All
My Children's resident lesbian character, Bianca (Eden
Riegel), has had a tough time of it in the last few months:
just days after she finally got a girlfriend, Lena (Olga Sosnovska)
and the two shared their first (and only) kiss, Bianca was
raped and subsequently discovered she was pregnant, while
Lena tried to commit suicide. In the process, Lena and Bianca's
relationship fell apart (the two women have rarely even been
in the same room together in the last few months), while Bianca's
friendship with best-friend Maggie (Elizabeth Hendrickson)
is suddenly front-and-center again.
This
series of tragic events in Bianca's life has conveniently
saved All My Children from having to deal with the
controversial aspects of featuring a lesbian relationship
on the show. Since admitting that in fact, they're not
willing to treat Bianca and Lena just like every other couple
on the show, and that the much-hyped "first lesbian kiss
on daytime" was primarily a ratings stunt, would undermine
the "we're so progressive" drumbeat they've been
sounding so proudly since Bianca and Lena shared their first
(and only) on-screen kiss almost six months ago, AMC is doing
everything possible to put off the inevitable moment when
they will have to either give Bianca's relationships equal
treatment, or acknowledge the double-standard.
Bianca's
pregnancy also represents a step backwards in the development
of her character, since it almost assures her continued asexuality
in the near future. The pregnant-lesbian storyline is a favorite
refuge for TV writers who both want to avoid dealing with
the sexual aspects of lesbian relationships and who want to
"normalize" the lesbian characters--to show viewers
that, at their core, lesbians are just like heterosexual women
(who of course, all want to be mothers).
Not
that the last few months haven't seen a few positive
developments on All My Children. Eden Riegel has
played her role to great effect; although many viewers
vehemently dislike the direction her character has taken,
Riegel's performance has been almost universally praised (as
has Sosnovska's performance, despite the limited screen time
she's been given).
The
fact that Bianca's friendship with Maggie has been given more
screen time has made BAM (Bianca-and-Maggie) fans happy, as
well, and given new life to the character of Maggie, who was
languishing in her previous storyline with former boyfriend
Henry. It's a nice reward for all the fans of Bianca and Maggie
who've waited patiently to see them together again.
But
Bianca's renewed (platonic) friendship with Maggie has supplanted
Bianca's relationship with Lena, as Maggie and Bianca make
plans to share an apartment together, go away together for
the last stages of Bianca's pregnancy (although this is unlikely
to actually happenp), and even raise the baby together--activities
that are usually shared by couples.
Reinforcing
the confusion between Bianca's relationship with Maggie and
Bianca's relationship with Lena is the fact that recent dialogue
between Bianca and Maggie seems to imply there may be something
more behind her desire to help Bianca than simply friendship.
When Bianca's mom, Erica (Susan Lucci), questions Bianca and
Maggie about this news, Maggie tells her "don’t
worry, we’re gonna take care of each other" and
when Bianca questions Maggie's decision to take a leave of
absence from college to help Bianca with the pregnancy, Maggie
tells her "did it ever occur to you that I wanna be with
you?” Maggie even throws in an "I love you"
for good measure.
Compare
these to Lena's statements to Bianca in the same
week: "whatever it is that you’re afraid to tell
me, we’ll deal with it together," followed by "this
feels so right. You and me, together, talking again,"
and "just remember that I love you."
Even
the soap magazines are contributing to the confusion. Soaps
In Depth recently put Bianca and Maggie on the cover of an
October issue previewing November storylines with the caption
"Together At Last!" even though the actual article
does not address the possibility of a romantic relationship
between the two. Around the same time, Soap Opera Weekly included
a pinup poster of Bianca and Lena in their magazine--the first
ever pinup of a lesbian couple in a soap magazine.
For
lesbians on All My Children, friendship appears to
be an acceptable substitute for romance--not that there is
much difference between friendship and romance for Bianca
in the first place. Bianca's romantic relationship with Lena
(for the two or three days it lasted) looked almost exactly
like her current platonic friendship with Maggie. While it
is certainly okay and even a positive development that Bianca
and Maggie are spending more time together, their friendship
is looking more and more like a romantic relationship without
actually being one.
If
the Maggie-Bianca relationship is heading down a path towards
romance, then all of this buildup is fine; if AMC has no intention
of having Maggie come out, however, then it just feels like
exploitation.
AMC
has stated in the past that Maggie is straight (when Bianca
confessed her feelings to Maggie in January 2003, Maggie's
response was "I love you...but I'm into guys"),
and there is no official indication so far that they have
changed their position on this. As long as they insist on
maintaining Maggie's heterosexuality and keeping Lena at bay,
the innuendo and long looks between Maggie and Bianca--and
Bianca and Lena--seem like nothing more than a blatant attempt
to have it both ways: keep lesbian viewers watching by dangling
the possibility of a lesbian relationship, while always ensuring
it is just out of reach.
Viewers
may prefer one pairing over the other, and that's simply a
matter of personal taste, but the point is that All My
Children is continually hinting at both and following
through on neither.
Ultimately,
this means all Bianca fans, whether they're rooting
for a Maggie-Bianca pairing or a Lena-Bianca one, will end
up disappointed. All My Children needs to develop
a relationship between Maggie and Bianca, or stop writing
dialogue between the two that sounds like a love poem; at
the same time, they need to either rekindle Lena and Bianca's
romance, or stop pretending they're going to.
Soap
operas are all about teasing, of course, and couples are continually
brought together and pulled apart as various obstacles are
placed in their path to relationship bliss. On-and-off relationships
are what keeps viewers tuning in.
But
the permanent position for Bianca's relationships seem to
be "off," and this, combined with the fact that
there aren't any other lesbian relationships to offset Bianca's,
is where the double-standard arises. For every straight couple
on AMC that is wrenched apart, there is almost always another
straight couple proclaiming their undying love for each other
in the same episode (usually before locking in a steamy embrace).
For
every lesbian couple that's pulled apart, there's...well,
nothing else. And even when they are together, the lesbians
are only allowed to hold hands.
The
rumors seem to indicate that Maggie will eventually orchestrate
a reunion between Lena and Bianca--but not for awhile. Now
that Bianca is having a child, her storyline over the next
several months is likely to revolve around the pregnancy
and the mystery of who murdered Michael Cambias, neither
of which leaves much room for a romantic relationship between
Bianca and Lena. And since the writers seem determined not
to develop a romantic relationship between Maggie and Bianca,
that leaves Bianca with no one. Again.
Which
means All My Children will continue to promise
much and deliver little when it comes to its lesbian characters,
hoping that lesbian viewers won't be able to tell the difference
between friendship and romance, or will be so grateful for
any lesbian storyline at all that they won't care that it's
full of tragedy and relationships that never go anywhere.
That might work for a little while, but lesbian viewers
have too many options on TV now to settle for this for long.
Eventually, AMC will have to follow through on its promise
of a lesbian relationship if it wants to keep viewers from
following Bianca and Maggie's lead and leaving Pine Valley
for greener pastures.