Welcome to AfterEllen.com!

Enter your AfterEllen.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Lesbian and Bisexual women in Entertainment and the Media

Peppermint Patty's personal pilgrimage

Here's a list you thought you'd never see: 17 Memorable Thanksgiving Television Moments. I mean, who can think of 3, let alone 17?

At least they started with the best: A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving. In case you missed it Monday night (or, gasp, have never seen it), let me hit some of the highlights for you.

Peppermint PattySo the basic plot is that Peppermint Patty calls Charlie Brown and pretty much invites herself over for Thanksgiving. She also seems to flirt with him, calling him "Chuck" and talking about "dates."

But even in a two-dimensional story like this one, there can be a poignant layer of subtext. Consider these, the 7.5 Memorable Lesbian-ish Moments of A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving:

1. Having muscled her way into an invitation, Peppermint Patty quickly calls back and tells Charlie Brown that "that great kid Marcie" is also free for dinner. Not such a cozy date now, is it, Chuck?

2. P-Patty refers to herself as "brusque and rough" and claims she doesn't know "how to behave outside of a baseball game." Consequently, she makes Marcie apologize to Charlie Brown for the whole crashing-the-party thing. Ah, the civilizing force of the love of a good woman.

Peppermint Patty the Pitcher

3. Marcie looks meaningfully at the camera (think Jim in The Office) when Peppermint Patty says all that stuff about being brusque and rough. She is Marcie B. Toklas to Peppermint Patty Stein.

Peppermint Patty scowls4. P-Patty's wardrobe and hair. Come ON.

5. When P-Patty scowls about the substandard fare, she even intimidates Snoopy. And that's no small feat: I mean, that beagle can win a fistfight with a folding chair and play ping-pong by himself!

6. When the bookish Marcie's intellect fails her, P-Patty quickly steps in and leads the group in a rousing rendition of "Over the River and Through the Woods." And I think you know where she's going with that.

Peppermint PattyMarcie

7. Only Marcie is allowed to call P-Patty "Priscilla" (which harks back to Linus's reference to Priscilla Mullins and John Alden, two love-struck pilgrims). Marcie even throws in an actual "nudge, nudge" with her elbow as she does so.

7.5 Woodstock puts Snoopy's ear in the toaster. No, that's not lesbian-ish: It's just comedy gold.

Really, with all of this hinting, we ought to be annoyed that Patty and Marcie were so closeted. But it was a cartoon in 1973, so everything I've just said makes about as much sense as Chuck's grandma does when she talks on the phone: "Wuaah wuaah wuooah, wuh wuoaah wuahh."

  • scribegrrrl's blog
  • Login or register to post comments
  • ice cream's picture

    I have a tatoo of Peppermint Patty on my lfet arm. It is very personal for me. She always fell asleep in school. Did not do well in math and lived for her art and gym classes.
    Also her devotion to Marcie...

    When I went away to college, my mother always sent me cut outs of the Peppermint Paty stories from the Peanuts comics.

    I'm so happy to see Peppermint Patty on this site.

    ice cream's picture

    Props to Chas S. The fact that he had lesbians and a black kid in 1973 is genius.

    ice cream's picture

    Good grief. This is like the Enid Blyton's Noddy and what's his name supposed gay relationship and the Smurf-communism thing.

    ice cream's picture

    Big Ears - Noddy and Big Ears.

    ice cream's picture

    Well, Charles Schulz was good friends with Billie Jean King, Supposedly, in one of the strips, Peppermint Patty asks Marcie, "Has anyone ever told you that when you're mad, you look just like Billie Jean King?"

    ice cream's picture

    Has anyone seen the Saturday Night Live Charlie Brown Xmas special? The one where they transform something into something better like a pathetic little runt of a tree into a glorious Xmas tree with all the trimmings and then turn these two girls playing baseball into lesbians? At the end they were like, "goodbye XMas Tree... goodbye lesbians." lol

    ice cream's picture

    I'd forgotten about Peppermint Patty being such a big lez. Excellent.

    ice cream's picture

    AfterEllen recounts the evidence of Peppermint Patty's Sapphic tendencies...

    http://logo-blogs.com/afterellen/2006/11/21/peppermint-patty-her-personal-pilgrimage/......

    trent bowie's picture

    Awww, Peperminy Patty and Marcie

    I always thought those two were so sweet...:) Who else noticed the Jock/Geek dynamic that worked so well? Hey, it's a pre-fab Xenaverse Uber Pair! Sweet.
    angel winters's picture

    Marcie and peppermint patty

    lets see the lady like Marcie and the tomboy p-patty ...pre xenaverse uber jock/geek pair.....I so agree...I swear its because of this pairing...I was so prime to love xena/gabby pairing from the beginning not to mention to be a jock/geek myself and as a kid p-patty, was one of the best examples on how to be a kid growing up...bad for my parents...great for me.
    fairly butch's picture

    minty fresh!

    fame at last! 

    what's not to love about a gal who obviously wears Birkenstocks and plays baseball?  and although she tries to fool people with her half-assed pursuit of Charlie Brown, we all know she's only doing it to make Marcie jealous....such drama!  definitely a dyke-in-training: her toaster oven is in the post.

    and shouldn't she be on Alice's chart???

    machinefr's picture

    this is awesome!!! peanuts =

    this is awesome!!! peanuts = love