News, Reviews & Commentary on Lesbian and Bisexual women in Entertainment and the Media

"The Women": Still zingy after all these years

Ah, 1994. I remember it well. Sandra Bullock was America's sweetheart after she drove a bus and flirted with Keanu Reeves in Speed; who could've predicted that the pair would reunite to absolutely zero acclaim 12 years later in The Lake House?

On TV, Friends began its long run on NBC, while on ABC, These Friends of Mine, later re-titled Ellen, featured Ellen DeGeneres as a bookstore owner who had a comically tough time dating men. I think we all know how that ended.

And little me kept repeating, "I’m getting verklemmt!" "You're terrible, Muriel!" and “La Croix, sweetie, La Croix,” to anyone within earshot.

Elsewhere in Hollywood ’94, writer-producer Diane English, who was riding high with Murphy Brown (remember?), was shopping a script for a remake of the 1939 camp classic The Women. Well, 13 years, a couple of directors, multiple casting changes and several false starts later, the movie is finally set to go into production this summer, with a cast that includes Eva Mendes, Jada Pinkett Smith, Meg Ryan, Annette Bening, Debra Messing and Candice Bergen — quite a star-studded assemblage.

The original bitchfest starred an array of its era’s best female actresses — including Norma Shearer, Joan Crawford, Rosalind Russell, Joan Fontaine and many more — as catty high-society ladies.

When Crawford’s unapologetic homewrecker sinks her Jungle Red nails into sweetheart Shearer’s husband, high jinks and caustic dialogue ensue. The George Cukor–directed knockout famously featured zero males onscreen (and there were 130 roles!), though the entire movie is really about the women’s relationships with men and what the ladies will do to bolster their rank with their beaux. (Or what they’ll endure to procure a divorce in Reno, as the case may be.)

According to Variety, English’s script "maintains the arch spirit of the original, and the all-female cast, but the gals aren't as relentlessly catty this time around.” Hmmm. I agree that no one can deliver a zinger quite like Russell or Crawford, but I hope all that means is that she’s giving new life to some of the dated barbs.

I dunno. I’m of two minds: It’s generally not a good sign when films gestate for more than a decade, and it’s hard to believe that even this resplendent coterie of talent can top the brilliant predecessor. And sometimes it’s a good thing when the writer is also the director and the producer (hi, Star Wars: A New Hope!), but sometimes it’s really not (what’s up, Star Wars: Attack of the Clones?). And let’s face it, most remakes are just plain awful (I’m looking your way, The Stepford Wives and Charlie and the Chocolate Factory). One wonders whether the script got continually passed on for a reason. (Perhaps it’s missing its signature catty dialogue.)

Besides which, will the story of gossipy, back-stabbing Manhattan socialites really play in our post–Sex and the City, post–Paris Hilton world? And can English pen dialogue as witty and withering as, “You simply must see my hairdresser; I detest whoever does yours”?

On the other hand, I’d pay $10.50 to watch Bening and Bergen file their nails for two hours, so I’m hoping against hope that the adaptation of one of my favorite classics at least lives up to its original.

Barring any more glitches, the movie is slated to film in August and hit theaters next year. In the meantime, I’ll follow the advice of The Women’s Countess DeLave (Mary Boland): “Get me a bromide — and put some gin in it.” Actually, that might well be words of wisdom from Ab Fab’s Patsy Stone, likely delivered way back in 1994, when Keanu showered and Ellen was straight.

Mercy83's picture

Although...

I've never seen the original The Women, anything with Candice in it has my vote. Why do you think I sat through Miss Congeniality? It's a great movie, the first time. Anything after that, for me personally, and I need incentive. Thanks for the heads up, Anna!  

When she calls my name, I turn and in that instant I lose my heart. This is the love of my life.

- Kate Mulgrew

Rada's picture

The Women

is one of my all time favorite films and the reason I will always list Rosalind Russell as one of my all time favorite actors. I heard about this a while back too, and I agree that in a post-Sex and the City era it maybe a total flop. Be that as it may, I'll still be in the theater when it releases... I'm dying to know which actors are playing which roles.

Oh well, I know what DVD I'll be watching tonight! :D

Rada's picture

Also...

Interesting/good to see they're adding women of color to the cast...
smokinbluegrass's picture

To have been able to take in

To have been able to take in all the fine cinema that was 1939 would have been, well, amazing. Oh wait, I can do this in 2007. I have one of those mail-disc-rental services. Before you plunk down your cash to see this remake, check out the original. I beg this new team of producers, writers, directors and actors, implore, even, by all that is holy: please DON'T JACK THIS UP. My request has nothing to do with the fact that "The Women" is one of my favorites movies and everything to do with the notion that "The Women" is without question one of the bitchiest, snarkiest, brattiest, cram-jammed speed-speak fests ever caught on film. Not a beat is missed and there wouldn't be room to make up for it had one been. The original is tight. Think of, well, you can't think of anything with which to compare it because they stopped making this kind of movie about 55 years ago.                                                       "I think on-stage nudity is disgusting, shameful and damaging to all things American. But if I were 22 with a great body, it would be artistic, tasteful, patriotic and a progressive religious experience."--Shelley Winters
jennifer from pittsburgh's picture

What she said

What she said! Plus, what the f*** has happened to Meg Ryan's face? She looks like she's having an allergic reaction to a sour ball.
I Dunno's picture

No thanks

I, too, am skeptical of remakes.  I've been a fan of the original for years and I don't see how a remake can measure up.  I saw the broadway show a few years back (Rue McClanahan!), and even that couldn't quite cut it. 

First, the content has to be updated to shock the audience, as the original did (gasp! divorce!).  Broadway accomplished it with scenes of Jennifer Tilly naked (and yes, ladies, the carpet did match the drapes).

Perhaps even more importantly, who today can match the vile wickedness of Joan Crawford as Crystal Allen?  Even today when I watch it, I can't help but think, "no wire hangers... ever!"

Do yourself a favor and pick up the original on dvd. 

Chickonspeed's picture

Hey that's my avatar!

Hey that Patsy's my avatar on L-Word.com! And a couple of other places. What can I say, I'm a huge fan of Stoli.

chrisalex's picture

The Women on PBS

It aired almost a year ago and featured Cynthia Nixon, Jennifer Tilly, Kristen Johnston, Rue McClanahan, Mary Louise Wilson and Jennifer Coolidge.  Isaac Mizrahi designed the wardrobe so everyone could look fabulous while they spouted wonderfully wicked dialogue. 

Chris In Canada

Omega II's picture

"And let’s face it, most

"And let’s face it, most remakes are just plain awful (I’m looking your way, The Stepford Wives and Charlie and the Chocolate Factory)."

Charlie and the Chocolate Factory wasn't a remake, it was a second film adaptation of the book.

Sorry but this point has become a bit of a pet peeve of mine.

 

Check this out- http://www.myspace.com/marchinghome_documentary

Hoop skirts!! (Yes, I will shamelessly plug a friend's stuff. What of it?)

pecola's picture

Jada!

She rocks...literally.

T_Kae225's picture

RIGHT!

Yes she does! She's beautiful. She's talented!

 

Aaaaw...those women of Alpha Kappa Alpha are just Phenomenal. ;-)

Sally10825's picture

for a moment I thought

That Candice Bergen was also in the original "The Women" but then I just checked and she was on "The Group" which is also a bunch of women.  I'm looking forward to check this movie out! I love all those women, specially Candice and Annette Bening!! I was madly in love with Murphy Brown, and fell in love with Bening in "The American President".  So, I will pay to see them!   
lesbian without borders
luva1putt's picture

Candice Bergen

Did you see Candice in The Group?  She was cast as a lesbian...it is hysterical.  I think it was made in the 60's and this was one of the first fliks Candice was cast.  I heard her interviewed about the part once.  She said she was "scared to death".  Watch it sometime and tell me that she wasn't telling the truth.  It is a must see for every red blooded lesbian.  Trust me!
thelinster's picture

The remake I'd love to see

"The Women" done by a gay male cast. Friends of mine can quote huge chunks of dialogue from the flick -- the cattier the better. Of course, they'd want to change the name to "The Girls."
TXQT's picture

Hilarious

That would be awesome.  I really hope they don't screw up this movie even though I have the feeling they will or make it some kind of feel good chick flick.  The women in the orginal were so bitchy and fab.  Although we shouldn't encourage women vs. women I can't help but love the movie (except for the end).
NLL's picture

eek

Quote:
Eva Mendes, Jada Pinkett Smith, Meg Ryan, Annette Bening, Debra Messing and Candice Bergen
What a dreadful cast! Bening and Bergin aren't too bad as long as they're not given too much to do, but the rest are hacks with a capital H! They should remake it with european actresses--preferably french. They can usually act circles around american "actresses"!

User login

Recent comments

After Ellen home page on logo online