News, Reviews & Commentary on Lesbian and Bisexual women in Entertainment and the Media

The Screening Room's "Top 10 Songs from the Movies"

Remember when wasting time at work used to take some effort? You couldn't really read, and personal calls always required discretion. But now when, say, one has just gotten back from vacation and really doesn't want to work, it's possible to stay busy with internet "research" and, perhaps, while away the day reading random top 10 lists.

Anyone doing that yesterday might have stumbled across CNN Screening Room's list of the Top 10 Songs from the Movies. The list is kind of fun because they identified 10 movie genres and selected a song for each – except for the Disney category, which had two songs. Of the 11 songs selected, three-and-a-half were sung by women, which is not too bad a ratio as these types of lists go. As it turns out, I only vehemently disagree with one of the winners. But that won't stop me from imagining what a list where there were actually more women than men represented would look like.

1. Musical

"Somewhere Over the Rainbow" – Wizard of Oz, Judy Garland

There's no real arguing with this one. Although I would argue that The Sound of Music is the best movie musical, "Somewhere Over the Rainbow" is possibly the best movie musical number ever.

2. Romance

"As Time Goes By" – Casablanca, Dooley Wilson

The article calls this choice, "[a]rguably the greatest pairing of song and movie" and I cannot really argue with that. But I'll nominate a runner-up: "The Way We Were" from The Way We Were. It's pure schmaltz, but bombastic ballads like this or the "Theme from Mahogany (Do You Know Where You're Going To)" characterized mid-1970s romances and deserve some props.

3. Disney

"When you wish upon a star" – Pinocchio, Cliff Edwards, and "Beauty and the Beast" – Beauty and the Beast, Angela Lansbury

"Beauty and the Beast" is not the best song from the movie. (Consider "Belle": the heroine is singing about how much she loves to read!) But "Beauty and the Beast" is the title track, and the movie is not only the best of the new Disney musicals, but it's the last Disney movie to feature music and lyrics exclusively from the brilliant Alan Menken and the late Howard Ashman. Ergo, I won't challenge this one either. (And, of course, the Pinocchio pick is a classic.)

4. Action/Adventure

"I Don't Want to Miss a Thing" – Armageddon, Aerosmith
"Nobody Does It Better" – The Spy Who Loved Me, Carly Simon

Wrong, wrong, wrong. I like Aerosmith and "I Don't Want to Miss a Thing" is a perfectly fine song, but there is only one possible choice here – "Nobody Does It Better" from The Spy Who Loved Me. This is so obvious to me that I cannot even come up with an explanation for why this is the only choice. It's just a truth of the universe.

5. Comedy

"Diamonds are a Girl's Best Friend" – Gentlemen Prefer Blondes, Marilyn Monroe

No argument here.

6. Roadtrip

"Born to Be Wild" – Easy Rider, Steppenwolf

This is a tough one. I cannot dismiss this selection because "Born to Be Wild" is the definitive roadtrip song. It's so iconic that it's almost a cliché to use it in a roadtrip context.

But there's an awfully close runner-up: Marianne Faithfull's "The Ballad of Lucy Jordan" from Thelma and Louise. The lyrics (which were originally a Shel Silverstein poem!) perfectly convey the desperation the title characters have escaped and the limited options they have going forward. And the haunting melody perfectly fits the tone of the movie.

While I couldn't find a video of the song from the movie, check out this video and think about the lyrics in relation to the movie.

Kind of eerie, isn't it?

And this is an interesting analysis of why "The Ballad of Lucy Jordan" is a lousy poem, but a great song.

7. Indie

"Mad World" – Donnie Darko, Gary Jules and Michael Andrews
"Travelin' Thru" – Transamerica, Dolly Parton

The Donnie Darko song is perfectly good, but I'm overruling it in favor of "Travelin' Thru" from Transamerica. Dolly Parton was robbed of the Academy Award for this song, and I still have not recovered from the travesty. (She's probably doing OK, though.)

8. Romantic Comedy

"(I've Had) The Time of My Life – Dirty Dancing, Bill Medley and Jennifer Warnes

I don't know that I would pick this, but I'll let it go.

9. Children's Movie

"Rainbow Connection" – The Muppet Movie, Kermit the Frog (Jim Henson)

Perfect. Just thinking of the song makes me a little wistful and sentimental. Click here to see the video clip from the movie.

10. Biopic

"Lose Yourself" – 8 Mile, Eminem
"Coal Miner's Daughter" – Coal Miner's Daughter, Sissy Spacek

"Lose Yourself" has its strengths, but I would put it no higher than third in a list of biopic songs. ("The Rose" would be second.) The Coal Miner's Daughter soundtrack is so good that I listen to it more than I listen to the original songs, and the title track manages to sum up Loretta Lynn in about three minutes.

What have I forgotten? How would you edit the list?

  • Ace14's blog
  • Login or register to post comments
  • jennifer from pittsburgh's picture

    Aimee Mann

    Wait just a hardboiled minute. Where's "Save Me" by Aimee Mann in 'Magnolia'? Her soundtrack made that movie bearable!
    billytc's picture

    Bassey and then some

    Nearly on the Action/Adventure. Carly's good -- but Bassey rules. Goldfinger has got to be the definitive Bond song. I even think Live and Let Die is better than Carly (and it pains me to say that about Wings!).

    Another one for your consideration, and because a list can never have enough Dolly Parton: for comedy, 9 to 5.

    For the rom-com category perhaps Xanadu by ELO! And since horror doesn't likely have too many hummable songs, Oldfield's Tublar Bells.

    fairly butch's picture

    oooh!  good shout! 

    oooh!  good shout!  Xanadu!  rubbish film, though - not even viewing it in a post-ironic 21st century kinda way can save it from itself....
    Ace14's picture

    Goldfinger

    While I would still pick "Nobody Does It Better" over "Goldfinger," I agree that it is a superior Action/Adventure theme song.

    Goldfinger was actually included in the list I didn't mention: Top 10 Original Movie Scores (http://www.cnn.com/2007/SHOWBIZ/Movies/08/22/top10.scores/) I glanced at this list and saw that it was all male composers.

    If I were going to edit that list, I would include Aimee Mann Magnolia, and The Roches Crossing Delancey.

    I also agree, btw, with 9 to 5 for comedy.

    fairly butch's picture

    nobody does it better....

    ....apart from Paul McCartney & Wings' "Live And Let Die", which would be my pick for number 4 (action/adventure). 

    and you gotta love Dolly Parton - anybody who can say "it's just as well i was born a woman, or i'd be a drag queen" and still survive in the country music industry gets my vote every time!

     re Coal Miner's Daughter, i remember seeing that as a double feature with 'Fame' back in 1980 or so (i know, i know - i could be your mother, which believe me, freaks me out far more than it freaks you out). 

    peeking's picture

    How

    about "Up Where We Belong" from  Office and a Gentleman?  Good for  sweeping the object of your affection off her feet and carrying her...somewheres.  Also, lookat those Mom Jeans on Thelma and Louise...I'm just sayin.
    Elvis730's picture

    9 to 5

    I luved that movie!!! and I love that song! how could you not?

    I too luved the Goldfinger bond song out of all of them...but mostly coz I luv Shirley Bassey's voice

    If I were making this list I would have had 'Jailhouse Rock' for the musical/drama catagory....ok so maybe that wasnt a real catagory...but....I dont care it's my list damn it!

    Elvis Rocks My Socks!

    4meAfterD's picture

    No Bette?

    What about "Wind beneath my wings?"  I loved Beaches and I still love that song, I cry during that scene every time.
    notl33t's picture

    Indie?

    To be a truly indie song, wouldn't the singer have actually written the song as opposed to ripping off lyrics from Tears for Fears? I totally agree with your pick instead, Ace14.
    Muriel le Champignon's picture

    Can I make up my own category?

    How about the Queer Movie Category? This is afterellen.com, after all.

    For gay movie I nominate "The Wings" from Brokeback Mountain. It was the first song I ever learned to play on the guitar. I watched the movie and the song was so beautiful that I set out to find the tab and learn it. It's just so haunting. The other day i was playing it, and although she hadn't seen Brokeback in over a year, my mom still recognized it and then hummed it for the rest of the day. Gustavo Santaolalla deserved his Oscar win for the score of that movie 100%.

    And for lesbian movie subsection, I nominate "A Little Respect" from D.E.B.S. Yes, I know there are lesbian movies out there that are much more serious and ground-breaking, but I simply cannot resist Jordana Brewster as Lucy Diamond lip-synching a silly 80's song in order to get back the girl she loves.

    Plus I love D.E.B.S. A lot.



    User login

    Recent comments

    After Ellen home page on logo online