Find Articles On:
 TV Shows:
 Movies:
 People:
 Extras:

Review of Broken Flowers
by Gregg Shapiro, August 17, 2005
Broken Flowers poster Jessica Lange as Carmen Chloe Sevigny as Carmen's assistant and lover Sharon Stone as Laura

warning: spoilers

Sophia Coppola’s acclaimed sophomore feature Lost In Translation forever changed my opinion of Bill Murray. Before that, in spite of notable work in The Royal Tennenbaums, Rushmore, and even, to some degree, Groundhog Day, I couldn’t watch him in anything without thinking of his trademark obnoxious comedic style which involved smug mugging for the camera, as in Stripes, Meatballs, and the list goes on.

With Broken Flowers, written and directed by influential indie-film god Jim Jarmusch, Murray not only continues this admirable acting streak, but blossoms in new and unexpected ways. As well-to-do software mogul Don Johnston, with a “t,” a name that not only earns him a few snickers from strangers (as in “You’re Don Johnson?”), but also fits as a label for his Don Juan, love-‘em-and-leave-‘em persona and reputation, Murray is an unlikely stud.

But he embarks on a journey of self-discovery after receiving an anonymous hand-addressed but typewritten letter from an old flame, just as his current flame Sherry (Julie Delpy) is leaving him, informing him on her way out that a nineteen year old son he didn’t know existed is on a quest to find him (shades of The Life Aquatic).

With the aid of next door neighbor Winston (the always amazing Jeffrey Wright of Angels In America fame), an amateur sleuth and father of a considerable brood, Don sets off on a trip in which he plans to arrive unannounced at the homes of four of the five women with whom he was involved twenty years earlier (the fifth is deceased) to determine the source of the letter.

First stop is the home of Laura (Sharon Stone), a blonde bombshell and race car driver widow whose aptly named teenage daughter Lolita (Alexis Dziena) goes out of her way to live up to her namesake. Stone’s comedic chops are in good shape and her scenes with Murray are memorable, amusing and touching.

After determining that Laura is not the mother of his son, Don’s next stop is the home of childless Dora (Frances Conroy), one half of a successful real estate team with husband Ron (Christopher McDonald). Murray’s craggy but expressive face is put to good use in this scene as it contains a minimum of dialogue, although neither Murray nor Conroy need to speak to get their meanings across.

In what is the movie’s subtlest, and queerest touch, Don meets with ex-girlfriend (and animal communicator) Carmen (Jessica Lange). Used to having women, even exes, still react to him in a passionate manner, Don is frustrated at the wall Carmen constructs between them. Even Carmen’s assistant (Chloe Sevigny) is not taken in by him. Following a tense conversation in her office, Carmen walks Don to his car, where her assistant, comes to fetch her and remind her of her next appointment.

After whispering something in Carmen’s ear, her assistant’s hand slides down to Carmen’s side, her hip and then brushes her thigh, revealing to Don, and the audience, why he is powerless with these two women.

His final visit, the one that holds the most promise, is to the ramshackle mountain home of Penny (an almost unrecognizable Tilda Swinton), who is none too glad to see Don. In fact, one of her male companions works done over pretty good. Returning home, Don appears defeated until he spies a kid (Mark Webber) he thinks might be his itinerant son at the airport, and then again later in town.

These scenes, which are some of the film’s funniest and most emotional, take the viewer to yet another level of intrigue, allowing the experience to continue to bloom in the most entertaining and fragrant ways.

Get Broken Flowers on DVD

NOTE: AfterEllen.com is not affiliated with Ellen DeGeneres or The L Word
Thoughts? Feedback?
comments@afterellen.com
Copyright © 2006 AfterEllen.com