News, Reviews & Commentary on Lesbian and Bisexual women in Entertainment and the Media

6 women directors and their groundbreaking movies

It seems to be a great time for women directors. They're currently earning critical and/or commercial success (e.g., Kasi Lemmons' Talk to Me and Sarah Polley's Away From Her). Not surprisingly, this celebration is accompanied by analysis of how little has actually changed. Women still have disproportionately few directing opportunities outside the realm of independent movies. As Terry Lawler, the executive director of New York Women in Film & Television, noted:

"While it's wonderful to see all these women getting recognition, we have had these moments before where a door seems to open, and then it turns out that the door doesn't lead anywhere."

And Academy Award–nominated director Jane Campion recently voiced a similar analysis (basically, "Men control all the money").

The subject is frustrating, but it warrants regular revisiting if things are ever going to change. And I'll do the one thing I can do: recognize some of the great women directors and their stereotype-shattering, groundbreaking movies. This list is far from exhaustive and does not include lesbian directors of lesbian movies. So please don't yell at me for excluding Angela Robinson and Rose Troche.

6. Ida Lupino, Not Wanted (1949)

Best known as a B-movie actress from the 1940s, Ida Lupino was also a prolific writer and director. She had already expanded from acting into production when the director of Not Wanted (aka Shame and Streets of Sin — how good does that sound?!) suffered a heart attack on the third day of filming. She took over as director and went on to a lengthy career in movie and television direction — including two episodes of Gilligan's Island!

5. Barbara Kopple, Harlan County USA (1976)

Barbara Kopple, one of the few women directors in the 1970s, won the Best Documentary Feature Oscar for her first movie, Harlan County USA. The film told the story of the 1974 coal miner strike in Harlan County, Ky. She won a second Best Documentary Feature Oscar for 1990's American Dream. Kopple has continued to direct documentaries and television (including Homicide: Life on the Street and OZ). Most recently, she directed Shut Up and Sing, the Dixie Chicks documentary that led me to road-trip to Nashville to see them in concert.

4. Penny Marshall, Awakenings (1990)

I'll repeat the question that others have asked before: How does a movie get nominations for Best Picture, Best Actor in a Leading Role and Best Adapted Screenplay and not get a Best Director nomination? Does the movie magically make itself? I'm not a huge fan of Awakenings, but I recognize that Penny Marshall is responsible for one of the most critically acclaimed movies of 1990. It would be nice if the Academy had recognized that as well.

3. Mimi Leder, The Peacemaker (1997) and Deep Impact (1998)

An Emmy-winning director for ER, Mimi Leder is notable for her direction of two commercially successful action-thrillers in the late 1990s, The Peacemaker and Deep Impact. Leder is credited with disproving the stereotype that women only make "women's movies." Unfortunately, she followed these successes with Pay It Forward. Blech!

2. Kimberly Peirce, Boys Don't Cry (1999)

I know I said I wasn't celebrating lesbian directors here, but Hillary Swank won Best Actress in a Leading Role for Boys Don't Cry, and I simply must venerate Kimberly Peirce for just a moment. I have no choice in the matter. Boys Don't Cry was both critically and commercially successful. It grossed 11.5 million dollars, which is pretty amazing for a story about a murdered transgender teenager. The supporting cast of Chloe Sevigny and Peter Sarsgaard certainly helped, but Kimberly Peirce deserves major credit for directing such an utterly compelling movie.

1. Sofia Coppola, Lost in Translation (2003)

Sofia Coppola was only the third woman and the first American woman to be nominated for a Best Director Oscar. Had Lost in Translation not coincided with the end of the Lord of the Rings trilogy, she likely would have won. It's easy to downplay Coppola's accomplishments as nepotism. But she's amazing because of her extraordinary professional redemption: Her performance in 1990's The Godfather: Part III was universally panned, yet she came back to direct what was arguably the most critically acclaimed movie of 2003.

  • Ace14's blog
  • Login or register to post comments
  • abzug's picture

    I think you're onto something here

    With your point about Penny Marshall.  At the risk of making a really broad generalization, it seems like male directors get credit as auteurs, while female directors are just keeping the trains running on time and so the other artists working for them (writers, actors etc) get more credit.  Perhaps its a reflection with our societal discomfort with female leaders: we're at the point where we'll let them be in charge every once in a while, but damned if we'll give them credit for anything they do when they're in charge!

    The acclaim that Sophia Copolla or Sarah Polley have received more recently seems like the beginnings of a shift, but they're not working on studio films, so I'm wondering if that difference is the key.  It's ok for a woman to be in charge on a small little independent project, kind of akin to a stay-at-home mom running a business from home, as opposed to a woman running a Fortune 500 company and getting credit for making said business successful/profitable/whatever.

    --abzug

    Visit http://www.badgirlsannex.com!

    newbie's picture

    Great examples..

    Being the sort of person who occasionly goes to the movies but is addicted to Netflix, I have to say that I do not look at the director’s sex, or name for that matter. Unless I am completely overwhelmed by two or more of their films (Almodovar, Eastwood, Coppola, etc.). Content, actor and assumed quality, is what pulls me out of my backyard garden or kayak to the movie theater or leads me to add a specific film to my queue. That and a trusted recommendation. My opinion, and it’s just an opinion, maybe we focus too much on the gender and not on the quality.  Women filmmakers have come a lonnnnggg way, granted. They’re doing what they love and some are outstanding.  And sometimes they hit it right on the nail. Just like a few of the guys.  It’s the law of averages in my book.  Hence the quandary of the minority.
    thanks, Ace!

    betsyforgets's picture

    Marina De Van

    Marina De Van was Francois Ozon's screenwriter for many of his earlier films.  This includes "8 women" (8 femmes) which is incredibly gay, and incredibly amazing. She made her first feature length film "In my skin" (Dans ma peau) a few years ago.  It's about a women's self destruction and objectification of herself.  It's really powerful and completely horrifying.  It's groundbreaking to say the least.  In the screening I went to many people actually left before the film ended.  It's not for the faint of heart.  It's really an amazing film, and worth seeing. I thought it was absolutely brilliant, not as a first feature film, but simply as a film.  Those are my two cents. 

    tarrabbit's picture

    GREAT list and...

    kudos to you Ace for selecting female directors with work that is wide and varied instead of genre specific and limited. we're all sisters of the universe and therefore should show support.


    User login

    Recent comments

    After Ellen home page on logo online