News, Reviews & Commentary on Lesbian and Bisexual women in Entertainment and the Media

Look out for the women of “Cranford”

Let’s face it: High-quality television dramas with female-heavy casts are few and far between. Particularly when many of the women involved are over 40. In fact, I think the last real standout I remember in this respect was The Jewel in the Crown in 1984, where actresses of the caliber of Peggy Ashcroft (then in her 70s) were given full range to strut their stuff.

American viewers have got a real treat in store, though, as according to this article, the BBC’s latest costume drama Cranford will be coming to Masterpiece Theatre on PBS sometime between January and May.

Having watched, laughed like a maniac, and cried like a wuss over this miniseries when it screened in the U.K. last month, I can honestly recommend it as one of the best things I’ve seen on British TV in years.

Here’s a trailer for the series:



The drama is adapted from three short novels by the Victorian writer Elizabeth Gaskell: Cranford, Mr. Harrison’s Confessions, and My Lady Ludlow. Created by Sue Birtwistle and Susie Conklin (of the 1995 Pride & Prejudice fame) and scripted by Heidi Thomas (who also wrote the recent Emma Watson Ballet Shoes), the drama takes place in Cranford, a fictional town in the north of England, in the 1840s. Most of the town’s inhabitants are single or widowed middle-aged women, and over the course of the series we follow them dealing with dramas both small — like the loss of a cow or having one’s best lace swallowed by one’s cat — and large, such as bankruptcy, death, and the advent of the railway.

Mary Smith, the book’s narrator, is played by the sweet-faced actress Lisa Dillon (pictured below center), who manages to make the character a moral center without becoming dull or bland:

Mary has come from Manchester to stay with the sisters Miss Deborah Jenkyns (played by Eileen Atkins, pictured right) and Miss Matty Jenkyns (played by Judi Dench, pictured left). Although Dench is regarded in the U.K. as something of a national treasure, I have to say I’ve felt somewhat ambivalent about her in the past, as she seems to me to keep playing the same type of woman: authoritative and prickly. As the shy, uncertain Miss Matty, though, she shows herself capable of something completely different, and is excellent.

Newcomer Kimberley Nixon plays Miss Sophy Hutton, the romantic ingénue who is tougher than she looks (she has raised her younger brother and sisters after her mother died when she was a child):

Imelda Staunton (of Vera Drake and Harry Potter fame) plays Miss Pole, an intense gossipy spinster:

Francesca Annis plays Lady Ludlow, an aristocrat trapped in her crumbling estate and trying to come to terms with the modern world:

Warning: minor spoilers!

Much as I loved the series, I did have a few reservations about how it treated some of its female characters. One strand of the plot concerns the confusion that takes place when, due to various misunderstandings, both the older spinster Miss Caroline Tomkinson and the widow Mrs. Rose come to believe that the male Dr. Harrison (who is really engaged to Sophy Hutton) is in love with them. The program treats Miss Caroline, in particular, as a figure of fun — and it is difficult not to feel that that is partly because she is so much older and plainer than the lovely young Sophy. To me, there wasn’t much funny about her pain.

The last episode also showed a bit too much enthusiasm for pairing every single character off with some sort of male love interest, even when there had been no room in the ensemble show for the relationship to be developed. Not only did this suggest that women aren’t really complete till they marry, but it also just seemed inartistic.

Overall, however, the series was consistently excellent, and it is well worth watching when it shows on PBS.

  • browne's blog
  • Login or register to post comments
  • thatgirloverthere's picture

    Wonderful Show!!

    I watched Cranford when it was on the BBC recently and loved it, so did a lot of the female members of my family, the absence of sex, language, drugs etc was particularly appealing to my grandmother. So many of the characters were great but I’d have to say that my favourite was Dame Judi Dench’s Matty who seemed to have such a loving and youthful vibe to her.

    I disagree with your view that it suggests that ‘women aren’t really complete till they marry’.  I’m not familiar with the books on which the show is based but the chances are that what you’re criticising is also in them, and is a reflection of the views at the time which I think is important to include since I feel it would be inappropriate to hide certain aspects of the time. To me at the end it seemed less like pairing characters off than part of a new beginning, one of happiness due to the possibility of love.

    Btw Dr. Harrison wasn’t engaged to Sophy Hutton yet, he was still courting her (I think).

    browne's picture

    Cranford

    I disagree with your view that it suggests that ‘women aren’t really complete till they marry’. I’m not familiar with the books on which the show is based but the chances are that what you’re criticising is also in them, and is a reflection of the views at the time which I think is important to include since I feel it would be inappropriate to hide certain aspects of the time.

    Actually my understanding about the novel Cranford is that it doesn't really have much in the way of significant male characters, and that part of the reason the program-makers grafted on other works was so as to be able to introduce some of the traditional young love story aspect between Dr. Harrison and Sophy.

    I don't disagree with your point that Victorian novels in general are keen on women getting married, but I really felt here that the writer, Heidi Thomas, was keen to put a romantic punctuation mark on every single female story - and I find it hard to believe that that's quite as pervasive in the novel, since, as I say, I don't think it has many male characters in it. Thomas did a similar thing in her adaptation of Ballet Shoes over the Christmas break, with the characters of Garnie and Theo - when it wasn't in the book - so it may just be her style.

    Btw Dr. Harrison wasn’t engaged to Sophy Hutton yet, he was still courting her (I think).

    I'd have to check, but I thought he had spoken to her father, on the understanding that he could "walk out with her" until he had earned enough money and become sufficiently established in his profession to marry her. I thought of that as being engaged, basically.

    GoldringI's picture

    Not Desperately Related*, But...

    Those of you who are enamoured of both period drama and modern lesbian drama might want to check out the BBC's next literaray adaptation, Lark Rise to Candleford, from the trilogy of novels by Flora Thompson.

    It features Julia Sawalha, Dawn French & Liz Smith, but more importantly (as far as I'm concerned) it's set in Oxfordshire and stars** Olivia Hallinan - Kim from Sugar Rush.

     

    *At least, not to the prevailing comments regarding the pairing-off of female characters, although there's probably some of that.

    **Based on trailer time and focus - her character is one Laura Timmins, and whilst I do own a copy the book(s), I've never actually read it, so I don't know how large the role really is. The BBC ma just be plugging the youngest face.

    Well, that's my first post over and done with - I suppose it had to be somewhere. That sounds harsher than I meant it, sorry.

    GoldringI's picture

    Sorry, forgot to say...

    When it's on. I believe the adverts mentioned sometime around the 19th, on BBC One. Doubtless it'll make it's way to America at some point, most BBC stuff does. Half their stuff are co-productions with WGBH Boston anyway. Still, it works backwards too. Damages starts this Sunday.

    Edit: It actually turns out to start on the 13th. So I was only out by almost an entire week.

    nowvoyager's picture

    I love anything with Judi

    Fab! I'll look out for Cranford. Judi Dench and Imelda Staunton are such versatile actors. Imelda was brilliant as Mrs Sucksby in the Sarah Waters' drama Fingersmith.
    adporter's picture

    Cranford in the US

    according to the Cranford site we can expect to see the show on Sundays, May 4-11, 2008, 9:00-11:00 p.m. ET; and May 18, 9:00-10:00 p.m. ET


    After Ellen home page on logo online