| **warning
to non-US readers: L Word finale spoilers**
It
seems like just the other day that I was sitting
in front of my television in that semi-vegetative state
watching one of those sexy L
Word promos and waiting anxiously for the first
episode to premiere, and now it's all over (the first season,
at least).
Since
it premiered in January, the show has drawn legions of fans
and detractors within its broad cross-section of straight,
gay, male and female viewers. Even while we are grateful
to have such a series to argue over in the first place,
with the burden of representing a very invisible and very
diverse community on its shoulders, the series was destined
to provoke diverse opinions about what does and does not
work.
By
and large, I liked the characters, and was glad
to see lesbians portrayed as something other than truck
drivers or criminals. I also found the acting very sensitive
and engaging, particularly performances from Mia
Kirshner as the conflicted Jenny, and Leisha
Haley as the quick-witted and always-endearing Alice.
I
also gave the show brownie points for featuring Jennifer
Beals as biracial museum director Bette Porter, one
of the most consistently captivating characters on the show.
Before the series began, Beals and creator/executive producer
Ilene Chaiken communicated in countless interviews their
intention to explore the tricky intersections of race and
sexuality, and as a multiracial woman myself, I eagerly
awaited these plotlines.
Fortunately,
I didn’t have to wait long. In the pilot,
Bette and long-time white partner Tina (Laurel
Holloman) are going to therapy in preparation for starting
a family. They are desperately trying to find a perfect
donor, and conflict arises when Bette selects a black donor
because Tina believes “That’s a lot of otherness
to put on one child.” True, but it doesn’t make
the reaction any less problematic.
The
couple seems to get over this speed bump and Tina becomes
pregnant by the black donor. They continue to go to couple’s
therapy, where Bette encounters Yolanda, the living embodiment
of The Angry Black Woman. Yolanda launches into Bette for
passing and not “coming out” as a black woman,
a scenario that seemed contrived at best, and a negative
reinforcement of black stereotypes at worst.
Many
viewers had already chosen to overlook the fact that of
Bette and Kit (Pam Grier), the bi-racial (half-white) sister
was the successful one and the black sister was the deadbeat
mom-alcoholic-entertainer. But it was impossible to ignore
the fact that the character of Yolanda was two-dimensional,
disturbing, and even embarrassing to black viewers of the
show who, up until this point, had not seen a non-bi-racial
black lesbian portrayed on the show.
Granted,
we all know a Yolanda – but did she need to be the
first black lesbian character on a show trying to make invisible
communities visible and shatter stereotypes about them?
While
we can support Bette for advocating that she will not identify
as exclusively black any more than she would choose to be
exclusively white, as Kit pointed out to her in the very
first episode, Bette lets people see what they want to see,
and by her lifestyle and her appearance, she most likely
and conveniently will be seen as white. No wonder her girlfriend,
Tina, sometimes forgets, and doesn’t understand why
Bette gets so riled up about Yolanda’s attacks on
her racial identification.
Therapy
does end up being good for one thing: Bette begins
to wonder if she’s falling out of love, which
sets the stage for her affair with Candace Jewel (Ion Overman).
When Bette and Tina lose the baby, and Bette ends up at
one of Kit’s shows solo while Tina grieves at home,
the stage is set for infidelity. Bette runs into, of all
people, Yolanda, whose ex-girlfriend, Candace catches her
eye; Bette checks her out, as do we. Candace, a carpenter
by trade, is beautiful and mysterious. Even some of the
other characters notice their chemistry: the pimp/playa/entertainer
Slim Daddy (yet another stereotypical black character, played
by Snoop Dogg) expresses to Bette that she and Candace have
that “basic instinct” together.
Bette
invites Candace to bid on installing an art show, Provocations,
which has been landing her in hot water, and despite Candace
being the most expensive, she gets hired (surprise, surprise).
But Candace is picking up on the vibes Bette has been sending
out, and is not only surprised to find out she has a girlfriend,
but also finds that she won’t be able to sleep if
she doesn’t tell Bette, “all I’ve wanted
to do all day long is kiss you…please tell me if you
don’t want me to.” Bette doesn’t say a
word, and probably the hottest kiss of the season ensues.
Bette
is overwhelmed, and continues to be as the two complete
the Provocations job together. But there’s a protest
at the gallery, and when Candace and Bette land up in jail
– in the same jail cell – for getting into a
scuffle with protesters, we are treated to one of the quirkiest
and sexiest scenes of the season. The two women, breathtakingly,
consummate their relationship without even touching each
other; for Bette, a wall is enough.
And
then comes the season finale, in which Candace and Bette
share a steamy sex scene, Tina figures it out, and Bette
and Tina engage in violence-laced sex before Tina leaves
her to temporarily move in with Alice.
But
where does that leave Bette and Candace? And more
importantly, where does that leave representation of women
of color on The L Word next season? Candace
has been one of the few positive representations of black
lesbians on the series (even if racially, Ion Overman is
difficult to read: she has been claimed and championed by
bi-racial/multiracial, Hispanic and African-American lesbians
alike). Candace also is the least “lipstick”
of the cast, sporting androgynously sexy overalls at work,
but appearing stunningly femme with those magnificent cheekbones
in her first and last encounters with Bette.
Candace
is also college educated, an entrepreneur, and an activist
(she has done abortion clinic defense, while Bette just
funds it); she is confident and articulate, and the only
character on the show so far to “top” Bette,
both verbally and physically. Bette becomes completely dismantled
in Candace’s presence, and we get the sense that Candace
is the one character (apart from the psychiatrist) who doesn’t
buy into all of Bette’s endless verbal dances around
what she is actually feeling. With a look, it seems, Candace
sees through Bette’s game and shuts it down.
Candace and Bette shared only a couple of hasty flings,
but they left many fans salivating for more--one need only
look to the Showtime message boards to hear the parade of
questions from her fans, eager to know more about her background:
her upbringing, her college, her coming out story, her sexual
history, her own class, racial, sexual and gender identifications.
It
also left many women of color wondering: who else will be
there to represent them if Candace does not return for Season
2?
The
L Word has had its hands
full trying to tell a number of stories, and address a number
of issues in a community which is tremendously diverse.
I applaud the writers for what they have accomplished under
such pressure and scrutiny, and for the ground they have
laid, but it's important that they improve the visibility
of lesbians of color on the series.
With
Ion Overman and the character of Candace, there is a possibility
not only of more fully developing another three-dimensional
lesbian of color on television, but really engaging on the
issues of race and class with the character of Bette, and
portraying, if only briefly (since Beals and Chaiken seem
invested in Bette and Tina’s relationship), a relationship
between two lesbians of color. Los Angeles is a city with
staggering Hispanic population, and a thriving black lesbian
community, so there seem to be no credible excuses for not
having another one in the cast. And in the mind of this
author and many other viewers, that character should be
Candace Jewel.
|