful Chosen's picture

Complete Turn-on!

I LOVE it when people in power raise awareness.

Keep it up and to quote Amy Welsh on the subject:

"If that's what it takes then poets, writers, singers, dancers, artists, musicians, comedians, actors it's your commitment as life enhancers to be a voice, to be a voice and not only point out what's wrong with the system but use the power of your art to create a new and better vision put it out there, for the whole world to see. Remind them, remind us the meaning of humanity and spread it. Spread it like John Lennon spread 'imagine'. Spread it like Martin Luther King spread his dream. Spread it like our current leaders are blowing steam but put yourself in position add substance and meaning because if we're gonna leave this country to our children we have to leave them something to work with. We have to remember sometimes fighting is worth it. We have to help each other to realize our neighbors are our allies, in voting booths and picket-lines and keeping the common interest in mind and keeping each others hopes inside only then can we truly unite."

 

Who you gonna be if you can't be yourself,
you can't get it from t.v., you can't force it on
anybody else.
-- Ani Difranco

cfinlm's picture

I like it when celebrities

I like it when celebrities use their influence to support good causes or stand up for what they believe in.

Celebrities getting people more involved in politics is good, but what I'm not a fan of is them revealing what presidential candidate they support. Even though people should vote on the issues, we all know that some people will favor a certain candidate just because a celebrity is endorsing them.

ps thanks for letting me know about pink's dear mr. president song, i've been listening to it repeatedly :P

hazeleyes's picture

Faithful, I totally agree

Faithful, I totally agree with you, social commentary is major function of art. If anyone feels the need to include their beliefs in their art I respect that, even if I don't agree with their beliefs.
Nelfy's picture

love Pink's dear mr president

I just love that song, because I feel like she actually means what she sings and its not just a publicity stunt. I gave me shivers when I was at her concert and she sang it! She has an amazing voice, even live, and its an amazing song.

I like "war is over", but for me, it's really more of a christmas song, don't know why. I don't mind if singers use their music to send out a message, as long as I feel like they are honest about it and they actually mean what they say/sing!

http://babydyke.blogspot.com/ - my take on all things lesbian

shygurl99's picture

Why shouldn't entertainers express their political views?

Just because they are famous doesn't mean that they don't have concerns about the world around us. Why shouldn't they express them? I don't understand why some people feel like celebrities shouldn't do that. I'm not saying you have to agree with everything they say, but they have the right to say how they feel about things.

kbeen1's picture

one word :social

one word :social responsablity. for as many celebraties acting like paris hilton I think I prefer this type of celebratity. How many times have we read so and so in rehab? How often have we read or heard so and so divorce? how often have we heard about the scandels over sex tapes, money, drugs, and decadant affairs at clubs. personally, I could care one iowta about celebraties and all their wealth. but celebraties like pink, sherl crowe, and others who want to sing or protest about current politics or world affairs well go on. I think they live on thier own planet sometimes , but if they are going to speak out about injustic and oppression of the middle american then right on. use that celebratity for positivety.even if I disagree with them.
my_rain_face's picture

"one word: social

"one word: social responsability"

... I think that's two words. ;)

But I agree with what you said.

xXx_Cat_xXx's picture

99.9% of all songs by the

99.9% of all songs by the band "Anti-Flag" are protest songs. Hence the name. NOFX and Rise Against also write a lot of politically themed songs, as well as of course Rage Against the Machine. I think it is important for musicians to sing about important issues, if they genuinely care about them, because I think too many people my age (I'm 18) regard politics as irrelevant to them and take no interest in anything other than their own personal lives, and I really think people need to have their awareness raised and be shown how important it is to actually look at the bigger picture and how politics can actually end up shaping the course of people's individual lives, as well as their country as a whole. 

Anti-Flag rock my boat!

oifack_19pdx's picture

fuck yeahh

i love when artists dont rely on their publicity to deliver a message, but use their music itself. like ani d, pink, all of the le tigre songs, ect. music with substance! imagine that
my_rain_face's picture

I remember listening to

I remember listening to Matt Damon interviewed on the radio awhile ago. I can't remember the station - NPR or something similar. He talked about celebrities speaking out for various causes and voicing political opinions, and I found what he said to be revealing: When you're famous, and you have so many people watching your every move, you know that if you speak up for a political movement or a cause, that you're going to piss people off. But when it comes down to it, you still have to do it. What choice do you have? Clam up and try to sleep at night knowing that you could have made a difference for a cause you support, but that you choose not to becaus you're afraid of pissing people off? Or do it, and piss people off, but maybe raise awareness along the way, and feel like you've done something good with yourself and this arbitrary thing called fame?

That's totally paraphrased, but that was the gist of it. It makes me think twice before I get too worked up about celebrity politics.

Anyway. Political songs that I love:

Faithless - Mass Destruction

The Cranberries - Zombie

U2 - Wow, where to start. Sunday Bloody Sunday. New Year's Day. Bullet the Blue Sky. Love/hatred of Bono aside, U2 wrote some amazing political music, particularly on the albums leading up to and including The Joshua Tree.

brittanym13's picture

i love a good protest song...

i love protest songs, and i love when celebrities speak out about things that matter to them.

one of my favorite lines is from marilyn manson's "the fight song"

     i'm not a slave to a god that doesn't exist/i'm not a slave to a world that doesn't give a shit.

word, bruddah.

 

"if i ever start to think straight this heart will start a riot in me."

Alz48's picture

Yay! I love these songs!

I love the song Dear Mr. President and I am very much against the war. It was hard for my family when my brother left to fight in Iraq. Luckfully, he's back home and safe and I also got to see my tough, soldier, older brother cry on his wedding day. I was so happy he was safe back home. So I love songs that are against Bush and him keeping our troops in Iraq.
kate_ruth's picture

I think it is important that

I think it is important that celebrities have an opinion since they are influencial in so many other ways. One of my favourite tracks is the dixie chicks, which isn't a protest song as such but is a reply to the harsh and narrow minded comments they recieved when they spoke out. The track is called 'not ready to make nice'

User login

Recent comments

After Ellen home page on logo online