If
you watched The Late Show with
David Letterman this week you would have seen a truly remarkable
thing: an out lesbian comic doing a stand-up routine about her
girlfriend on prime time network television.
A
little after midnight on Tuesday night, March 18th, stand-in host
Tom Sizemore (Letterman was out with an injury) introduced comedian
Suzanne Westenhoefer,
who almost immediately launched into a routine that began with
"my girlfriend and I have been together for ten years, and
we have absolutely nothing in common."
She
then proceeded to riff on a variety of topics, including how her
girlfriend is a closeted eighth-grade English teacher who always
returns Suzanne's love notes with grammar corrections; how she's
surprised her mom lets her and her girlfriend sleep in the same
bed together when they visit because "we never let her and
my stepfather sleep in the same bed when they visit us...we
have very impressionable animals!"; and how the (straight)
cruise director on the all-lesbian cruise never "gets it"
and continues to say "ladies and gent--oops" over the
loudspeaker.
Westenhoefer
was laid-back and funny, and the audience responded well to her
performance. In this regard it all seems fairly standard, just
what you'd expect from a comic good enough to land a spot on one
of the top late-night shows...except that there was nothing standard
about it.
In
fact, this non-event was actually was on a clear indication
of the progress we've made in increasing and
improving lesbian visibility in recent years. I can't imagine
turning on the television even five years ago and seeing a publicly-identified
lesbian talking so matter-of-factly about writing love letters
to her girlfriend. For the first time, lesbian viewers were able
to turn on a late night talk show and see a stand-up routine that
explicitly and unabashedly included us.
Besides
the mere fact that she was on the show in the first place, the
significance of Westenhoefer's performance was that it assumed
an audience that was lesbian-friendly. There was no attempt to
skirt the topic, or to introduce the subject into the conversation
gradually--Westenhoefer made it clear from her opening line that
she was gay and then proceeded as if this information was not
at all unusual.
In short, she assumed lesbianism was no big deal to the majority
of Americans--and the audience seemed to agree, laughing loudly
at many of her jokes and clapping enthusiastically when she finished.
Suzanne
Westenhoefer has been doing stand-up for a long time
now. I first saw her perform in 1995 at my college; she was a
big hit with the packed audience of lesbian, bisexual, and straight
women then, and she has gone on to do several sold-out tours around
the country since then.
But
it is only recently that Westenhoefer has started to get broad
national attention. This is partly because she has worked long
and hard to get it, and partly because of the increase in lesbian
visibility in the media in the last five years. From lesbian characters
on sitcoms and dramas to lesbian issues highlighted on news magazine
shows like Prime Time Live and The Barbara Walters
Special to lesbian characters on daytime television, television
is now much more hospitable to a lesbian stand-up routine than
it was even a few years ago.
Other
lesbian comics have paved the way as well, of
course. Lea Delaria has done a number of guest-spots on
TV (on shows like Ellen and Friends) and in
movies (The First Wives Club), and Kate Clinton has had
several appearances on talk shows like Good Morning America,
the Rosie O'Donnell Show, and Nightline. Marga Gomez
has also had modest success in mainstream venues, with small parts
in Batman and Sphere.
Ellen
Degeneres did her now-famous "conversation with God"
stand-up routine on The Tonight Show in 1986 (becoming
the first female comedian to be asked to sit with Carson following
her first appearance), but her stand-up routines never contained
explicitly lesbian content. She wasn't out then, either, and although
Degeneres has made numerous guest appearances on talk shows since
coming out publicly, the appearances were to promote her television
show and did not generally include a stand-up performance (and
her stand-up routines still never include much lesbian-specific
content).
Although
this is her first exposure to a national audience on
network TV during prime time, Letterman
is not Westenhoefer's first television appearance--that was in
a 1991 episode of Sally Jesse Raphael entitled
"Breaking the Lesbian Stereotype...Lesbians Who Don't Look
Like Lesbians."
Westenhoefer
went on to become the first openly gay comic to host her own
HBO Comedy Special in 1994, which also included very specific
references to lesbians and lesbianism. Most recently, she played
a straight woman in the 2002 romantic lesbian comedy A Family
Affair, which also stars Helen
Lesnick, Michele Green, and Erica Shaffer.
Like
Clinton, Delaria, and Gomez, Westenhoefer has
refused to subvert her sexuality in public and in fact always
discusses it very candidly in her act--although the majority of
the audience for her stand-up routines are lesbians, so that is
not exactly risky (although it was at one time, when Westenhoefer
was first starting out). But the fact that she was able to successfully
present the same routine to the largely heterosexual
audience on Letterman is ground-breaking--partly
because it was framed as just another comedy routine.
Westenhoefer's
identification as a lipstick lesbian may account for some of her
mainstream commercial success over other out lesbian comedians,
since television and film have always preferred conventionally
feminine lesbians over more "masculine" ones since the
former are perceived as less of a visual threat to traditional
notions of what it means to be a woman. But if Westenhoefer wasn't
a talented comedian she wouldn't even be in the consideration
set, and her increasing popularity is a sign that television is
moving in the right direction in terms of improving lesbian visibility.
This
won't trigger a tidal-wave of change--it's
not like we're suddenly going to see out lesbian comics doing
stand-up routines about lesbians every other night on prime time
television, and Westenhoefer's not going to become a household
name by this time next year. But it is a historic moment,
both for Westenhoefer's career and for lesbian visibility on television,
and worth reflecting on before it gets lost in the shuffle of
just another "first" for lesbians on television.
Read
our interview
with Suzanne, or check out her official
site